Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Aug. 10, 2023

Andre Rand and the Legend of Cropsey

Andre Rand and the Legend of Cropsey
Andre Rand and the Legend of Cropsey
10 Minute Murder
Andre Rand and the Legend of Cropsey

It’s the 1970s and we’re in Staten Island. Islanders have embraced that 70s laid back lifestyle and children are given lots of freedom: they roam the streets freely, running errands or playing until the streetlights come on.
Fast forward ten years,...

It’s the 1970s and we’re in Staten Island. Islanders have embraced that 70s laid back lifestyle and children are given lots of freedom: they roam the streets freely, running errands or playing until the streetlights come on.
Fast forward ten years, children are scared to leave their yards and parents anxiously scan the newspaper for any new disappearances.
What’s changed?
The emergence of a peculiar and disturbing man by the name of Andre Rand.

SUBSCRIBE
to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.

10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com

HelloFresh FREE Shipping and 50% OFF:
hellofresh.com/10minmurder50

(enter code: 10MinMurder50)

Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder

Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder



This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement

0:13 Discretion is advised. This is ten minuted murder. It's the nineteen seventies and we're in Staten Island. Islanders have embraced that seventies laid back lifestyle, and children are given lots of freedom. They roam the streets freely, running errands or playing until the street lights come on. Fast forward ten years later, children are scared to leave their yards and parents anxiously scan the newspaper for any new disappearances. So what's changed the emergence of a peculiar and disturbing man by the name of Andre Rand. Andre Rand was born Frank Russian on March eleventh, nineteen forty four, in Manhattan, New York. He had a relatively peaceful childhood until fourteen, when his father died, and shortly after his mother was admitted to a psychiatric hospital. As he grew older, he began committing petty crimes, and those around him would describe him as getting increasingly peculiar.

1:29 However, our story doesn't begin with andre Rand, but instead with a story of Cropsey. Cropsey was an urban legend about an escaped mental patient who hunted children, taking them into tunnels of abandoned buildings to kill them. The story was originally told around camp fires or by older siblings just having some fun, but it soon took on a new use. Parents began telling it as a cautionary tale against exploring a specific building, Willowbrook State School, and parents had good reasons for this. Willowbrook State School was not a school, but a horrifying mental asylum. To give you an idea of what Willowbrook was like, in nineteen sixty five, Senator Robert F. Kennedy visited Willowbrook and described residents as living in filth and dirt, their clothing in rags, and he described the rooms as quote less comfortable and cheerful than the cages in which we put animals in a zoo. And honestly, that might have been a generous description, because this place was awful, like the stuff of nightmares. The school was extremely understaffed, with about fifty residents for every one Willowbrook attendant, and overcrowded, leading to frequent outbreaks of diseases such as hepatitis. Though Kennedy made some suggestions to improve conditions, little changed until nineteen seventy two, when ABC reporter Heraldo Rivera made headlines with a TV expose on Willowbrook's abuse. That expose

3:00 is available on YouTube, and the footage is truly chilling, but worth watching anyway. The expose led to a national outcry and understandably a few lawsuits. Willowbrook was promptly closed. Before we go on, it's important to note that Willowbrook was built across three hundred seventy five acres of land, so the buildings were all connected by a walkable underground tunnel or tunnels for the staff to get around in the winter. When Willowbrook closed, most of its residents were released into group homes or when to live with their families, but some were left to basically fend for themselves. There are reports of former residents camping in the nearby woods of Willowbrook and even occupying the tunnels themselves. The story of Cropsey evolved to an escaped Willowbrook patient killing his victims in Willowbrook's underground tunnels, and now that it involved a real place, the legend of Cropsey caught fire.

3:54 So Willowbrook shuts down and its grounds are admittedly a bit creepy, but everyone lives happily ever after. Right where there's a bit more to the story. Than that. When Willowbrook was open, they clearly did not do a very thorough background check because from nineteen sixty six to nineteen sixty eight they employed and orderly who went by the name of Brushette. Brushette was simply Frank Russian's alias. When Willowbrook closed, Frank became unemployed, but instead of scrolling through Craigslist because that didn't exist, he found a different, more sinister way to occupy his time. In May of nineteen sixty nine, a passing police car noticed a suspicious looking van in a vacant lot. Upon investigating, they discovered a naked Frank and a nine year old girl. Frank was arrested and charged with attempted rape, serving sixteen months in jail. Upon release, Frank legally changed his name to Andre Rand. And I don't know about you, but if I'm a Staten Island judge and an ex convict slash sex offender who's operated under ATLAS in the past petitions me to change his name, I'd probably say no.

5:03 But that's not how it went down, because in nineteen seventy two, Frank Russian legally became Andre Rand, and this new Andre Rand was not the reformed man that he clearly convinced the courts that he would become. On July seventh, nineteen seventy two, three thirty pm, Alice Pierra was playing with her brother in the lobby of their apartment building. Her brother left her alone for about a minute, and when he returned, she was gone. Andre Rand was working as a painter in that very building and was brought in for questioning, but released because of a lack of evidence connecting him to Alice's disappearance. Alice was five when she disappeared and has never been found, and the disappearances only continued. On a summer day in nineteen eighty one, seven year old Holly Anne Hughes was sent to the store to buy a bar of soap.

5:54 Storekeepers at the Port Richmond Delhi confirmed that Holly bought the soap, but she never made at home. In investigating her disappearance, police discovered that she had been seen talking to Andrea Rand outside the shop. They brought Andre in for questioning, and he admitted to talking to Holly, even that he played hide and seek with her. Other witnesses reported seeing Andre's green Volkswagen circling the Deli that Holly disappeared from. Once again, authorities didn't have enough evidence to hold him, so Andre was released. Despite many searches, Holly has never been found. Okay, so far we have two disappearances that Andre Rand seemed suspiciously connected to. But maybe he was just really in the wrong place at the wrong time. But probably not when you hear what he got up to.

6:43 In nineteen eighty three, just two years after Holly's disappearance, Andre drove a large van into a Staten Island YMCA. Andrea convinced eleven children to get into the van, claiming that he would drive them to a park. He then drove them to the Newark State Airport, where he bought them all Whitecastle burghers. Why he did this is truly a mystery. He claimed he only wanted to take the kids on a fun excursion, and to be fair, he didn't actually harm the children, but still he kidnapped and transported them across state lines without parental consent. Andrea was arrested and the children returned home unscathed. He was given ten months in jail. Just twelve days after he was released, Andrea was on the prowl again. On August fourteenth, nineteen eighty three, Tiahis Jackson disappeared on a short errand to the supermarket. Police investigated, and wouldn't you know it, Andre Rand was a suspect. He had a campsite at a cemetery creepy just a half mile from where Tiahis lived, and Tiahise's mother had reported seeing a man fitting his description lurking around the parking lot. Andrea was questioned, but charges were not filed. Eleven year old Teaheis was never found. So this trend of people going missing and being last seen with Andre Rand continued for several years, most notably with the disappearance of Hank Gafario and Ethel Atwell. As usual, Andrea is taken in for questioning, but there's not enough evidence to connect him to the crime and he walks

8:15 free. However, after years of frustration, the police finally catch a break. On July ninth, nineteen eighty seven, twelve year old Jennifer Schweiger went for a short walk around her neighborhood. She had down syndrome, and when she felt restless, her mother would instruct her to take a walk. On this particular day, though she did not return Her parents called the police, and an investigation and search quickly ramped up. Two eyewitnesses reported seeing Jennifer walking around with a middle aged man in her last known moments. Others reported seeing Andrea's car circling the block that Jennifer was walking on. Andrea was taken in for questioning, but authorities didn't have enough evidence to reach conclusions, so he was released. It wasn't until the thirty fifth day of the search that a volunteer noticed an unusual clumping of dirt and clay. He began digging under that spot and discovered a little foot and then Jennifer's entire body. Her body was buried just one hundred fifty yards from a campsite that belonged to Andre Rand.

9:16 Even worse, her body was found on the grounds of Willowbrooke State School. Finally, authorities had enough evidence and arrested Rand. He was charged with kidnapping and first degree murder. The jury couldn't reach a verdict on the murder charge, but convicted Rand of kidnapping, sentencing him to twenty five years to life in prison. Finally, eighteen years after his reign of terror began, Andre Rand faced significant jailed time, and the families of the victims received some sort of closure and a sense of justice. Andre Rand is still in jail. In two thousand and four, investigators had enough evidence to bring charges on Rand for Holly Anne Hugh's disappearance. As a new witness came forward, investigators pieced together that Andrea had offered Holly candy, pulled her into his car, and drove away. Rand was found guilty of kidnapping and given twenty five years to life. Currently, he's serving time at the Great Meadows Correctional Facility and won't become eligible for parole until he's ninety three years old. So that's the story of Andrea Rand, the man that showed us that often reality can be worse than imagination. More than half a century after his first crime, much is still unknown about him, as he operated in the shadows, darting around tunnels and graveyards, praying on the most vulnerable. Still, one thing is certain.

10:37 He has ensured that the legend of Cropsy will live on and on. That's ten minute Murder for today, brief and binge able true crime. My name is Joe. I'm the host, and I really appreciate you listening. If this is your first time tuning in to Ten Minute Murder, I said, tuning in like like this is a radio. If this is your first time checking out Ten Minute Murder, please subscribe now so that you can catch up on all the back episodes and never miss any of the new ones. Connect with me on social media too. You'll see the visuals that go along with what we're talking about here on the podcast. If you like this episode, there's a place you can rate and review on Apple, Spotify and so many of the other places. Please do that. Your positive feedback is appreciated and it helps this show grow. So, Joe, how was your day today? I appreciate you asking, and I'd love to tell you I had an exciting day. I slipped down in the target parking lot zero out of ten would not recommend. And you know how, when you fall down, you officially know how old you are because the people. If you fall down and people laugh, you're cool. Everything's good. When you fall down and people look concerned, that means you've gotten old. It was a mix of the two when I fell today in the parking lot, So that tracks all right quickly. This email today comes from Robert in Tallahassee. Hi Joe, great podcast. I'm curious. Your audio always sounds so good, unlike many

12:11 other true crime shows I listened to, not Robert throwing shade. What kind of microphone do you use, Robert? It is a Sinheiser mk H four sixteen. And if you don't know anything about microphones, that means nothing to you. That's like another language. But just know that it looks like I'm talking into a giant magic marker. When I first started this podcast, I bought the one that all podcasters seem to use, that Shore SM seven B, and I've had this one that I'm using now four years and years and years from doing voiceovers. But I bought the one that looks like a podcast microphone because I thought, hey, this will make my voice sound more podcasting. I used it on a couple of episodes and I didn't like it, so I sold it and I went back to the microphone that I've been using for a very long time. Well, okayd okay, that's going to do it for this episode today. I'm so glad that you to spend a few minutes of time listening to this podcast. It means the world to me.

13:05 Thank you. For listening to ten minute murder