Frostproof: The Fishing Trip Murders
Frostproof: The Fishing Trip Murders If you popped the hood on Damion Tillman’s little red S-10, you’d find an engine that came out of somebody else’s truck. Damion lived around Frostproof, Florida, a small orange grove town in Polk County with a...
Frostproof: The Fishing Trip Murders
If you popped the hood on Damion Tillman’s little red S-10, you’d find an engine that came out of somebody else’s truck. Damion lived around Frostproof, Florida, a small orange grove town in Polk County with a lake around every bend. His buddies Brandon and Keven spent a Friday afternoon in July fixing the brakes on Brandon’s pickup, and that night they all planned to meet up and fish Lake Streety Road. On the way, Damion stopped at a Dollar General for bug spray and a headlamp. A man he knew was in the store, and a camera caught them talking at the register with no sound. Nobody knows what they said. This episode follows those families from that Friday night all the way to a courtroom in Bartow, with a stop at a McDonald’s drive-through and a truck sitting at a house with no motor in it.
🔔 Subscribe for True Crime Cases multiple times a week
Never miss a story. Subscribe to 10 Minute Murder for bite-sized true crime episodes delivered fresh every week.
Get a weekly email from me about the upcoming cases and more: 10minutemurder.com/newsletter
📱 Follow for Behind-the-Scenes Content Get exclusive case updates, research photos, and sneak peeks of upcoming episodes:
- Instagram: @10minutemurder on IG
- Facebook: 10 Minute Murder on FB
- TikTok: 10 Minute Murder on TikTok
- Rate & Review: Leave a 5-star review to help other true crime fans discover the show
- Share: Send this episode to fellow true crime enthusiasts
- Join the Discussion: Tag us in your episode reactions on social media
Check out True Crime Blueprint, also created and hosted by Joe.
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/43zuDpH01HtdIrH0ShCAid?si=86b2281063334139
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/true-crime-blueprint/id1877878404
iHeartRadio: https://iheart.com/podcast/323307878
Amazon Music/Audible: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/b7d5eaae-9d27-40f9-8efb-6864c2af8055
Deezer: https://www.deezer.com/show/1002664071
Podcast Addict: https://podcastaddict.com/podcast/true-crime-blueprint/6785639
Podchaser: https://www.podchaser.com/podcasts/true-crime-blueprint-6381660
Spreaker: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-blueprint--6879387
Stitcher: https://www.stitcher.com/show/1113943
Pandora: https://www.pandora.com/podcast/true-crime-blueprint/PC:1001113943
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/10-minute-murder-bingeable-true-crime-stories--4603604/support.
0:00 On a Friday night in July, a 23-year-old named Damien Tillman walks into a dollar general in Frostproof Florida, where bugs prey into headlamp. He's headed out to Nightfish, on Lake Streeti with his buddies Brandon and Kevin. There's a guy inside that store that Damien knows, and the engine sitting in Damien's truck came out of that guy's old truck. [Music] [Music] Frostproof is a little town way down at the south end of Polk County, Florida, and is mostly orange groves and a lake just about everywhere you turn, and Brandon Rollins' family fished all of them.
1:10 On a Friday afternoon in July of 2020, Brandon's working on the breaklines of his white Ford F-150 pickup. He's 27 years old, he lives at home with his parents and his girlfriend. He runs equipment for a long-care company. On his own time, he hunts hogs and trains dogs. That sounds like a t-shirt. And Brandon is always wheeling and dealing on something. And you've got Kevin Springfield. He lives down the road. He's helping Brandon work on this truck. Kevin's 30 and he's an auto mechanic by trade. He's also got a wife and eight kids. You heard me right. 30 years old with eight kids.
1:52 At around nine that night, the two of them head out to fish on Lake Streeti. They're meeting a buddy named Damien Tillman. Damien's 23 and he works at the lows over in seabring and his mom says that he'd help anybody with anything. Just a nice guy. Damien drives a little red Chevy S10 pickup and if you pop the hood on that S10, you'd find an engine that came out of somebody else's truck. That somebody happens to be Tony Lee Wiggins Jr. Who everyone calls TJ. And TJ grew up in old trailers back in the woods that ran off a generator. Some stretches, the family's water came out of a pond or they just collected rainwater to have water at their home.
2:33 His family says the grown-ups around him were always on drugs and TJ was the one that was looking after his little brother, William, who everyone for some reason called Robert. TJ potty trained him. That's how much he looked after him. At 12 years old, TJ starts getting himself arrested, doing different things. As a grown man, TJ does two stretches in state prison. Somewhere along the way, TJ's old Chevy pickup ends up with Kevin and the engine of it ends up inside Damien's S10. Kevin was a mechanic and the investigators never confirmed anything was stolen. Prosecutors say that TJ was convinced that Kevin took his truck.
3:15 In early July, TJ's girlfriend Mary buys some toll ammo 9mm ammunition. The store camera has TJ standing right next to her picking through the boxes. TJ is a convicted felon and Mary's the one who pays for it. At about 9.50 that Friday night, Damien swings into the dollar general. He's a regular and he tells the cashier that he's going fishing and Kevin's going to be out there. He grabs bug spray into headlamp with a spare battery. TJ is in there too with Robert and Mary. After heading out, Wright is Damien walks in and TJ turns around and goes back inside. The store camera catches TJ and Damien talking at the register at about 9.55.
3:59 There's no sound on the video so nobody really knows exactly what was said to each other, but keep in mind, TJ thinks that his truck was stolen and that motor from that truck is now in Damien's truck. The cashier says TJ's group heard Damien say where they were headed. Damien walks out at about 9.56. The TJ's out the door less than a minute behind him. A gas station camera at the intersection picks up a red pickup turning south toward the lake. A white pickup goes straight through and it west. Lake St.D. Road is a clay road along the water so obviously it's very dark. No street lights. Brandon's phone calls his dad at 10.06.
4:40 Brandon's mom, Dottie, hears him on the other end of the line shouting for his dad to help him. Over and over. The real runs out of the house and leaves without his phone. Then the call drops. Cyrill doesn't know the street names out there. At about 10.42 he runs into a sonoco asking for help. The clerk's daughter is there. She's 17 years old. Her mom doesn't want her to go but she gets into Cyrill's truck anyway to go help find him. She reads him the road signs and stays on the line with 9.11. When they get there, Kevin's on his back between the trucks and he's not breathing. The dispatcher walks the girl through CPR on him. Brandon's still alive.
5:20 He tells the 17 year old girl he doesn't want to die. A friend holds pressure on Brandon's wounds with his bare hands. Paramedics work on Brandon until his heart stops and they pronounce him dead at 11. Damians in the bed of his red Chevy S10 pickup. All 10 shell casings are on the ground and they are toll ammo. Damians dollar general bag is sitting on the front seat with the bug spray in the headlamp inside. Never even opened. At 10.26 a white Chevy pickup rolls through a McDonald's drive through over in Lake Whales. Roberts behind the wheel. TJ is in the passenger seat. Mary in between them. They order 10 double cheeseburgers and then they tack on two McChicken's and they take all of that home to eat.
6:07 Back at the crime scene, the bag on Damians front seat is what sends the detectives over to the dollar general. That's how they find the video. TJ tells the detectives the three of them drove straight from the dollar general to the McDonald's. Roberts, first story he tells the cops, is that they're riding around in a green car. Google Maps puts that drive in about 13 minutes. They hit the drive through 29 minutes after TJ walked out of that store. Part of that could be the drive through line. Might have been a little bit busy, but prosecutors say the rest is when the murders happened. When Robert's story changes, he says TJ had him turned down another road and when the fishing trucks passed, TJ told him to whip a U-turn and follow them.
6:51 Out at the lake, he says TJ accused Kevin of stealing his truck and punched him. And then he shot all three of them. Damians blood turns up on the passenger seat belt of the white Chevy, which is the seat TJ was sitting in in the McDonald's video. The next morning, Robert runs that truck through a car wash in Lake Whales. Outside, TJ's trailer detectives find a toll ammo casing fired from the same gun as the casings on Lake St.D. Road. The deputies arrest TJ, Robert and Mary five days after the murders. Sheriff Grady Judd calls TJ "pure evil" in flesh. He says that TJ has 230 charges in his arrest history, which sounds unbelievable, but at some point he tells the room, I didn't stutter.
7:37 At same day, a lieutenant goes out to Kevin's dad's house and there's TJ's old truck sitting there with no motor in it. In one letter from jail, TJ tells Robert to write a statement saying that he only lied to detectives because he was scared they'd pin it on him. Another letter has drawings. At prosecutors say TJ got them tattooed on his body. It's a stop sign that says, "Stop snitching." And a US Highway 27 sign wrapped in crime scene tape. The trial starts in September of 2026, over in Bartow. Robert's already pleaded guilty as an accessory and his deal says that he'll testify against his brother. Then, in the middle of the trial, with the jury out of the room, Robert says he and TJ were never even at that lake.
8:25 He tells the prosecutors, quote, "I just told them whatever they wanted to hear." When the prosecutor says Robert kept looking over at TJ, Robert says he hasn't seen his brother in two years. The prosecutors never even put him on the stand. They do, however, put up an agent from the National Insurance Crime Bureau. He calls the truck's hidden ID numbers the birth certificate of a vehicle. General Motors stamps the last six digits of a truck's "Vin" that number that you can read through the windshield of your vehicle right onto the engine. The engine in Damien's S10 has the number from TJ's old Chevy. The agent says he's 100% sure that is TJ's motor from his truck.
9:06 TJ never takes the stand. His lawyers call the investigation sloppy and they argue nobody can prove a gun was ever in TJ's hand or that any of this was planned. During their closing, Cyrille stands up and shouts on his way out of the courtroom. The defense asks for a mistrial. The judge says no. At this point, nobody knows what's going to happen. The jury takes about three hours to find TJ guilty on every count. The state wants the death penalty. TJ's lawyers bring in a psychologist and a neuropsychiatrist and they play a video of his family talking about those trailers in the woods about how his family was all on drugs.
9:47 The jury recommends life, which under Florida law means life without parole. TJ smiles through the synancing hearing. Dottie holds up a picture of her son Brandon and she tells TJ she hopes every guard and every inmate he meets in prison is named Brandon. So he remembers that name for the rest of his life. Kevin's brother-in-law tells TJ there's no sense in killing somebody over $200. He keeps calling TJ a coward until the judge tells him to be quiet. Damien's mom, Elizabeth, tells TJ that if this was really about the motor, Damien would have given it back to him for his life. TJ doesn't say a word to any of them. The judge gives him three life sentences back to back, no parole.
10:31 Mary pleaded guilty as an accessory and got four years and she's already done her time. Robert synancing was on hold until after TJ's trial and nothing public says where it stands now that he walked away from his deal. Nobody by the way ever found the gun. Out on Lake Streedy there's a memorial with three crosses. To real, mose the grass next to it and he says the family comes out every day. Thanks for listening to 10 Minute Murder, Bingeable True Crime.
11:11 Hi, I'm Joe, the host and here's my take on this whole story. Keep in mind I don't know anything about cars or trucks or motors. But $200 seems like a low amount for a motor. But that's what was mentioned in the story so we're going to stick with that. But if a motor with a $200 value was stolen from you and you killed three people for it, that tells me that you would kill anybody for anything. The slightest wrong done to you, you would kill someone for it. That's what that tells me about TJ. And by the way, it's never been proven if it was in fact a stolen motor. This truck could have been sold by a family member out from under him when he was doing one of his stretches in prison and then got out and was like, no truck would happen to my truck.
11:56 And it was never proven that it was in fact stolen. And personally I would lean toward it not being stolen simply for the reason of TJ seized Damien at the dollar general. If Damien thought, oh, this truck, this motor I've got in my truck is stolen and this guy walking in, that was his motor. We stole it from him. He would be like, oh, damn, let's get out of here. But he didn't do that. He had a whole conversation with this guy standing at the register. And again, you can't hear what they said, but it didn't look aggressive. They didn't fight right there. So that tells me that Damien and his friends weren't too concerned about it. They left the store and went fishing.
12:37 And another part of the story that I brought up just very briefly, but I think it deserves more attention. And that's the 17 year old at the Sonoco. She was there at the gas station, her mom working there said, no, you can't go get in this strangers truck to help him read the road signs and look for his son who was called and needed help. She did that anyway. He wouldn't have found them like he did if it weren't for her going to help. And she was on 9-1-1 the whole time helping to navigate the cops to the location. And then when she got there, she did CPR on Kevin with 9-1-1 right there in her ear. She deserved so much credit for the role that she played in this, even though the circumstances turned out the way they did.
13:19 All three of them died, but she was a hero in this story. And if you have thoughts on this case, I'd love to hear them. You can go to 10minutemerder.com there. You're going to find links to where you can follow 10 minute murder on social media. Just comment on the post about this. I'd love to hear your opinion on what exactly happened. Is a motor worth $200? I thought it would be worth more, I don't know. In all the other strange aspects of this case, 10minutemerder.com and you can get the links to where you can follow 10 minute murder on social media. And that's going to do it. That's your episode for today. Thank you for listening to 10 minute murder. See you next time. [BLANK_AUDIO]
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube