Episodes

Make Something of Yourself: The Murder of Randy Voigt Bartow, Florida is an old phosphate town in the middle of the state, and Randy Voigt was born and raised there. He and his wife Susan bought a house there in 2006, and their son Joseph grew up...

Just Felt Mean That Day: Christa Pike and the Knoxville Job Corps Murder Colleen Slemmer could take a computer apart and put it back together, and she owned a shirt that said Computer Geek to prove it. She left Orange Park, Florida, on Halloween in...

Pink Ribbons on Every Lawn: The Unsolved Death of Lilly Bova Pink ribbons started showing up all over Glenview, Illinois, and every one of them was for a 16-year-old sophomore named Lilly Bova. Lilly was learning to drive and making plans to spend...

The Monster of Atwater Village: The Timothy McGhee Case A T-shirt police seized from Timothy McGhee in the Arizona desert said, "Fugitive. Can't see me." Back home in Atwater Village, a working-class neighborhood on the LA River, he'd been a heavy...

Modelbehavior63: The Catfishing Murder of Kacie Woody Kacie Woody picked her screen name, modelbehavior63, from a Disney movie and her big brother's football number. She was a 13-year-old sax player with a big honking laugh, and she lived at the dead...

A Home Movie for Zachary: The Andrew Bagby Case Andrew Bagby grew up starring in his best friend's homemade movies in California, and by 2001 he was a family medicine resident in Latrobe, Pennsylvania. One November morning, a man picking up cans in...

I Choose You: The Caleb Flynn Case An Apple Watch in a Tipp City, Ohio, house counted 105 steps in the minutes before Caleb Flynn called for help. His wife, Ashley, taught Bible classes for LifeWise Academy and coached 7th grade volleyball. Caleb led...

A Flat Tire at the Bonefish Grill: The Savannah Gold Murder Savannah Gold texted her mom or dad every time she got to work, and she did it in full sentences with actual punctuation. She was 21, an artist who put art school on hold to stay home while...

Hooters Girl Homicide: The Murder of Tina Foster A soldier on an Army funeral detail stops for lunch at the Hooters on Williamson Road in Roanoke, Virginia, and strikes up a conversation with one of the waitresses. Her name is Tina Foster. She wants...

Agent 47695: The Manchester Teen Who Incited A Murder In June 2003, a 14-year-old boy known as John was stabbed twice in an alley behind a row of shops in Altrincham, Greater Manchester, and his 16-year-old friend Mark told detectives a hooded...

A Revelation From God: The Real Killers of Under the Banner of Heaven renda Wright Lafferty and her 15-month-old daughter, Erica, were murdered in their American Fork, Utah home in July 1984, and the homicide investigation led straight to her...

Mamaw's House: The Sherry Cole and Jessie Allen Murders In April 2022, 59-year-old Sherry Cole and her 7-year-old grandson, Jessie Allen, were found dead outside their home on Old Snapps Ferry Road in Limestone, Tennessee. The homicide investigation,...

The Chief's Wife: Murder in Gig Harbor In April 2003, Tacoma Police Chief David Brame shot his estranged wife, Crystal Judson Brame, in a shopping center parking lot in Gig Harbor, Washington, while their 2 young children waited nearby. The homicide...

Life Sentence at 14: The Carly Gregg Case Ashley Smylie was a 40-year-old high school math teacher in Brandon, Mississippi who was shot and killed inside her own home on March 19, 2024, and the suspect deputies arrested nearby was her 14-year-old...

The Last Call: Inside the Killing of Jordan Wheeler In Clinton Township, Michigan, 33-year-old Jordan Wheeler was killed on October 19, 2023, inside her own home, and the criminal investigation that followed led to a 2025 conviction for her estranged...

A Marriage of Secrets: The Susan Cox Powell Case Susan Cox Powell disappeared from her West Valley City, Utah home on December 6, 2009, launching a homicide investigation that centered on her husband, Josh Powell, before he killed himself and their...

Divorce Papers on an Empty Bed: The Dan Markel Case Dan Markel, a 41-year-old Florida State University law professor, was shot twice in the head in the garage of his Tallahassee home on July 18, 2014, in a murder-for-hire plot built by his former...

Gerald and Charlene: The Sex Slave Murders Between 1978 and 1980, Gerald and Charlene Gallego abducted and murdered at least 10 victims across California, Nevada, and Oregon, including Sacramento teenagers Rhonda Scheffler and Kippi Vaught, in a...

Au Pair Affair Murders: The Brendan Banfield Double Murder On February 24, 2023, pediatric ICU nurse Christine Banfield, 37, and a stranger named Joseph Ryan, 39, were killed inside a home in Herndon, Fairfax County, Virginia, in a double homicide...

Dead Weight: The Windi Thomas and Keeno Butler Case On March 18, 2018, 44-year-old Keeno Butler was killed inside his Erie, Pennsylvania apartment in a domestic violence homicide that ended with his girlfriend, 44-year-old Windi C. Thomas, pleading...

Three Words Carved in a Tree: The Kelly Cochran Case Kelly and Jason grew up next door to each other, married young, and made a promise on their wedding night that most people would have laughed off by breakfast. Twelve years later, in a corner of...

A 13-Year-Old Killer: The Murder of Derrick Robie On August 2, 1993, 4-year-old Derrick Robie was lured into a wooded area one block from his home in Savona, New York, and murdered. The suspect was 13-year-old Eric Smith, a neighbor, and the homicide...

A Videotape and a First Grade Mind: The Shelton Holloway Story In April of 1987, 17 year old Patricia Ann Hannah disappeared after a school dance in York, Alabama, and two weeks later her body was found behind an Alabama Power office. A fellow Sumter...

The Cooler That Wouldn't Sink: The Anne Marie Fahey Story Anne Marie Fahey, a 30-year-old appointments secretary for Delaware's governor, vanished from Wilmington in June 1996 after having dinner with prominent attorney Thomas Capano. The...