Join Joe's List! Get updates on new episodes, blogs, and more
November 1987. A young family in rural Illinois was weeks away from escaping a wave of unsolved murders. Keith didn't show up for work. Police found his pregnant wife, his toddler son, and a newborn baby girl dead in their waterbed. Keith was in a f…
August 9th, 2017. Stillwater, Oklahoma. A man walks into a bail bonds office thinking he's there to talk about selling his car. Minutes later, he's climbing out a window, trying to escape. Then a gunshot. He falls to the pavement outside, dying from…
In the summer of 1985, Southern California became a place where people slept with guns under their pillows and left every light in the house on. Because Richard Ramirez didn't care who you were. Didn't matter if you were 79 years old or six. Man,…
Picture a neonatal nurse convicted of murdering seven babies. The evidence seemed solid. The case seemed closed. Then 14 international medical experts reviewed every single death and said wait, no crime was committed here. What actually killed these…
January 31st, 2012. A doorbell rings in Madison, South Dakota. Norman Johnson, age 72, walks to his front door. The man standing there asks Norman to confirm his identity. Norman says yes. And then everything Norman built over seven decades ends …
May 13th, 2011. A six-year-old boy checks out of a Wisconsin water park resort with his mother. Four hours later, she's spotted alone at a grocery store. By morning, she's dead. The note she left behind has kept the FBI searching for over a decade. …
What would you do if the person you loved most in the world was the one who planned your murder? Terry Caffey survived five gunshots, a burning house, and the loss of his entire family. But nothing prepared him for what came next: learning his own d…
In 1968, a young woman selling encyclopedias door-to-door knocked on the wrong house in Portland, Oregon. The man who answered seemed interested in buying her books. He invited her inside his garage. She was never seen alive again. What happened in …
October 24th, 1988. Greenfield, Massachusetts. A 19-year-old grocery clerk puts on a hockey mask, grabs a knife, and walks to his victim's house. He's about to make his favorite horror movie a reality. The victim? An 18-year-old college student who …
November 1938. Halifax, England. For two weeks, an entire town believed they were being hunted by a razor-wielding maniac. Businesses shut down. Mobs formed. An innocent man died. But here's what nobody saw coming: the attacker they were hunting …
Twenty-four bodies pulled from Houston's bayous in under a year. Social media exploded with serial killer theories. A promising college student vanishes after a night out, only to be found days later in the water with no signs of trauma. But here's …
Easter Sunday, 1990. A couple playing license plate games on a back road in Michigan. An aggressive driver in a beat-up van. And a bloody sheet at an abandoned schoolhouse. What Ray and Marie Thornton saw that day would help solve a murder, launc…
A teenager with a backwards name for murder. Six lives taken in nine months. Three kids watching their father shot down while waiting for a puppy. This is the story of the allegations against Antonio Reyes, and the four-year investigation that prose…
Between 1968 and 1985, someone hunted young couples in the hills outside Florence, Italy. Same gun. Same ritual. Sixteen victims. The police arrested the wrong people again and again while bodies kept piling up. In 2024, DNA evidence proved what eve…
In 1893, a pharmacist in Chicago built a hotel specifically designed to kill his guests. He installed gas lines in the bedrooms, secret passages in the walls, and a crematorium in the basement. His victims disappeared during the World's Fair, and th…
On a June evening in Florida, a mother knocked on a neighbor's door to talk about kids playing in a field. Behind that locked door, a woman grabbed a gun. What happened next would expose how two years of harassment, racist threats, and 911 calls cou…
A successful businessman. A beloved community volunteer. A children's entertainer who dressed as a clown for charity events. And beneath his house, the bodies of 33 young men and boys. This is the story of how John Wayne Gacy fooled an entire commun…
Between 1989 and 1990, seven men picked up a hitchhiker along Florida's highways. None of them made it home. Aileen Wuornos said she killed them in self-defense. The state said she was a monster. But what if the truth is somewhere in between? What i…
In September 1972, a dog came home carrying a human arm. What police found next launched 50 years of ghost stories, conspiracy theories, and absolutely zero answers. But in 2024, everything changed. This is the real story of what happened to Jeannet…
Three witnesses. Thirty feet. Three minutes. That's all it took for Branson Perry to vanish from his own backyard in a town that's world-famous for knowing how to keep a secret. And when I say famous, I mean globally infamous. This isn't a case wher…
A first-grade teacher. 20 stab wounds. 10 of them in the back of her neck. The medical examiner called it homicide, then changed it to suicide. Now, 14 years later, the city just discovered 20 more bruises and 3 more stab wounds that were never docu…
December 9th, 2001. A 911 call at 2:40 in the morning. Michael Peterson says his wife fell down the stairs. But it's not what he said. It's how he said it. And when prosecutors started digging into his past, they found another body. Another staircas…
There's a guy in Wichita who will measure your grass with a tape measure and write you a citation if it's too long. He's also the president of his church council. He installs home security systems. He leads a Cub Scout troop. And for 31 years, no…
A bucket hat. Surveillance footage. And DNA evidence that traditional forensics couldn't crack. When a jealous husband stood trial for murder, the jury couldn't decide. But then prosecutors used technology that's rewriting the rules of criminal just…