Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Oct. 31, 2023

Brides in the Bath

Brides in the Bath
Brides in the Bath
10 Minute Murder
Brides in the Bath

0:13 Discretion is advised. This is ten minuted murder. The concept of nature versus nurture is one that has been debated for years. Are people taught to be evil or are they born that way? George Joseph Smith was born on January eleventh, eighteen seventy two, in London. At nine years old, he was sent to a reformatory for his behavior. After his release from the reformatory, he was in and out of prison during his adolescent years for theft and larceny. In eighteen ninety eight, Smith married Catherine Thornhill, and his marriage to Catherine was his only legal marriage, despite the fact that he would go on to marry many many more women. Smith taught Katherine into working as a maid for wealthy families and stealing just enough so that her employers wouldn't notice anything was missing. They managed to make their scheme work for a few months before she was caught. She served twelve months for her crimes, but didn't take the fall alone. She turned in her husband as her accomplice and the mastermind.

1:34 He spent two years in prison and was released in nineteen oh one. After Catherine was released, she moved to Canada. However, there was a stint of time between when Catherine was arrested and Smith was imprisoned, and during that time Smith met a new woman. In eighteen ninety nine, he used a fake name and married a woman that he met in London, although her name is not on the records. Even though he spent two years in prison, that wife waited for him to be released. Upon his release, he returned to her. Unfortunately, he only went back long enough to clear out her bank accounts and then disappeared from her life. The next phase of his criminal career started in June of nineteen oh eight. Smith married a wealthy widow named Florence Wilson under another alias. After gaining Florence's trust, he cleared out her savings and disappeared. By July of nineteen oh eight, he had already found his next bride. He married Edith Pegler and actually used his real name this time. Although he seemed to be happy with Edith, Smith relied on the system that he'd created for income, so in October of nineteen oh nine, using the name George Rose, he married Sarah Freeman. Six days after getting married, he stole all of Sarah's money and returned to Edith. Smith took another trip without Edith in August of nineteen ten, and he used the name Henry Williams, Mary Beatrice or Bessie Monday. Bessie had a rather large

3:05 trust, but she couldn't access it. Smith took what he could from her bank accounts and returned once again to Edith. Together, they bought an antique business. Not only did it provide some legal income, but it gave Smith a legitimate explanation for his frequent trips. He would tell Edith that he needed to travel around the world to make business deals with other antique dealers, and George Joseph Smith must have been a pretty smooth talker because he convinced Bessie to take him back in May of nineteen twelve. And not only did she take him back, but she had created a will making him the sole beneficiary. She was worth in today's dollars about one hundred eighty thousand. She created that will on July eighth. Smith bought a bathtub for their place on July ninth and had it installed. Then on July thirteenth, Bessie died while taking a bath in that bathtub. Quick to recover from the loss of that wife.

4:02 Smith married Alice Burnham in nineteen thirteen. Maybe receiving the money from the will after Bessie's death made him realize that there was a faster way to make a lot more money. Shortly after his marriage to Alice, he took out a life insurance policy on her. Two months after the policy was signed, Alice died while taking a bath. Smith cashed in on the policy, which was the equivalent of forty five thousand dollars today. Not one to be alone for very long, Smith used the name John Lloyd and married Margaret Elizabeth Lofty in nineteen fourteen. They looked at a couple of places and then they found one that they wanted to rent. Smith took out a life insurance policy and Margaret for what would today be sixty three thousand dollars. Two weeks later, she died while taking a bath. A paper named News of the World picked up on the story of Margaret Lofty and ran a report about the woman that died mysteriously in her tub. Soon after, Inspector Arthur Neil of the Scotland Yard found a letter on the desk of Joseph Crossley, and Crossley was a landlord from Blackpool. His letter contained two clippings. One was an article from the News of the World about Margaret's death. The other was a coroner's inquest into the death of Alice Burnham. Crossley owned the house where Alice died. He noticed that there were several similarities between the deaths. Intrigued by the letter, Neil started to look into the cases. He talked to the responding officer at

5:34 Alice's case. The officer said that he found it odd that the husband didn't seem very upset about finding his wife dead in the bathtub. He also said that the tub was pretty small for a woman to accidentally drown in it. He talked to Crossley, who said that not only did Smith not seem upset, he said quote when they are dead, they are dead, as if it was just a matter of fact. Even though Smith had received money after Alice's death, he spent as little on the burial as he possibly could, placing her in a common grave. Neil also looked into Margaret Lofty's case. She had married John Lloyd the day before she died. He had talked to several of the local landlords and found out the soon to be husband. At that time was only interested in apartments that had bathtubs. John Lloyd had also complained about the cost of Margaret's burial and went with the cheapest options available.

6:30 Neil had a feeling that the crimes were connected, but he needed to find proof. On February first, nineteen fifteen, Neil located John Lloyd on the way to collect life insurance money for Margaret. He took him into custody for questioning. Lloyd admitted that his real name was George Smith. That was the name of Alice Burnham's husband. Now Neil could connect Smith to both women. Smith maintained the story that he was in fact married to both women, but just an unlucky widower. Neil was able to charge Smith with making a false entry of marriage since he had used a fake name when he married Margaret. With Smith in custody, Neil continued to look for more evidence to charge him with the other crimes. He read over the original coroner's reports, and they both stated accidental deaths. It was also noted that the husband claimed that the women felt unwell. Shortly before the deaths. Neil had Margaret's body exhumed for another autopsy. He thought perhaps the women had been poisoned. Before entering the bath, he looked for the best pathologists in England to examine the body.

7:38 He found a man named Bernard Spillsbury. Spillsbury also wanted to exume Alice's body. They even brought in the bathtubs to examine. Eventually, they learned about Bessie and exhumed her as well. After examining all of the bodies, Spillsbury found no signs of poison or any other foul play, although that also ruled out the theory the women had seizures or fainted. Since there were no signs of bruising from a fall, Spillsbury developed the theory that Smith would grab the women's ankles and yank them under so fast that the water would flood their mouths and nostrils. They wouldn't immediately be able to respond due to the shock from the sudden intake of water, and lose consciousness in a matter of minutes, ultimately leading to death by drowning. To prove Spillsbury's theory was possible, Neil had a female swimmer come in and lay in one of the bathtubs. He tested the theory by yanking her ankles and pulling her under. Within minutes, there was no movement and she appeared to be unconscious. They immediately pulled her limp body out of the tub. It took almost half an hour to resuscitate her. The unorthodox experiment had proven the theory could hold up in court, but it was also a horrifying experience for those involved because they thought they had just killed this woman that volunteered to take part in this experiment. After recovering, the experienced swimmer said she felt the water rushing up her nostrils and didn't remember anything else until she woke up and saw anxious faces standing over her.

9:09 Neil realized that Smith had married three women, moved them to places where no one knew them, and then would take them to a doctor to make it seem like they had a history of headaches or fainting. All three women listed him as sole beneficiary on a will or life insurance policy, and he was the one to find them all dead. Neil believed that Smith had murdered his wives and that he could now convince a jury how he did it. The trial for murderers started on June twenty second, nineteen fifteen. George Smith was convicted by a jury and sentenced to death on July first. On August thirteenth, the forty three year old was hung at the Maidstone Prison. His trial was one of the earliest instances where the idea of a systematic killer had been allowed to be discussed in court. The press called the crimes Brides in the Bath. The case cemented Spillsbury's reputation as one of Britain's greatest pathologists, and Neil became one of the most famous detectives in Scotland. Yard George Smith is remembered as a vicious predator of women. He quickly gained their trust, and just as fast he took their fortunes and sometimes their lives. He married at least eight women, but only the first was a legal marriage. The only marriage that seemed to matter to him was the one to Edith. He actually wrote Edith a letter write before his hanging, even though she testified in court against him. She testified to how often he was away but always came back

10:39 with plenty of money. Maybe George Smith actually cared for Edith in some twisted way. She said. He once told her to be very careful while taking a bath. Women often lost their lives from fainting while in the bathtub. That is ten Minute Murder for Today Brief and Bingeable true Crime. My name is Joe. I'm the host, and thank you so much for listening. If you're new, welcome, make sure you subscribe before you go, and also connect with ten Minute Murder on social media Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, I mean, I say Twitter, it is it even it's not called Twitter now, whatever it's called. You can follow there if you want, but I don't really do anything active over there. It's just stuff that gets pushed from the other social media accounts. So if you're trying to reach me and you're trying to do it through Twitter, I got bad news for you. I'm not seeing that. The main ones to follow Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok. And speaking of TikTok, that's where the place where you can watch my newest favorite thing on the internet videos of people going to these restaurants where the whole concept to be rude to the customers, like they roast the heck out of you. Dick's Last Resort is one of them, and then there's another one named Karen's Diner. And I've been to Dick's last resort once and it was something listen, these people that walk in expecting Applebee's are

12:16 Chili's or whatever, and they are immediately roasted. I can't get enough of it. It's so funny to me, especially if it's like an older lady, and usually without fail, her mouth will just drop open. She cannot believe that she's being talked to in the way that she's being talked to, and they get like straws thrown out them or paper towels. It is the funniest thing to me. I can't get enough of it. And if you're thinking right now, it might be kind of funny to take me mall to the dick's last resort without her knowing what it is and record the react. Yes, do that? Police do that. There aren't enough of them on the internet. I need to see more of it. I think I've watched everyone that exists, so please, we need more of those videos. All right, that's gonna do it. That is your episode for today. Thank you so much for listening to ten in its murdering