From Unsolved Mysteries to Hollywood: The Jeepers Creepers Murder Case
From Unsolved Mysteries to Hollywood: The Jeepers Creepers Murder Case When a couple's quiet Sunday drive turned into a terrifying chase on a Michigan backroad in 1990, they had no idea they'd just witnessed the aftermath of murder. This is the story...
From Unsolved Mysteries to Hollywood: The Jeepers Creepers Murder Case
When a couple's quiet Sunday drive turned into a terrifying chase on a Michigan backroad in 1990, they had no idea they'd just witnessed the aftermath of murder. This is the story of Marilynn DePue, a high school guidance counselor who tried to escape an abusive marriage, and how her death became the unlikely inspiration for a horror movie that millions of people have watched without knowing the real woman behind the story. We're talking domestic violence, a year-long manhunt, the power of 90s true crime TV, and how Hollywood turned a real tragedy into the monster movie Jeepers Creepers. But most importantly, we're talking about a mom who deserved so much better than how her story ended up being remembered.
#JeepersCreepers #UnsolvedMysteries #TrueCrimePodcast #MarilynDePue #DomesticViolence #MichiganMurder #HorrorMovieTrueStory
🔔 Subscribe for True Crime Cases multiple times a week
Never miss a story. Subscribe to 10 Minute Murder for bite-sized true crime episodes delivered fresh every week.
Discount codes from show sponsors. Support 10 Minute Murder and save money at the same time:
https://hypernaturalstyle.com/discount/10MM
https://zivo.life/discount/10MM
https://bigforkbrands.com/discount/10MM
https://prepstartsnow.com/discount/10MM
📱 Follow for Behind-the-Scenes Content Get exclusive case updates, research photos, and sneak peeks of upcoming episodes:
- Instagram: @10minutemurder on IG
- TikTok: @10minutemurder on TikTok
- Facebook: 10 Minute Murder on FB
- Rate & Review: Leave a 5-star review to help other true crime fans discover the show
- Share: Send this episode to fellow true crime enthusiasts
- Join the Discussion: Tag us in your episode reactions on social media
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/10-minute-murder-bingeable-true-crime-stories--4603604/support.
0:00 Easter Sunday, 1990, a couple playing license plate games on a back-roading Michigan, an aggressive driver in a beat-up van, and a bloody sheet at an abandoned schoolhouse. What Ray and Marie Thornton saw that day would help solve a murder, launch a nationwide manhunt, and eventually inspire one of the two thousand's biggest horror films. But the woman at the center of this story deserves to be remembered for more than just an inspiration for a monster movie.
0:53 Ray and Marie Thornton had a Sunday ritual. Every week they'd take a drive through a quiet back road of Southern Michigan, close to the Indiana border. It was their way of decompressing, getting away from work, stress, and the chaos of raising kids. They played little road trip games to pass the time, like trying to make words out of license plates. Totally wholesome, totally normal, especially in a time before we all had the internet. April 15, 1990 started out like any other Sunday. They were cruising down Snow Prairie Road, about 12 miles outside of Cold Water Michigan. Not much traffic, just them in the open road. Then suddenly this van comes roaring up behind them.
1:34 Some sources say it was brown, others say green, but what everyone agrees on is that the driver was aggressive as hell. The van got right up on their bumper, then swirved into the oncoming lane and flew right past them. Marie called the letters "GZ" on the license plate as it went by and made a joke. "GZ, he's in a hurry." They laughed it off. Some jerk in a rush, right? We've all seen that driver. Sometimes we've been that driver. Within a few miles down the road, they passed an old abandoned schoolhouse, and there was that same van parked right there. The driver was outside. And what Ray and Marie saw made their blood run cold. The guy was carrying something wrapped in a white sheet, and the sheet was stained with what looked like blood.
2:20 Now they're freaked out. It gets worse though. Two or three miles past the schoolhouse, guess who shows up in their rearview mirror again? Van guy, and this time he doesn't pass. He stays right there on their tail, dangerously close for miles. This was intimidation. This was a man making sure they knew he'd seen them seeing him. The thorns did what any of us would do. They got the hell out of there and decided to report the license plate to the police. As they crossed into Indiana, they saw the van one last time, pulled over on the side of the road. The driver was crouched behind it, actively changing the license plate. And when they drove past, Marie could see directly into the open passenger door.
3:03 There was blood inside. What Ray and Marie didn't know yet was that they'd just witnessed a man trying to cover up the murder of his ex-wife. Five hours before the thorns saw that van, something terrible happened at a house in Cold Water, Michigan. Dennis and Marilyn DePue had been married for 17 years. They had three teenage kids. He was a property assessor for the state. She was a guidance counselor at Cold Water High School, the kind of person that students trusted and respected. Inside that marriage, things were dark. Dennis was controlling in paranoid. He isolated himself from the family and constantly accused Marilyn of turning their kids against him.
3:44 He blamed her for everything. In his mind, nothing was ever his fault. When Marilyn finally filed for divorce in 1989, it was her way of saying enough is enough. She was done being controlled. For Dennis, losing that control was unforgivable. On Easter morning, Dennis showed up at Marilyn's house for a court ordered visit with the kids. When the kids didn't want to go with him, he and Marilyn got into a heated argument, right? In front of their children, Dennis attacked her. Shove her down a flight of basement stairs. She was badly hurt, possibly unconscious. Then Dennis told his kids that he was taking their mom to the hospital. He carried her to his van and drove away.
4:25 That was the last time those kids ever saw their mother alive. Four hours later, one of the deputies' daughters called the police. She was worried sick. Her dad said he was taking her mom to the hospital, but nobody had heard anything since then. Police checked. Marilyn had never been admitted anywhere. The next day, a highway worker found Marilyn's body on a deserted road between her house and that abandoned schoolhouse where the Thornton said seen Dennis. She'd been shot once in the back of the head. Dennis obviously was immediately the prime suspect. The Thornton's eyewitness testimony was crucial. Dick evidence, including tire tracks at the schoolhouse, matched his van. But Dennis was gone.
5:07 He'd become a fugitive. For almost a year, he managed to stay hidden. During that time, he sent 17 letters to friends and family from all over the country. Virginia, Iowa, Oklahoma. Dennis used them to justify what he'd done, ranting about Marilyn's supposed lies and tricks, painting himself as the real victim. Classic narcissist. He'd lost his wife and kids, his home. He couldn't stop trying to control the narrative even on the run. Then in March 1991, producers at Unsoft Mysteries got interested in the case. If you're too young to remember Unsoft Mysteries, it was basically the true crime podcast of its time, except it wasn't a podcast at all because those didn't exist.
5:48 It was on NBC. It was hosted by Robert Stack, wearing a trench coat. It was a whole thing and it was fantastic. The show would do dramatic reenactments of Unsoft cases and fugitive hunts. And then asked viewers to call in tips. It was wildly effective. On March 20, 1991, the Dennis DePue segment aired. They did a full reenactment of what the Thornton's witnessed on Snow Prairie Road. They showed his photo. They asked America to help find him. And by the way, you really do need to see a photo of this guy. Go to 10minuteMurder.com, click on the Murder Blog. And before you look, imagine what you think this guy looks like. And he looks exactly like that. It's extremely creepy and unsettling.
6:30 The night that episode of Unsoft Mystery aired, a woman in Dallas was watching TV. As the DePue segment played, she realized something horrifying. The fugitive on her screen was her boyfriend. She knew the man as Hank Queen. Dennis saw the episode too. He knew it was over. He made up some story about his mom being sick. Ask his girlfriend to make him sandwiches for the road to keep her busy in the kitchen. Grabbed his stuff and bolted. Out the sandwiches. The show had already done its job. Tips were flooding in. Police in Louisiana spotted his van and a high-speed chase began. It tore across state lines into Mississippi where local cops were ready and waiting.
7:10 Warren County Sheriff Paul Barrett was one of the officers involved. He later told the Associated Press something that perfectly captures how surreal this was. Quote, "My wife and I watched the TV program about him and the next morning I am with other officers firing into his van. I'd say that's not going to happen every day." Less than 12 hours after that unsolved mysteries episode began, it was over. Dennis DePue's van was stopped in Vicksburg, Mississippi around 4 a.m. on March 21, 1991. They had been a shootout. When deputies approached the vehicle, they found Dennis slumped behind the wheel. A gun still in his hand. He'd shot himself.
7:51 The bullet entered through his mouth and exited the back of his head. Ten years later, something weird happened. The 2001 horror movie Jeepers Creepers came out and became a massive hit. The opening scene shows a brother and sister driving down a desolate road, playing a licensed plate game. A creepy old truck tailgates them aggressively, then speeds past. Later they see the same truck parked by an abandoned church. The driver is dumping what looks like bodies wrapped in bloody sheets. Then the truck chases them. And familiar, director Victor Salva has never officially confirmed that the Dennis DePue case inspired the film's opening. He only said it was based on a true story that I was told about an elderly couple.
8:36 The parallels are too specific to be coincidence. A licensed plate game, the aggressive tailgating, the abandoned building, the bloody sheets, the second, chase, it's all there. When you learn about the connection between Jeepers Creepers and the Dennis DePue case, it changes how you see that opening scene. Things aren't just fictional characters being chased down a scary road. That sequence is based on what Marie and Ray Thorden actually experienced, what they actually saw. Marilyn DePue was 43 years old when she died. She spent years working as a guidance counselor at Coldwater High School. The kind of person who actually gave a damn about kids and wanted to help them figure out their futures. She had three teenagers of her own who needed her.
9:17 She'd finally gotten encouraged to leave an abusive marriage and was building a new life. The week before Easter 1990, Marilyn was probably thinking about normal stuff. Maybe she was planning what to make for dinner. Maybe she was helping one of her kids with homework or college applications. Maybe she was looking forward to having a quiet holiday weekend. She had no idea that the man she'd been married to for 17 years was capable of what came next. Dennis DePue killed her because he couldn't accept that she'd moved on. That's what it came down to. Control. She lost it. He took everything from her. Her future, her chance to see her kids graduate, her chance to help more students.
9:58 All of it gone because one man decided his feelings mattered more than her life. Ray and Marie were just two people on a Sunday drive who happened to be in the wrong place at the right time. Their testimony helped law enforcement piece together what happened. That unsolved mysteries episode brought Dennis' timeline as a fugitive to an end within hours. Anya, a decade later, their experience became part of a movie that a lot of people love. Stories travel in weird ways. Sometimes they move through true crime TV shows. Sometimes they end up in horror movies. Sometimes they get told in podcasts like this one. What matters is that we remember Marilyn DePue was a real person. She mattered to her kids.
10:40 She mattered to her students. She mattered. Period. She deserved to live a long, peaceful life far away from the man who killed her. Thanks for listening to 10 Minute Murder, Bingeable True Crime Stories. I'm Joe, I'm the host, and if you are a new listener, hit subscribe right now. Wait, but only if you enjoy the podcast. If you think it kind of sucks, then don't subscribe. And I get it, this show isn't for everyone. It's not meant to be for everyone, but if you do enjoy the podcast, please do subscribe. It helps you and it helps me. So it's a mutually beneficial relationship we've got going on.
11:21 Also, you can go to 10minutemurder.com. Lots of stuff to do there. Check out the murder blog that I mentioned earlier in the episode where you can see a picture of Dennis DePue that you really do need to see. Imagine kind of a creepier Herman Munster. And that's him. Also, on the website, you can subscribe to the newsletter that's there. I've just started sending out newsletters now. I know that I've been collecting these email addresses for a while and you haven't been getting anything. That's because I haven't sent anything out until recently. But I do need to let you know that if you have subscribed and you haven't seen a newsletter email from me, it's probably in your spam. I put myself on the list, the newsletter list, and I didn't see it. I was like, where the heck is this thing?
12:01 It was in my spam. So if you haven't seen it, go check your spam folder. It's probably living in there. On the website, you can also email me, which is where this one comes from, subject accidental detective tendencies. Hey Joe, your podcast has officially ruined me. I now analyze every weird thing I see like I'm auditioning to be a detective. Strange car parked, long on my streets, case file. Neighbors trash can at a weird angle. Suspicious. Have you noticed that true crime fans pick up those little, I could solve the case if I needed to, habits? Or is it just me losing my grip on reality? Devon in Louisville. Devon, let me tell you, you're probably just losing your grip on reality. No JK, I think that in order to be someone that a connoisseur of true crime, you have to have that part of your brain that works that way.
12:50 You trust people, but not totally. You're always wondering what people's ulterior motives are. You see a piece of paper on the ground and it has like this reddish smudge on it, you think, oh, that's blood. That's potential evidence right there. I do that and I'm sure 90% of the people listening to this right now do that same thing. I think it's within our brains. We consume all this true crime and we just assume it's out there in the world, which by the way it is. That's not a conspiracy theory, there are murderers all around us. Not to try to scare you or anything, but you listen to the podcast, you hear these people, they're normal people, especially like the BTK killer. Devon, again, thank you for your email. That's going to do it.
13:30 That is your episode for today. Thank you again for listening to 10 Minute Murder. See you next time. [MUSIC]
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube