Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Feb. 29, 2024

George Stinney Jr

George Stinney Jr
George Stinney Jr
10 Minute Murder
George Stinney Jr

​A young black boy was executed in 1944 for the murders of two young white girls in a small southern town. 80 years later, his guilt is still a topic of debate. Not only is the case still debated, it is as fresh in the minds of the family members as...

​A young black boy was executed in 1944 for the murders of two young white girls in a small southern town. 80 years later, his guilt is still a topic of debate. Not only is the case still debated, it is as fresh in the minds of the family members as it was then. The emotions are still raw and the outcome still devastating. .

Thank you so much for listening to and supporting 10 Minute Murder!

SUBSCRIBE
to 10 Minute Murder.
Have friends that also like true crime stories?
SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to read about new episodes and see visuals that go along with the story.

10minutemurder.com

email: joe@10minutemurder.com
_______
Follow 10 Minute Murder-

Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Threads:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

If you have a request for a case to be featured on 10 Minute Murder, or have any questions for Joe (the host), please feel free to send them to the email address above.
*******
*******


Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):https://uppbeat.io/t/alex-besss/psychoLicense code: 9S4DJJHMH9Y2FLTW

0:08 Disprushing. Mister George Stenny Junior was born on October twenty first, nineteen twenty nine. He grew up in al Klou, South Carolina. His father, George Stenny Senior, worked at the local lumberyard in Sawmill. The sawmill brought a lot of life to the small town, employing many of its residents.

0:53 The Stenny family even lived in a company owned house. Their house was small, with a chicken coop in the back room, enough for George, his parents, and his siblings. When George Stenny was fourteen, he was still pretty small. He was only five foot one inch and around ninety five pounds. He had a younger sister named Amy that he often referred to as his shadow. She followed him everywhere he went. On March twenty second, nineteen forty four, they were playing outside of the house when two little white girls riding their bikes stopped to talk to them. This was extremely unusual at the time. The town was still extremely segregated. The white and black families attended different churches, the children went to separate schools, and the railroad tracks divided their housing. The girls were looking for may Pops. It's a name they used in that area for passion flowers, and Stenny told them he didn't know where to look for the maypops, so the girls continued on their way.

1:52 The next day, while his parents were away at work, two black cars rolled down the dusty driveway. Amy was scared and she hid in the chicken coop. George and his brother John were taken into custody and questioned for murder. Betty June Binnaker, age eleven, and Mary Emma Thames, aged seven, never made it home from their bike ride. Their bodies had been found on the black side of the train tracks, their heads beaten with a blunt object strong enough to crush their skulls, and the oldest had physical signs that she may have been raped. John was released, but George Stenney was charged with the crimes. One of the arresting officers claimed that Stenny gave a full confession and even told them where to look for the murder weapon. After a search of the area, they found a railroad spike. In just eighty one days, Stinney was dead too. The trial started and ended on April twenty fourth. Stenny's defense was made up of one court appointed council, Charles plowdhim X commissioner that was running for a local office. The prosecution called on three of the arresting officers, the reverend that discovered the girl's bodies, and the two doctors that performed the post mortem exams. Plowden didn't even cross examine the prosecution's witnesses, called in none of his own, did not challenge the prosecutor's recollection of events even though he told two different versions, and did not question

3:24 why there was no record written or confirmed of the confession. He did nothing to defend George Stenney Junior. The entire proceeding lasted only two and a half hours. In less than ten minutes, the jury, which consisted of twelve white men, returned from deliberation with a verdict of guilty for the fourteen year old boy. Judge Philip Stole sentenced Stenny to death by electrocution. The crowd both in and around the courthouse seemed pretty pleased with the finding. There were over one thousand white men and women that showed up for the trial, even though the defendant was black. They did not allow black men or women in the court house. From the time Stenny was arrested. His parents were not allowed to see him until after the trial. He sat in the interrogation rooms alone, no parents and no counsel. He sat in jail awaiting the trial alone. His parents had not been allowed to visit or communicate with him at all. Stenny's father was fired from his job, and since they lived in a company owned house, they had to immediately move. They relocated closer to grandparents while they figured out what to do. They tried to find someone to help them appeal the ruling. Local churches and the NAACP appealed to Governor Olan Johnson to consider clemency considering the age of the boy. Ironically, most of the letters he received were from white women that didn't want to see someone so

4:56 young executed. The governor visited Stenny to two days before his execution. The governor said that he wanted those begging for clemency to know that Stenny killed the smaller girl so that he could rape the bigger one, but then he killed the bigger one before raping her dead body. He even returned later with the intention of raping her again, but found the body was already too cold. He claimed Stenny admitted all of it. Of course, it was reported that all of those were rumors that the governor heard, and that it never came from Stenny directly. Steney told other inmates that he was coerced and maintained his innocence. On June sixteenth, nineteen forty four, at seven thirty a m.

5:39 He was prepared for execution. His arms and legs and body were restrained to the chair. He was too short, so they placed a thick bible under him. When asked if he had any last words, he said no, sir. Then they placed the leather strap in his mouth, and he burst into tears. They placed him that seemed way too large on his head, and his sobs could be heard around the room. With the first flick of electricity, the mask shook off of his head, revealing the tear stained face of the young boy. It took three flips of the switch before he was pronounced dead. There was a witness from one of the victim's families and said that the event was not nearly so dramatic. He denied that they placed a bible under him or that the mask fell off as soon as the electricity was turned on. Exact records of the event cannot be found, so we can only go on what is recounted from those that were there. So why eighty years later is this case still being debated In case you haven't been able to tell so far in the story, very little has been actually agreed upon what occurred in nineteen forty four. In two thousand and four, George Friarson, a historian that grew up in al Kalou, started researching the case.

6:59 It wasn't long before several pro bono lawyers got involved, and then they got more people to volunteer. They went through historical documents, found witnesses, and located evidence that they believe could exonerate Stenny. Although there was no transcript of the actual trial, a motion for a new trial was filed in twenty thirteen. In twenty fourteen, the Civil Rights and Restorative Justice Project at Northeastern University filed an amicus brief with the court stating that the case was based exclusively on a confession that was not recorded or written, and taken without the consent of parents or presence of counsel. Rather than approving a new trial, the judge vacated the conviction. The overturning of the conviction did not mean that Stenny was innocent, but that he did not receive a fair trial and should not have been executed so quickly. The new ruling also caused a flood of responses.

7:57 The Stenny family was thrilled. They always claimed that Stenny was innocent, that he was with the siblings when the murders occurred and he could not have done it. The Bickner and Thames families were disappointed. While they understood that he may not have received a fair trial, they felt as though he was being painted as a poor black boy that was unfairly charged with a crime, but in reality was undoubtedly guilty. The different opinions continued to be vocalized. There was an interview from Stinney's seventh grade teacher that was published in nineteen ninety five. They claimed he had threatened a girl at school the day the crime took place. Amy Stenny's sister contacted him and claimed that he told her it was not true, but he was paid to say that the teacher died shortly after, so neither side of the story could be confirmed. The reverend that found the bodies said that there was very little blood in the ditch, considering how badly the girls had been beaten. If they had been killed there, it seemed as though there would be a lot more blood if they had been killed somewhere else and then moved there. It didn't seem possible that such a small child could have picked them both up and carried them. There was a theory that the girls may have been killed by George Burke Junior. Stinny's mom worked for their family for a short time. They were a wealthy white family.

9:18 She was uncomfortable with the advances of the father. When she told her husband about it, he told her not to return to work for that family. Missus Burke was angry over the whole event, maybe a little embarrassed, and the theory is that the boys hurt the girls and pinned it on George Stenney Junior to get even. Added to that, George Burke Senior owned the property where the girls were found and served as the foreman on the grand jury in Stinney's case. Supposedly a member of the family made a deathbed confession about the event, but once again there are no records and no one to confirm it. Now, Alcalou, South Carolina, seems like a forgotten town with a population of around four hundred people. Weeds have reclaimed, old buildings, and vacant stores line the streets, yet the memory of what happened is far from fading. Three memorial crosses are placed at the ditch where the girls were found, one for each young life lost after a tragic event. Sometimes it's not the truth that decides the outcome of a story. Sometimes the majority can be persuaded by which side is the most convincing. As the old saying goes, believe nothing you hear and half of what you see. That's ten minute Murder

10:50 for today, brief and binge able true crime. I'm Joe, I'm the host, and I really appreciate you listening. If you're new to Ten Minute Murder, make sure you hit subscribe right now wherever you like to listen to podcasts, probably where you're listening right now, I'm gonna go out on a limb and assume that about it. Just hit subscribe and that will more easily help you catch up on all of the back episodes. Now, that is if you're a brand new listener. Now, if you're an OG listener, chances are you've already caught up on all the back episodes and If that's the case, make sure you are following ten Minute Murder on all places that the podcast has a presence on social media links from the show notes of the episode, or go to ten Minute Murder dot com and you'll find the links to all of that stuff. Now, we haven't done this in a while, but a quick listener email, Hi Joe, it's been ages since you gave a list of pet peeves or things bothering you right now, so do it please. I like your podcast, Nancy and North Kakilaki. And by the way she wrote North Kakilaki, I didn't just try to sound cool and say that what's bothering me right now? Man? I try to stay pretty positive, so it's difficult to come up with this on the spot. Whoever, stop saying that people rock, you rock. Nobody has rocked since like two thousand and four. We can stop saying that hit me up, knock it off. Don't say that anymore. And also, why are we doing shout outs still? We can mention something, but shout outs. I'd like for shout out the term shout out to just all together go away. I cringe

12:24 a little bit every time someone says, let me give you a shout out. Now, it's different in different contexts. In different contexts which I'm not going to go into, like it's it's acceptable. But for most contexts, I don't want to be shouted out. I don't want to hear someone be shouted out. I don't know why that bothers me, and I understand that it's irrational, but I was asked the question by Nancy and North Cakilaki, so I feel like I'm compelled to answer. All Right, that's going to do it. That is the episode for today. Thank you so much for listening to the podcast, and I'll see you in the next one.