Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Feb. 17, 2026

Julissa Thaler: The Mother Who Bought a Shotgun After Losing Custody Battle

Julissa Thaler: The Mother Who Bought a Shotgun After Losing Custody Battle
Julissa Thaler: The Mother Who Bought a Shotgun After Losing Custody Battle
10 Minute Murder
Julissa Thaler: The Mother Who Bought a Shotgun After Losing Custody Battle

Julissa Thaler: The Mother Who Bought a Shotgun After Losing Custody Battle In May 2022, Orono police discovered six-year-old Eli Hart's body in the trunk of his mother Julissa Thaler's vehicle during a routine traffic stop in Minnesota. The...

Julissa Thaler: The Mother Who Bought a Shotgun After Losing Custody Battle

In May 2022, Orono police discovered six-year-old Eli Hart's body in the trunk of his mother Julissa Thaler's vehicle during a routine traffic stop in Minnesota. The investigation revealed Thaler had shot Eli up to nine times with a 12-gauge shotgun just ten days after regaining full custody. Evidence included the weapon purchase six days after the father filed for custody, Google searches about child blood loss and life insurance payouts, and ammunition specifically requested to "blow the biggest hole." Despite 21 police calls to Thaler's home, documented mental health crises, and explicit warnings from family members that she would kill Eli rather than lose custody, Dakota County Social Services recommended returning the child to her care.

Eli was a kindergartener who loved the monkey bars, fishing with his dad, and making friends at school. Despite being born with medical challenges that required surgeries and hearing aids, everyone said he was one of the happiest kids they'd ever met. His foster mother told social workers directly that she believed Thaler would murder Eli to keep him from his father. Two weeks after getting full custody, that's exactly what happened.

#EliHart #JulissaThaler #TrueCrime #MinnesotaMurder #ChildWelfare #Justice #SystemFailure

🔔 Subscribe for True Crime Cases multiple times a week

Never miss a story. Subscribe to 10 Minute Murder for bite-sized true crime episodes delivered fresh every week.

Get a weekly email from me about the upcoming cases and more: 10minutemurder.com/newsletter

📱 Follow for Behind-the-Scenes Content Get exclusive case updates, research photos, and sneak peeks of upcoming episodes:

💬 Have a Case Suggestion? Know a fascinating case that deserves coverage? I love listener suggestions and feature the best ones in upcoming episodes. Email: joe@10minutemurder.com Website: 10minutemurder.com ⭐ Help Grow the True Crime Community
  • Rate & Review: Leave a 5-star review to help other true crime fans discover the show
  • Share: Send this episode to fellow true crime enthusiasts
  • Join the Discussion: Tag us in your episode reactions on social media
🎧 Want Even More True Crime? If you love the brief and bingeable vibe, check out my other podcast: 10 Minute Mystery - same bingeable storytelling, different cases. Search "10 Minute Mystery" wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for being part of the 10 Minute Murder community. Let's make 2025 the ultimate year for bite-sized true crime storytelling. 🖤


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/10-minute-murder-bingeable-true-crime-stories--4603604/support.

0:00 Six-year-old Eli Hart was a kindergartener who loved playing on the monkey bars and going fishing with his dad. He was born with medical challenges that required surgeries and hearing aids. But teachers and families said he was always smiling, always making friends. In May 2022, during a traffic stop in Orano, Minnesota, police found Eli's body in the trunk of his mother's car. She'd shot him nine times with a shotgun. And had been exactly ten days since Dakota County gave her full custody of Eli. [Music] There's a moment in a lot of true crime cases where you realize that tragedy didn't have to happen.

1:08 Someone saw the warning signs. Someone raised the alarm. Someone tried to intervene. And then you find out that all those someone's were ignored and the child ended up dead. The case of Eli Hart is one of those stories where every single person who tried to save him was told to sit down and be quiet. And ten days later, that little boy was gone. Eli was six years old in May 2022. He was in kindergarten at Shirley Hills Primary School in Mount Minnesota. By all accounts, he was this bright, energetic kid who loved being around other people. His dad, Tori Hart, said Eli was always happy, always outgoing, full of energy.

1:48 He loved the monkey bars at the park, loved playing with toy cars, loved going fishing. Eli had medical challenges from birth. He was born with a genetic disorder called Townsbrox syndrome that affected his feet and his hearing. He had multiple surgeries when he was a baby and wore hearing aids. But none of that slowed him down. Teachers said he was popular with the other kids. He made friends very easily. But Eli's home life was a different story. His mother, Jalissa Thaler, had been struggling with severe mental illness and addiction since she was a teenager. During the ages of 13 and 18, she was in and out of mental health institutions. She was treated repeatedly for drug and alcohol abuse.

2:31 During her senior year of high school, she ran away and lived on the streets for 45 days. As an adult, her life was chaotic. She had arrests for stealing pharmaceuticals from a health clinic. She was kicked out of court-ordered parenting classes. Between 2020 and 2021, police were called to her home 21 times in a 10-month period. In October 2020, Dakota County Social Services found Eli wandering around naked in a house described as being in terrible condition. That's when they removed him and placed him with the foster mother named Nikita Kronberg. Nikita loved that little boy. But she also saw something that terrified her. She told social workers.

3:13 She told the court appointed guardian. She told anyone who would listen that she believed Jalissa would kill Eli if she ever got him back. She said Jalissa would rather see Eli dead than let his father have custody. She said this multiple times. She was explicit about it. Tory Hart was fighting desperately to protect his son. Jalissa had thrown all kinds of accusations at Tory trying to keep him away from Eli. She accused him of domestic abuse. She claimed he planted a nail bomb in her car. None of it was true. Police never substantiated any of it. It created enough chaos that it delayed Tory's efforts to get custody. In March 2022, he was sending frantic emails to social workers saying Eli was being neglected, sleep deprived, wearing dirty clothes for days, missing medical appointments.

4:03 Even the social workers' own reports showed serious problems. During supervised visits, Eli would hide behind furniture to avoid his mother. He'd have bathroom accidents after seeing her. Despite signs of a child experiencing trauma, despite all of this, despite the 21 police calls, despite the warnings, despite Eli's own behavior screaming that something was wrong, Dakota County Social Services recommended closing the protective case and giving Jalissa full custody. On May 10, 2022, a judge did exactly that. 10 days later, Eli was dead. At March 11, 2022, Tory Hart filed a petition seeking full custody of Eli.

4:48 Six days later, on March 17, Jalissa bought a 12-gauge shotgun. This wasn't impulsive. She took a friend to the gun range the next two days to learn how to shoot it. Neighbors saw her carrying the shotgun wrapped in a grey blanket between her apartment and her car. Her Google search history tells you everything. She searched how much blood can a six-year-old lose. She searched how much does life insurance pay for a dead child. She looked up how to get away with crimes. Days before she killed Eli, she went into a gun shop and asked the clerk for ammunition that would "blow the biggest hole" in something.

5:28 On the 9th of May 19, 2022, Eli was at Jalissa's apartment in Spring Park. Her boyfriend, Robert Piccareanian, was there. He later testified that Eli was playing with kittens and getting rowdy. Jalissa got angry. When Eli wouldn't go to bed, she started hitting him. Piccareanian eventually went to sleep, but before he did, he saw Jalissa take the shotgun to her car, come back inside, grab Eli, and leave with him late at night. Cellphone tracking showed exactly where she went. She drove to a secluded parking lot at Lake Minnetonka Regional Park. Eli was strapped into his booster seat in the back of her silver Chevrolet Impala.

6:10 Jalissa fired six rounds from the shotgun into her son at close range. Then she reloaded and fired three more shots into his body and head. The force of the blasts blew out the back window. After killing Eli, Jalissa drove around with his body in her trunk. At some point, one of her tires shredded completely and she was driving on a bare metal rim. She stomped at multiple gas stations and threw evidence into dumpsters. She dumped Eli's backpack with his kindergarten worksheets inside. She dumped his blood-soaked booster seat. Around 7-10 in the morning, on May 20, police pulled her over after getting reports about a damaged vehicle.

6:50 The officer said she looked disheveled and nervous, avoiding eye contact. He noticed what looked like blood on her hands and face in a spray pattern. When he asked her about it, she gave a bizarre excuse. First she said it was menstrual blood. Then she said she'd been carrying deer meat from a butcher. Inside the car, there was blood spattered on the ceiling and back door. There was a bullet hole in the back seat. But officers didn't search the trunk right away. Jalissa complained about being cold and refused to sit in the squad car. So they gave her a ride home and let her go. It wasn't until after they dropped her off that they searched the vehicle. Police went back to arrest Jalissa but she had already left on foot.

7:40 Inside the car, the washing machine running with the blood stained closed she'd been wearing during the traffic stop. When they caught her shortly after, she still had blood and what appeared to be biological matter in her hair. DNA testing would later confirm it was Eli's tissue. The trial started in early 2023. The prosecution had an overwhelming case. They had the gun purchased six days before Tory filed for custody. They had the Google searches. They had cell phone data placing her at the murder scene. They had DNA evidence. They had the ammunition purchase. They had Picarenian's testimony about the violent night before. The defense barely mounted a case.

8:20 Their argument was that the state couldn't prove the gun was in her hands at the exact moment of the shooting. They suggested maybe she was an accomplice but there was zero evidence anyone else was involved. The jury deliberated for less than two hours before finding Jalissa Thaler guilty of first degree premeditated murder and second degree intentional murder. At her sinencing hearing in February 2023, she did not show remorse. She maintained her innocence and used profanity to insult the court and Eli's family. The judge sentenced her to life in prison without the possibility of parole. "I'm a scholar, you were right to speak this morning, if you'd like, you don't have any obligation to speak, but if you'd like to choose to speak now it's time to do it."

9:07 "Yes, I would like to say something." "Go ahead." "I'm innocent, fuck you all, you're garbage." "That's what we're on." "Thank you Miss Thaler. I don't know that that's appropriate here." "Sorry, I told you what's in her hands." "What I was saying." "What I would say is, you know, the worst thing that seems to happen to parents is to lose their child." "It's worse though when you don't lose your child to something like cancer or an accident. It's when someone takes that child from the world. What I can't imagine, nobody can imagine, is when the person that takes a child from the world is the one that brought that child in.

9:48 That is what the jury concluded you did in a respect to the jury's judgment and respect to the minister. So, this decision about what the appropriate consequence is. Nothing that I do would bring justice to this situation. Nothing I do would relieve any of the pain that you can't expect doing that, but what is, according to my other just unfair sense of what you did is when Mr. Ali said in that, it is life in prison without the possibility of parole. So, I will consider guilty of the first to be murdering an issue that sentence, I will not impose any sentence. "I'm sorry, Mary, you're all right. I'm sorry."

10:28 "The bottom line is that you are being sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole and the start. I'm not composing any kind of fine of fees. I'm going to look at you. I'm going to submit a DNA sample as a National Keep Constitutional." Tory Hart filed a federal lawsuit against Dakota County and the social workers who handled Eli's case. In December 2024, the county settled for $2.25 million. They didn't admit wrongdoing, but it was a public acknowledgement that something went catastrophically wrong. Tory and his wife Josephine started the Eli Hart Foundation to help other parents fighting for custody who can't afford legal representation.

11:09 Here's what this case really comes down to. Eli was a little boy who survived surgeries and medical challenges and was still happy. He was resilient and social and very loved. And then the people whose job it was to protect him ignored 21 police calls. Ignored a foster mother who explicitly said she believed this would happen. Ignored a father who begged them to intervene and gave that child back to someone who had already shown everyone exactly what she was capable of. Thanks for listening to 10 Minute Murder, Bingeable True Crime Stories.

11:52 I'm Joe, I'm the host and here's an email subject Ted Bundy. Hi Joe, and greetings from Devon England. Love your podcasts. For the past year or so I've been traveling through your back catalog and I've reached back to July 2021 where I came across your three-part podcast of Ted Bundy. I guess I slash you slash us slash we get to the point where you become somewhat immune to the depraved behaviors of murders and the like. But the Bundy tapes certainly gave me the creeps especially when they contained so much of his actual voice. Mercifully in British society we don't usually get to that level of violence apart from notable exceptions of course.

12:33 Up the good work I'll reach out at the end of your archive at some point. Cheers David. David, thank you for the email. I didn't know the internet reached that far. JK, I really do appreciate the email and yeah the Ted Bundy stuff. Back when I covered that, like you said 2021, man it's been some years. It didn't seem like it was that long ago but those were some sleepless nights where I was researching that because Ted Bundy seems so average and normal and smart and ladies found him attractive and all these things and he was just a sicko in every way possible. And you'll find once you run through the archive of stories here on 10 Minute Murder, I repeat some every now and then if I want to update the information or talk about a different angle in different cases I'll repeat them.

13:22 And Ted Bundy is one that I think I could cover once a year till further notice. There's so much to talk about when it comes to Ted Bundy. Alright, if you are a new listener to this podcast, make sure you hit subscribe right now. You can also go to 10minuteMurder.com, get more information about the podcasts and me a message, sign up for the weekly newsletter. OG listeners, I love you, keep sharing the show with your friends and your family, rating it five stars wherever that's possible. And that's gonna do it. That's your episode for today. Thank you again for listening to 10 Minute Murder. See you next time. [Music]