Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Dec. 30, 2025

Sarah Jo Pender: The Female Charles Manson Case Explained

Sarah Jo Pender: The Female Charles Manson Case Explained
Sarah Jo Pender: The Female Charles Manson Case Explained
10 Minute Murder
Sarah Jo Pender: The Female Charles Manson Case Explained

Sarah Jo Pender: The Female Charles Manson Case Explained They called her the Female Charles Manson. In October 2000, two people were shot to death in an Indianapolis drug house. Sarah Jo Pender bought the shotgun that morning at Walmart. Her...

Sarah Jo Pender: The Female Charles Manson Case Explained

They called her the Female Charles Manson. In October 2000, two people were shot to death in an Indianapolis drug house. Sarah Jo Pender bought the shotgun that morning at Walmart. Her boyfriend Richard Hull pulled the trigger. She got 110 years, he got 75. Now the prosecutor who convicted her says he was wrong. But here's the thing about Sarah Jo Pender: everywhere she goes, people end up doing things they wouldn't normally do. She manipulated a prison guard into breaking her out. She lived as a fugitive for months. And now she's one hearing away from walking free. This is about intelligence as a weapon, about the difference between pulling a trigger and aiming the gun, and about whether 25 years is justice or just good patience.

#SarahJoPender #TrueCrime #DoubleMurder #FemaleCharlesManson #PrisonEscape #Indianapolis #Manipulation

🔔 Subscribe for True Crime Cases multiple times a week

Never miss a story. Subscribe to 10 Minute Murder for bite-sized true crime episodes delivered fresh every week.

Get a weekly email from me about the upcoming cases and more: 10minutemurder.com/newsletter

📱 Follow for Behind-the-Scenes Content Get exclusive case updates, research photos, and sneak peeks of upcoming episodes:

💬 Have a Case Suggestion? Know a fascinating case that deserves coverage? I love listener suggestions and feature the best ones in upcoming episodes. Email: joe@10minutemurder.com Website: 10minutemurder.com ⭐ Help Grow the True Crime Community
  • Rate & Review: Leave a 5-star review to help other true crime fans discover the show
  • Share: Send this episode to fellow true crime enthusiasts
  • Join the Discussion: Tag us in your episode reactions on social media
🎧 Want Even More True Crime? If you love the brief and bingeable vibe, check out my other podcast: 10 Minute Mystery - same bingeable storytelling, different cases. Search "10 Minute Mystery" wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for being part of the 10 Minute Murder community. Let's make 2025 the ultimate year for bite-sized true crime storytelling. 🖤


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/10-minute-murder-bingeable-true-crime-stories--4603604/support.

0:00 October 24th, 2000. A 21-year-old secretary walks into a Walmart in Indianapolis and buys a shotgun. 12 hours later, two people are dead. She gets 110 years in prison. The shooter gets 75. The prosecutor, who called her the female Charles Manson, now says he's wrong. But when you look at the pattern, when you see what she did in prison, when you watch how she's fighting for freedom right now, you start to wonder if maybe he was right the first time.

0:57 October 2000, Indianapolis. Sarah Jo Pinder is 21 years old. She's working as a secretary. She's smart. She's got no criminal record. She's dating this guy named Richard Hull, who is a bouncer with a temper and a rap sheet. They're living with another couple. Andrew Cotaldi and Trisha Nordman, and everyone in this house is dealing drugs. This, if it wasn't already, is where things get complicated, because Sarah Jo Pinder had been sexually assaulted a few months earlier. She was feeling traumatized, and a lot of people say that she latched on to Hull because he was tough and he was protective and he made her feel safe. That's the sympathetic version. Here's another way to look at it. She found a guy who was violent and not particularly smart and could be controlled. But we'll get into that. So Cotaldi starts causing problems. He owed money for drugs. He's threatening Hull's family. The tension in this house is building. And on October 24th, Sarah Jo Pinder and Richard Hull drive to Walmart. They buy a Mossberg 12-gauge shotgun and deer slugs. Deer slugs, not bird shots that could wound you, the kind of ammunition that would absolutely rip through a person.

2:16 Hull is a felon. He can't legally buy a gun, so Pinder fills out all the paperwork. Pinder pays for it. Pinder carries it out of the store. That night Hull and Cotaldi get into an argument. It escalates, and Hull shoots Andrew Cotaldi in the chest. One deer slug. Then he shoots Trisha Nordman twice. Chest and head. Richard Hull admitted to pulling the trigger. Nobody disputes that. He is the shooter. Sarah Jo Pinder says that she walked away from the argument before it turned violent. She heard the shots and she came back and Hull was standing over the bodies and she was terrified. That's what she says. If she was terrified, what happened next is interesting. October 25th, the day after the murders. Pinder goes to work. Shows up to her secretary job like nothing ever happened. Hull stays home and scrubs blood off the floors.

3:13 That night they load up the two bodies into the back of a pickup truck. They drive to a dumpster behind the Teamsters Union building and they throw Andrew Cotaldi and Trisha Nordman into the trash. Look, I'm not saying a terrified person couldn't do this. Fear makes people do strange things. But a terrified person might also, when they're away from the house, call the police. A terrified person might run. Sarah Jo Pinder went to work and then helped dispose of the bodies. Those are the facts. When they get arrested, Hull immediately says "Pinder made him do it." She manipulated him. She's orchestrating this whole thing. Everyone dismisses this because of course Hull is trying to save himself. He's pointing the finger to get himself a better deal. Then there's this confession letter that supposedly Pinder wrote to Hull while they're both in jail. It says something like "I wish I could go back and change the events of that night." Years later, Hull says he forged it. Another inmate named Steve Logan says that he wrote it. Their fingerprints are on the letter. Pinder's fingerprints aren't. So that letter is probably fake or Pinder dictated it and had someone else write it. Who knows? There's also Floyd Pinington, a jailhouse snitch who testified that Pinder confessed to him. Pinington had a whole list of cases that he was snitching on to reduce his sentence so maybe he's lying. Maybe he's not lying.

4:43 August 2002, the jury convicts Pinder. She gets 110 years in prison. Richard Hull pleads guilty. He gets 75 years. The shooter gets less time than the person who bought the gun and a lot of people think that's unfair. But here's what the prosecutor argued. The person who plans a murder is more dangerous than the person who executes it. Richard Hull, without Sarah Jo Pinder, is just a violent guy with the temper. He might get in fights. Two people probably don't end up dead. Sarah Jo Pinder, without Richard Hull, she finds another Richard Hull because the dangerous part isn't the gun itself. It's the person who knows how to use it. Fast forward to six years into her sentence. Pinder's appeals are going nowhere.

5:33 She's looking at dying in prison. So she starts a relationship with a corrections officer named Scott Spittler. Five years on the job for him. Battery charge is pending. His marriage is falling apart. Pinder promises him $15,000. And on August 4, 2008, he drives her out of prison in an apartment of corrections van. Scott Spittler goes to prison for eight years. Over this, Jamie Long, the woman who helped hide her, gets seven years. For four months, Pinder lives in Chicago under the name Ashley Thompson. She gets a job. Her coworkers like her. Her neighbors think she's pleasant and normal. A neighborhood watches America's most wanted, recognizes her, and calls it in. Chicago police rate her apartment on December 22, 2008.

6:22 Pinder goes back to Indiana. She gets put in solitary confinement for over five years. And look, maybe that part was excessive. Maybe that was cruel. She sued and won a settlement. But she also manipulated a prison guard into committing a felony for her. Actions have consequences. Here's what keeps bothering me about this case. Everywhere Sarah Jo Pinder goes, people end up doing things they wouldn't ordinarily do. Richard Hull shoots two people. Scott Spittler throws away his career and his freedom to drive her out of prison. Jamie Long risks seven years to hide a fugitive. And now the prosecutor who once called her female Charles Manson says he's wrong. Larry Cells is retired. He found the snitch list. He realized the confession letter was probably forged. He's advocating now for her release. A prosecutor admitting that he made a mistake is powerful. It's the kind of thing that makes you reconsider everything. But Sarah Jo Pinder has spent 25 years in prison. She's earned two associate degrees. She's taken every class available. Georgetown students are making documentaries about her. Professors call her one of the smartest students they've ever taught. She's built a whole movement around the idea that she's a victim of a broken system.

7:47 December 5, 2025. Pinder appears before Judge James Snyder. She's asking to run her sentences concurrently instead of consecutively. If he grants it, she walks free immediately. Witnesses testify about her transformation. Her father talks about the love she shared with her late wife Amanda Dixon, who died of cancer in 2024. A documentary filmmaker says Pinder inspired her. Pinder speaks to the families of Andrew Cattaldy and Trisha Nordman. She says, "I'm so sorry for the terrible loss you suffered and for the role I played in it." The role she played in it, not "I'm sorry I helped kill them." The role she played. Everyone is moved. Everyone thinks she deserves another chance.

8:32 Sarah Jo Pinder is not innocent. She bought the gun. She helped dump the bodies. She escaped from prison. Those are facts. The question is whether she planned the murders or reacted to them. Whether she manipulated Richard Hall into killing two people or whether Hall acted alone. And I think personally the answer is in the pattern. She found a violent man who could be controlled. She armed him. She was there when it happened. She helped cover it up. She manipulated a prison guard. She manipulated a judge into considering her release. Maybe 25 years is enough. Maybe she's genuinely changed. Maybe people deserve second chances. Or maybe Sarah Jo Pinder is exactly what Larry Cells called her the first time. A brilliant, manipulative person who uses other people to do violence. Charles Manson never pulled the trigger himself either. The hearing is ongoing. We'll see what the judge decides. But when you look at this case, when you really look at it, you have to wonder if the prosecutor was wrong about being wrong because the evidence keeps pointing in the same direction. And it's been pointing there for 25 years.

9:48 Thanks for listening to 10 Minute Murder, Bingeable True Crime Stories. I'm Joe, I'm the host. And let's get to a couple of emails. First one, Subjects. Just wanted to say this. Joe, you managed to talk about dark stuff without feeling exploitive, which is harder than people think. I don't know how intentional that is, but it comes through. Thanks for that. Monica and Santa Fe, New Mexico. Monica, thank you for the email and I really appreciate you saying that because that is a conscious effort throughout every single episode. I tried to not be exploitive. I don't want it to feel that way in any way, shape, or form. I'm just telling stories here. Now occasionally, like in today's story, I will offer my opinion on the story, but not in an exploitive way. Second email, Subject True Crime Social DeLemma.

10:52 Hi, Joe. I love your show, but I never know how to explain it to people who don't listen to True Crime. It's short murder stories. Doesn't always land well. Any tips? Brian in Carter's ville, Georgia. Brian, rather you may be barking up the wrong tree here. I think at this day and age, True Crime is such a massive, massive genre that you're either into it or you're not. People who currently are not into True Crime, you're not going to be able to convince them, I think, into listening to stories about True Crime. Now, if they're interested in True Crime, short murder stories probably is the best way to describe this podcast. Ten minutes limits me so that I can't tell you every single detail of every single case, but I like to think that I do a good job of getting to the meat of the story and tell you the details that matter, the most interesting parts of the case, the twists, the turns, everything that you would want to hear in the episode. So I think if it doesn't land well, if you're trying to convince someone to listen to this podcast that doesn't like True Crime, it's probably a no-go. But listen, I really do appreciate your efforts. Hey, if you're a brand new listener to this podcast, I'm assuming that you're into True Crime. Hopefully you're into bingeable True Crime stories. Make sure you hit subscribe wherever you're listening right now. You can go to 10minuteMurder.com. Several things you can do there, including sign up for the newsletter. You can see all the places to follow on social media. Also, check out the Murder Blog that's there on 10minuteMurder.com. You can also go to the website and send me an

12:25 email like Brian and Monica did today. And that is going to do it. That is your episode for today. Thank you again for listening to 10 Minute Murder. See you next time.