Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Sept. 14, 2023

Sheila LaBarre - God's Avenging Angel

Sheila LaBarre - God's Avenging Angel
Sheila LaBarre - God's Avenging Angel
10 Minute Murder
Sheila LaBarre - God's Avenging Angel

After being abused as a child, Sheila LaBarre believed that she was an avenging angel, sent to Earth by God to get revenge against pedophiles…but the men that she lured to her farm and murdered were innocent.

SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you...

After being abused as a child, Sheila LaBarre believed that she was an avenging angel, sent to Earth by God to get revenge against pedophiles…but the men that she lured to her farm and murdered were innocent.

SUBSCRIBE
to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.

10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com


Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder

Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder



This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement

0:13 Discretion is advised. This is ten minuted murder. Kenneth County met Sheila Labar in two thousand and six through a personal lad posted in the newspaper. Now, if you're younger than a certain age, that one sentence can be pretty confusing. Before tender and bumble and hinge, people met people through newspaper personal ads. Apparently their first date was on Valentine's Day, which is pretty bold, and only a few days later, Sheila asked Kenneth to move in with her, which he accepted. At twenty four years old. Kenneth was more than twenty years younger than Sheila. He was known to have a low eye que that made him behave in a way that his family described as childlike.

1:14 He didn't question why Sheila had asked him to move in so quickly with her. Instead, he was excited to start a new life with the older woman he was smitten with. Kenneth had always been a trusting guy, someone who saw the best in everyone, and that included Sheila. Sheila did not share Kenneth's optimism. She spent her childhood being abused both physically and sexually by her father and his friends, and as an adult she struggled to have normal relationships with others. She had been married and divorced several times, and when her most recent wealthy partner suddenly died suspiciously, Sheila had inherited his farm in New Hampshire, the same farm where she'd invited Kenneth to live with her. The last time Kenneth was ever seen alive, he was in a wheelchair being pushed through a nearby walmart by Sheila. The store's employees, who had met the couple before, noticed that Kenneth was very pale and appeared to be ill, and that he had a large amount of bruises and cuts on his arms, hands, and face. Shortly afterward, Sheila phoned the local police station and played them a strange audio recording in which Kenneth appeared to admit that he was a pedophile. The police weren't convinced that this call was credible, but because they were familiar with Sheila and her erratic behavior, it did make them concerned for Kenneth's safety. Later that week, police arrived at Sheila's home to do a welfare check on Kenneth, but it was too late. Sheila Labar took

2:45 advantage of my son. Kenneth's mother said he was a kind, caring, gentle young man who could not socially defend himself. She was a master of evil who deliberately tortured him. Sheila Labar stripped my son of all of his dignity and self worth, and in the end she murdered him. When the officers arrived at the farm, they saw Sheila standing over a burn pile of garbage. The officers believed that they saw a large bone and maybe a pair of shoes in the pile, making them even more concerned for Kenneth, But when Sheila asked them to leave the property, they apparently had no choice. Without her consent, they couldn't investigate any further without a search warrant, even though they had a reason to believe that she was currently in the process of disposing of human remains. They came back later with a warrant, but by then Sheila had been able to destroy most of that evidence, and the large bone and sneakers were nowhere to be found. Investigators were faced with the task of searching Sheila's farm for evidence, all one hundred fifteen acres of it.

3:50 They found hundreds of rabbits, running wild inside the house, which is weird but not a crime, I guess. But they also located Kenneth's bone fragments, blood spatter in multiple rooms, a charred mattress covered in bloodstains, burnt hedge clippers and pruning shears, and a knife that had been partially melted in the fire. But when they drained the septic tank, they found a birth certificate belonging to a missing man, Sheila's previous boyfriend, Michael Deloche, who had been last seen in two thousand and five. She had attempted to get rid of this evidence by flushing it down the toilet. Like Kenneth, Michael had lived at the farm with Sheila. The last person to see him before his disappearance was a farmhand who had seen Michael being beaten by Sheila. Shortly afterwards, that same farmhand saw Sheila setting fire to a mattress outside of the farmhouse, and he never saw Michael again. Forensic analysis of dried blood in Sheila's bedroom was tested against a sample of Michael's mother's blood, and it was a match. Sheila filed for an insanity defense in resp bons to the murder charge against her, but she also decided to waive indictment and plead not guilty to another crime, the two thousand five murder of Michael Deloge. Possibly this was more of a risk than Sheila realized at the time. If she was found to be sane, she faced life behind bars. Because Sheila had now pled not guilty by reason of insanity to both crimes, she had officially implicated

5:24 herself and Michael's death as well as Kenneth's, there would be no chance for her to argue that she had not been the one to kill Michael. She could do was argued that it had been because of her mental illness. That meant that at trial, the prosecution didn't need to prove that she had killed both men, They only needed to convince the jury that she had not been insane. Sheila's defense attorneys argued that she had been severely mentally ill and that her mental illness had led her to kill both men. Several recordings that Sheila had made were played for the jury, including recordings of her attempting to interrogate Michael and Kenneth about their supposed pedophilia. A forensic psychologist testifying for the defense stated that the recording showed that Sheila suffered from delusions or a schizophrenic disorder, which had caused her strong belief that Michael and Kenneth were pedophiles. The psychologists also shared that Sheila believed she had been resurrected by God after she almost died.

6:21 After overdosing on prescription medication and taking her car out for a drive, Sheila passed out and crashed, spending more than a week comatose in the hospital. During that coma, Sheila had a vision. She believed that she had died, and when she woke up, she was sitting at the table surrounded by bearded men, one of whom she believed was God. God told Sheila that he was going to send her back to Earth as an avenging angel because she hadn't completed her life's purpose. He ordered her to get revenge on the kind of men that had abused her throughout her childhood by hunting down, torturing, and killing pedophiles. Throughout the investigation, police found no evidence that either Michael or Kenneth were attracted to children or engaged in any pedophilic activities at all.

7:11 Sheila's defense attorneys used this as a part of their argument insisting that there was no way that Sheila could have become convinced that both men were pedophiles if she were sane. The forensic psychologist for the state testified about his assessment of Sheila. He told the court that he had interviewed Sheila for several hours at a time on three separate occasions, and that he had also done an in depth review of Sheila's case file more than eight thousand pages. During this assessment, he'd found plenty of disturbing information about Sheila. She suffered from fits of rage and had a long standing obsession with pedophilia and pedophiles, and the forensic psychologists admitted that Sheila's obsession may have led to isolated psychotic episodes, but he did not believe that there was sufficient evidence that Sheila murdered her victims due to mental ill The forensic psychologist played the court snippets from some of his interviews with Sheila, and one recording, Sheila states that Kenneth's death had been an accident and that she had decided to burn his body to prevent his mother from seeing it, not because she was trying to hide evidence. In another recording, Sheila states that she was essentially forced to murder Michael because he was terrorizing her by torturing and killing her pet rabbits, a completely different story from Sheila's previous insistence that she'd killed Michael because he was a pedophile. Sheila answered questions well, she tried to explain away evidence that made her look bad. The forensic psychologist said, that is not what someone sees over many hours in a person

8:43 who is psychotic. On the twentieth of June two thousand and eight, the jury reached their verdict after thirteen hours of deliberation. They found that, despite her claims, Sheila Labar had been sane at the time she killed both Michael and Kenneth. In response, the two victims families began to clap and cheer. Kenneth's mother, Carolyn said, this is for my son. For two years, my son cannot rest. Now he can rest. Many people involved in the case believe that Michael and Kenneth weren't Sheila's only victims. Although Sheila has denied any role in the mysterious death of her previous partner, Bill, his death conveniently resulted in Sheila taking ownership of his farm, and during the search of Sheila's property, investigators discovered another piece of evidence, the skeletal remains of three human toes. Forensic testing revealed that the toes did not belong to either of Sheila's confirmed victims, but the DNA of the toes didn't match any profiles that the police had on file. Either someone conveniently died on the farm, only leaving three toes behind, or all of Sheila's crimes have yet to be discovered. That is Ten Minute Murder for today Brief and been Jible True Crime. I'm Joe the host, and thank you for listening today. If you're new to Ten Minute Murder, I appreciate you taking the time out of your day to check it out. Hope you enjoyed it. If you did, please subscribe You can more easily catch up on all the back episodes and

10:16 also when you open the app wherever you'd like to listen to the podcast. When you open the app, it's right there waiting for you. You don't have to go searching for it every single time. Connect with me on social media see the pictures of what we're talking about here on the podcast. It's never gross and graphic stuff though, if you'd like to contact me. My email address is Joe at ten minute Murder dot com. And if you like this episode, please leave a rating and review on Apple, Spotify, Audible, any place that's possible. I really do appreciate your positive feedback and our email. Question today, Joe, in your opinion, why do you think there were so many more known serial killers in the seventies, eighties, and even nineties than there are now? Macy and Lewisburg And I tell you, Macy, I think it's because of technology and investigation techniques that are used by law enforcement. There's so much better than they were in the past. Killers during those years, during those eras were able to go on longer and find more victims before police were able to figure out who they were and where they were. Now, I think that after one or two murders, technologies become so advanced that they get caught themselves. They do stupid things they make them get caught. There are obviously exceptions to that, because you still hear about it from time to time, and many of those cases that you hear about are the serial killers that are targeting sex workers or addicts on the street.

11:35 Those don't seem to get investigated with the same vigor as a missing white suburban housewife. But for the record, I'm no expert in the area of police investigation technology or techniques from then to now, so this is just me hazarding and educated guests based on the hundreds and hundreds of cases that I've read. Okay, that'll do it for this episode. Thank you so much for listening to ten minute Murder