Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Aug. 29, 2024

Snakes, Lies, and Murder: The Ben Renick Story

Snakes, Lies, and Murder: The Ben Renick Story
Snakes, Lies, and Murder: The Ben Renick Story
10 Minute Murder
Snakes, Lies, and Murder: The Ben Renick Story

Snakes, Lies, and Murder: The Ben Renick Story

In this episode, we delve into the chilling and twisted story of Ben Renick, a renowned snake breeder found dead in his Missouri home, surrounded by his prized reptiles. Initially suspected to be a...

Snakes, Lies, and Murder: The Ben Renick Story

In this episode, we delve into the chilling and twisted story of Ben Renick, a renowned snake breeder found dead in his Missouri home, surrounded by his prized reptiles. Initially suspected to be a tragic accident involving one of his snakes, the investigation takes a dark turn as secrets about his wife, Lynlee, begin to unravel. From financial woes to infidelity and a shocking murder plot, this case is packed with jaw-dropping revelations. Join us as we explore how love, greed, and betrayal led to the tragic demise of the "Rock Star" of the reptile world.


Thank you so much for listening to and supporting 10 Minute Murder!

SUBSCRIBE
to 10 Minute Murder.
Have friends that also like true-crime stories?
SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to read about new episodes and see visuals that go along with the story.

10minutemurder.com

email: joe@10minutemurder.com
_______
Follow 10 Minute Murder-

Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Threads:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

If you have a request for a case to be featured on 10 Minute Murder, or have any questions for Joe (the host), please feel free to send them to the email address above.

*******



Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/10-minute-murder--4603604/support.

0:44 June seventeenth, twenty seventeen, in Montgomery County, Missouri, law enforcement responded to a nine to one one call that you just don't see every day. As they pulled into a farm sprawling over seventy two acres, they found the owner lying in a pool of his own blood. This man was Ben Rennick, the bonafide rock star of the reptile world, who had over three thousand snakes surrounding him in various cages and displays. As if that didn't make this case unique enough, it was more than likely that one of these snakes was still on the loose and could potentially strike again. But Ben had his reasons. Aside from a burning passion for having so many dangerous animals in the middle of his home, Benrinnick was actually an internationally renowned snake breeder. What it started as an interest when he was only a child had quickly blossomed into a booming business.

1:39 Ben was doing stuff nobody had seen before. Friend and fellow breeder David Levinson later spoke to the press he had a lot of world's firsts over the years. Through his company Rennick Reptiles Ink, Ben bred snakes with unique colored combinations and patterns, essentially filling a hole in the market for bespoke designer pets and reptiles. His animals usually sold for upwards of one hundred thousand dollars and went from everywhere in the States to all the way across the ocean to Japan. Maybe needless to say that when Ben's wife, Linley and his brother Sam called the police after the discovery of his body, the blame almost immediately went to one of these prized reptiles. My brother's skull was crushed. Sam later said it had to have been a snake, he told the nine one one operator over the phone. Investigators rushed to the scene and pronounced Ben Rennick dead. He was twenty nine years old at the time.

2:35 During the then desperate search to locate and secure the dangerous snake believed to have killed him, a grief stricken Linley explained what had happened. She claimed to have come home and found Ben lying in a pool of his own blood. Not knowing what else to do, she then called her brother in law Sam and asked for help. It had been Sam's idea to call in law enforcement and seek aid in capturing the snake that had killed his brother. In my wildest dreams, I would have never imagined someone would hurt Ben. Sam later spoke to the press, but the investigators quickly ruled out that Ben's death had been an accident. Lying on the shelf above Ben's body was a discharged shell casing, and the investigators would quickly find more. It turned out that Ben had been shot eight times. One of those had been in the head, which had then caused the initial false impression that his skull had been crushed. The investigators quickly turned their attention from locating a deadly snake to finding Ben's real killer.

3:35 They first held his brother Sam as the prime suspect after discovering disputes that the two men had been having over the Rennick farm and property. But there was another big contender in this arena, Ben's wife, Linley. Ben and Linley had known each other since they were teenagers, but they had parted ways, only to reconnect again in twenty eleven. They were married three years later and had a child together. As threw herself into helping Ben develop his snake breeding business. By twenty seventeen, Ben had made a million dollar deal that included the sale of some pythons and anacondas, and it looked like the young family would be set for life with one successful business under their belts. Linley then wanted to try her hand at running her own business.

4:20 She and Ben opened up a spa called Essentia Spa, Inc. And established themselves as the couple to be in Montgomery County. Only things are never quite as they seem on the surface. Investigators quickly uncovered Facebook messages between the couple where they were arguing about finances and Linley's mismanagement of the spa. It turned out that Linley was way behind on her loan, her rent, and staff payments, and now her business was throwing the entire financial stability of the family into jeopardy. Sensing a potential motive for murder, the police questioned Lindley. They even tested her hands for gunshot residue, but the tests came back negative. It looked like the investigation had been barking up the wrong tree. Linley was released and the investigation continued, and then detectives uncovered another string of messages between Ben and Linley. It turned out that only three years into their marriage, Linley had cheated on Ben with multiple men from the messages between them, it looked like Ben had been suspicious about Linley and her infidelity, but had no proof. At the time, the Montgomery County couple to be was actually falling apart of the seams, and then the investigators heard a statement from a SPA employee that added fuel to the growing fire. It turned out that a month before Ben had been murdered, Linley had come into work and opened up about some of her most painful secrets. She claimed that Ben was abusing her and that she didn't see a way out of

5:51 her marriage. Desperate to help her friend and boss, this SPA employee had then agreed to do something heinous. She and Lindley laced a protein shake with fifteen percocet pills and gave it to Ben. Ben was poisoned. He became incredibly sick, but miraculously he survived this murder attempt. He then went on about his life, unaware of the fact that he was living with someone who had literally just tried to kill him. But the investigators would only find out about this attempt on Ben's life much further along the course of the investigation. For the moment and the initial period after Ben's death. Ben's friends and family, especially those who knew him from the reptile community, were left reeling from the sudden loss. They raised money to help support Ben's family and his prize possessions his snakes to see that they went to good homes and reptile experts within the community. But on the flip side of the coin, only two weeks after the death of her husband, Linley made preparations to sell the Rennick farm. This action in and of itself tells us that she was in a bit of a hurry to financially cash in on her husband's death, but that wasn't the only thing that she did.

7:04 Mere days after Ben had been murdered, Linley was on the phone to the insurance company asking how she could claim on Ben's million dollar life insurance policy. She was now looking less like a grief stricken widow and more like a prime suspect in the death of her husband. She was interviewed a total of six times and even took a polygraph test. She unsurprisingly failed a polygraph, but that alone isn't enough for law enforcement to arrest or charge her with murder. With the detective severely lacked was physical evidence, and it would take three long years for there to be any movement in the case. But it started with a tip that came from a jail cell.

7:45 A witness claimed to have overheard a conversation about Linley killing Ben with the help of one of her ex boyfriends, a man named Michael Humphrey. That wasn't much to go by, but it was enough to arrest both Lindley and and Michael on suspicion of murder. In the hot seat once again, this time, Linley surprisingly cracked. She told investigators that she had asked Michael to go with her to the farm that day. It turned out that she was finally going to pull the plug on her marriage, and she wanted back up just in case things turned sour. Linley claimed that she had no idea that Michael had been carrying a weapon that day. It had never been the plan to kill or even hurt Ben, but during the course of the argument, Michael had drawn his weapon and shot her husband. As you can imagine, Michael had a very different version of events. He did admit that he'd shot Ben that day, but it had actually been Linley who fired the killing shot. Exactly which one of them was telling the truth didn't seem to matter much. In the end, the jury found them both guilty of second degree murder and sent them both to prison. Michael received a life sentence. Linley, Ben's wife, the mother of his child and maybe the mastermind behind the entire plot, received sixteen years. At a Boom County John sentenced Linley Rennick to sixteen years in prison after she was convicted of killing her husband, Ben Renick in twenty seventeen. ABC seventeen's Laylah Mitchell is live

9:16 from the Boone County Courthouse. She covered this case from start to finish. Laila Ben Rennick's brother spoke for the first time this whole case. Devin Lucas. Emotions were high in the courtroom today as Sam Rennick told the court how Linley's choices and actions have affected their family since twenty seventeen, and Judge Kevin Crane did not take today lately and even had words for Lindley at the end of the sentencing. Last month, a jury sentenced Lindley to thirteen years in prison for second degree murder and three years for armed criminal action. Today, Judge Kevin Crane, agreeing with the jury, sentenced Lindley to sixteen years in prison. Flint's count one thirteen years, Count two three years said sentences to run consecutively. Ben's brother Sam spoke to the judge and the court for the first time, asking for the maximum possible sentence. And she murdered my brother to profit from his death. Lenny Rennick is a murderer. She will always be a murderer. Linley maintains that she did not kill Ben, but that her ex boyfriend Michael Humphrey shot him in twenty seventeen. During Linley's three day trial in December, Humphrey told a different story.

10:32 Whatever phrase she used, you understand it to mean. What talking about killing Ben? What did you tell her about your acknowledge willingness killer? I'm not in on my that Today. The defense asked the judge for a ten year sentence. Injury by finding murder of a second degree, rejecting the fact that this was a premeditated burder. The prosecution, like Sam, asked the judge for the maximum prize for her children, her family, those things d and Judge Crane had this message for Lindley. You're awful lucky ma'am. You're gonna get out in your forties and my forties work too bad. I just hope you don't kill again.

11:15 That's it. That is ten minute Murder for today, brief and binge able true crime. I'm Joe. I'm the host, and thank you so much for taking the time to listen to the podcast. If you are a brand new listener, welcome to ten Minute Murder. I'm super happy that you've decided to listen to the podcast today. If you enjoy it, subscribe and that will more easily help you catch up on all the back episodes and hear the new ones as soon as they come out. Once you've subscribed, follow ten Minute Murder anywhere that you are on social media links or the show notes, or you can go to ten minute Murder dot com to find links for every place that you can follow the podcast. Tell your friends and family also about ten minute Murder. Let them know it's a brief and bingeable true crime podcast. So if they've got ten minutes to listen, they can get an episode in. If they've got to I don't know, like thirty minutes, they can get three episodes in. And I'm not trying to mansplain math, but I think you get the picture, and may be the most important request is if you listen in a place that allows ratings and reviews like Apple or Spotify. Please, if you enjoy the podcast, give ten Minute Murder five stars. That helps the show reach more and more people. And that's it. That's your episode for today. Thank you so much for listening to ten Minute Murder.

Related to this Episode

Snakes, Lies, and Murder: The Ben Renick Story

The Murder of Ben Renick: Snake Breeder, Millionaire, and a Deadly Betrayal June 17th, 2017, in Montgomery County, Missouri, law enforcement responded to a 911 call that you just don’t see every day. As they pulled into a farm sprawling over sevent…