Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Aug. 24, 2023

The Chicago Tylenol Murders

The Chicago Tylenol Murders
The Chicago Tylenol Murders
10 Minute Murder
The Chicago Tylenol Murders

Four decades ago, Chicago was rocked by a seemingly senseless crime. The Chicago Tylenol Murders took place in 1982. Seven people died in the area as a result of Tylenol Extra Strength gelatin capsules being laced with potassium cyanide.

SUBSCRIBE...

Four decades ago, Chicago was rocked by a seemingly senseless crime. The Chicago Tylenol Murders took place in 1982. Seven people died in the area as a result of Tylenol Extra Strength gelatin capsules being laced with potassium cyanide.

SUBSCRIBE
to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.

10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com

HelloFresh FREE Shipping and 50% OFF:
hellofresh.com/10minmurder50

(enter code: 10MinMurder50)

Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder

Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder



This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement

0:02 Discretion is advised. This is ten minted murder. We hear about crimes and murders every day. The wife that found out her husband was having an affair and she shot him. The driver that get robbed making a delivery in a neighborhood known for shady activity. The man that let his anger get the best of him and pulled someone out of their car in a fit of road rage after they cut him off. Every incident, while terrible, both plays on our fears and gives us a false sense of security. We know what to expect in those situations. The who, what, where, and why they can all be answered. But what about when? The why was simply to create chaos? What about when the who, what, when, and where didn't make any difference. More than likely you've watched the Batman movies. The Cape Crusader that was able to solve every crime and figure out the riddles.

1:12 His mental capabilities even exceeded his physical strength. But even he met a criminal he just couldn't make sense of. In the movie The Dark Night, Alfred, who always seemed to know the right thing to say, no matter the circumstances, made an observation, while bone chilling, It's true, he said, some men just want to watch the world burn. Four decades ago, Chicago was rocked by seemingly senseless crimes. The Chicago thailan All murders took place in nineteen eighty two. Seven people died in the area as a result of thailan All extra strength gelatine capsules being laced with potassium cyanide. The first death reported was a twelve year old girl. Her parents gave her tailan all because she had a sore throat, which is what most would do. She was dead by the next morning. Of course, no one knew the cause of death in that moment. Luckily, no one else in her house took the tailan All before the paramedics got there and bagged it up. But not every family was that fortunate. A twenty seven year old polster worker took thailan All at home, and initially his death was thought to be a heart attack.

2:22 His brother and sister in law were distraught. They rushed over to the house upon hearing the news, and that day's events had their heads throbbing. The stress of it caused them to have headaches, so they did what any of us would do. They took Taylan All. They both died. Arlington Heights. Only public health official was sent to the crime scene to look around. She found the bottle on the counter and counted the capsules. There were forty four. Six had been taken, probably two by each of the three victims in that house. The bottle made its way to the Deputy Chief Medical Examiner. He immediately noticed that it had an almond like scent common with cyanide.

3:02 He asked the chief toxicologist to test the capsules. All forty four capsules tested contained fatal amounts of cyanide. Every single capsule in that bottle was potentially fatal. Police watched the graves and the funerals and hopes that whoever committed the crime would show up at one of the scenes, but no one that raised red flags did. The bottles purchased could not even be linked to a single store. The contaminated bottles had been bought from different businesses. Originally, they thought the bottles were all from the same lot, but soon they realized that they were multiple lots involved. A recall was issued on every bottle of thailan Al extra strength gelatine capsules in the Chicago area. It was one of the largest pharmaceutical recalls at the time. Johnson and Johnson, Thailanall's manufacturer, warned hospitals and distributors of the evolving crisis. They even stopped production of the product until more was learned. Then a new case popped up in California that was a long way from the cases they thought were contained to Chicago. This time, the thailand All had STRYCT nine in it. Johnson and Johnson made the decision to recall the product nationwide on October fifth, nineteen eighty two, and estimated thirty one million bottles were in circulation at the time. The cost of the product recall was over one hundred million dollars equivalent to well over three hundred million today. They even did some advertising to discourage people from consuming the product while

4:32 the source of the poison was being investigated. Market shares collapsed. The list of side effects and warnings on most medications is alarming, and yet with all the negative possibilities, they're promoted, advertised, and often praised. Maybe they're amazing, maybe they're not, but the manufacturers have no plans to slow down productions and sales. Now, obviously, the situation was different since they couldn't pinpoint the cause of the poison and peop were dying. But for Johnson and Johnson to actually put out advertising against their own product it seemed like financial suicide. Yet they were praised for their response to the crisis. Their honesty through public relations was something rarely seen. They demonstrated how a major business could properly handle a devastating disaster, and within a few years they once again held the highest market share for over the counter analgesus in the United States. The investigation led to the conclusion that the bottles had been tampered with after they had already been placed on shelves, not during production. They hypothesized that someone took them from the shelves, added potassium cyanide through the gelatine capsule, and returned them to be purchased and consumed by unknown customers. Now, if someone had been trying to buy Thailand all and return it all over town, someone would have noticed and questions would have been asked. So had the person or persons been stealing the bottles then casually placing them back into locations. A man named James William Lewis sent a letter to Johnson and Johnson, claiming responsibility for the deaths

6:06 and demanding a million dollars to stop. He lived in New York City and the police couldn't connect him to the crimes. He was, however, charged with extortion and spent some time in prison. A bar owner named Marty Sinclair reported that one of his patrons could be the suspect. Roger Arnold, frequented the bar and had made comments that led Sinclair to believe that he was guilty of the crimes. When the police searched Arnold's house, they found a book called The poor Man's James Bond, which contained instructions for making potassium cyanide, but they didn't find anything linking him to the actual crime. After the investigation, Arnold waited with a gun in hand for Sinclair. When he stepped out, he shot and killed him. Only it wasn't Sinclair, it was a random, innocent man. So both possible suspects ended up in prison, but neither for the crimes the police were originally investigating. With no one in custody, who's to say that the crisis had ended. Over the next few years, hundreds of copycats emerged involving over the counter medications perhaps all the perpetrators were hoping that the original individual would take the blame for another crime committed. I'm sure to them it seemed like a good plan, But instead, many of those murders were solved and quite a few scorned lovers ended up in prison.

7:28 When thailand All Extra Strength was finally reintroduced to the market, it was triple sealed to prevent tampering. A terrifying string of events led to reforms and packaging over the counter drugs and federal anti tampering laws. In nineteen eighty three, it was made a federal offense to tamper with products meant for consumption. In nineteen eighty nine, new guidelines for packaging of products meant for consumption were put into place. In nineteen ninety one, Johnson and Johnson reached an undisclosed sum to be paid out to the family of the individuals that died in Chicago. The agreement was not the business taking responsibility for the deaths, but rather wanting to help the families and encouraging everyone to put the terrible events behind them.

8:11 In twenty ten, with new DNA testing methods available, they once again tested the DNA from Arnold and Lewis against the DNA found on the taylan All bottles. They were not a match. Not only was it disappointing that they didn't match, but if the person that committed the crime had ever been convicted of another crime, their DNA should be in the system. So to have the DNA on the bottles but never being able to link it to a person is a mystery in itself. Did the individual never commit another crime or did they become more careful with their methods to not leave any evidence behind. It leaves the big question what was the motive behind the Chicago murders? Was therein intended victim and all the other casualties were just unfortunate mishaps. There's still not a definite answer, though it does raise other questions. How many items are in our cabinets, pantries and refrigerators that could have been tampered with without us even knowing. They never did charge anyone with the crimes. When we think about what it takes to get a product from production to market, there could be endless possibilities. The product starts in a facility, goes through a warehouse and packaging, and get shipped and delivered and stocked and picked up and put down by consumers until finally purchased and handed to a cashier. It makes you stop and think that our society must be extremely trusting in people when we think about the amount of hands that have contact with any given product. Maybe we should just hope that most people are good and honest, because it seems that the

9:41 hands that caused the Chicago tail in all murders just wanted to spark chaos and watch it burn. That's ten minute Murder for today, brief and bingeable true crime. My name is Joe. I'm the host of this podcast, and I really appreciate you taking the time to listen and stop right now what you're doing for a moment. Take a look at where you're listening to this podcast. Are you subscribed? If you're a brand new listener to ten minute Murder, that's cool. Make sure you do that now so that you don't miss any future episodes of ten Minute Murder, and it makes it easier to go back and listen to previous episodes of ten Minute Murder. Now. If you're an og listener of this podcast and you're not subscribed, I don't know what to tell you. I hate telling people that they're doing things wrong, but you're doing things wrong. Instead of searching for the podcast every time you want to listen to it, if you hit subscribe right now, it'll always be there. Now, some of the apps that you listen in don't always make it easy to find the subscribe button. I'll give you that because it doesn't always say subscribe for some reason. It might say collect or follow or any number of things, but something that kind of means subscribe. Push that button, and if you've been listening for a long time and you're already subscribed, I will love you for the rest of my life. The end, And quickly, let me talk about something that was on my mind during the majority of me telling that story. Just now, what keeps us, us normal

11:15 human beings from doing bad things to other human beings? Because most of us don't necessarily calls harm to other people intentionally on a day to day basis, But why what keeps us from doing that? For some of us, it's religion. For others, it's just because it's bad karma. For me personally, I think I just feel empathetic when it comes to other people, even if you're a piece of trash. I feel bad that you're a piece of trash. And there is a religious element in there for me, and there's also a karma element for me. And that's where I'm getting to when I'm talking about what was going through my head, this entire story that I was telling it, and it's one line from a song. I was singing the whole song in my head, but one line of it is the reason karma is a relaxing thought. And yes, that's a Taylor Swift song, but karma is a relaxing thought because if you believe that karma is a real thing, and you actively try to be a decent person, then karma is a relaxing thought. You don't have to get even with other people. You don't have to go out of your way to ruin someone's day because they harmed you in some way. Karma is a relaxing thought. Okay, now that I'm quoting Taylor Swift, I think it's probably time to end this episode for today.

12:30 Thank you so much for listening to ten Minute Murder