The Church Punishment
After they killed their eight-year-old son, Sonya and Joseph Smith never lost the support of their church. But did the Remnant Fellowship Church’s teachings lead to Josef Smith Jr.’s death?
SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also...
SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.
10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com
Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder
Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/
TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder
Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder
Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw
Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement
0:07 Discretion is it vised ten minute murders. In October of two thousand and three, a little boy died in Atlanta. His parents, Sonia and Joseph Smith, called nine one one from their family home, telling the operator that their son, eight year old Joseph Junior, was unresponsive. According to Joseph Senior, he'd gone to pick Joseph Junior up and noticed that the child was extremely sweaty and warm and he wasn't waking up. Believing that his son might have just gotten to hot, he carried him to the homes car port and laid him on the cool concrete floor, hoping that that coldness would revive him.
1:07 When Joseph Junior remained unconscious, Joseph Senor called for the ambulance. Cobb County first responders arrived at the scene, where they found Joseph Junior lying flat on his back. He was not breathing, and they couldn't find a pulse. He was rushed to the children's hospital, where the staff desperately tried to save his life, but they were unable to revive him. The following day, he was pronounced dead, but it was immediately clear to the medical staff that Joseph Junior had not died because of overheating or any other natural cause. He had passed away as the result of severe, long term physical abuse. Joseph Senor and Sonia admitted that they'd sometimes physically punished Joseph Junior, including locking him in a closet alongside a picture of g and forcing him to pray for long periods of time, but they denied that they'd ever severely physically abused him.
2:07 The Smith's definition of severe abuse was questionable. Under the guise of discipline, they would hit Joseph with belts, glues, sticks, and coat hangers. Sonia said that a usual punishment session, the child being punished would receive ten blows at a time. Sometimes his older brother would be ordered to hold Joseph Junior down to prevent him from running away or shielding himself. They didn't just lock him in a closet for a few minutes. They would bind his hands together with rope and keep him in there for hours or even days at a time. During these periods of imprisonment, Joseph had no food, no water, and he was given a bucket to use if he needed to go to the toilet. On the day that the nine to one. One call was made. Joseph had been disciplined multiple times by his father, who had beaten his stomach with a glue stick. Later, Joseph Juran came back a dark brown color, and he began complaining about having a sore stomach. When Joseph Senior took a break from the discipline to have a shower, Sonia took over, beating Joseph Junior with the glue stick hard enough to draw blood even through his clothes. Their oldest son then forced Joseph into a small wooden box while still beating him, and then Sonia wrapped an extension cord around that box so that Joseph could not escape. It was only after Joseph Senior finished his shower
3:38 and tried to let his son out of the box that he realized that he was not breathing. One of the police officers who arrived at the crime scene later reported that shortly after he arrived, Joseph told him quote, I'm not going to lie to you. He's bruised. In December of two thousand and three, Sonia and Joseph Senior were arrested for Joseph Junior death, and they might have been accused of horrific child abuse and murder, but they still had a loyal group of supporters, and none were more loyal than their church. For the past three years, the Smiths had been regular members of the Remnant Fellowship Church. It was a fairly new church founded by author and dietitian Gwen Chamblin in nineteen ninety nine. The Remnant Fellowship's original followers were all people who had signed up for way Down Workshop, a popular Christian diet and weight loss program that Gwen started in nineteen eighty six. Gwenn's program was highly controversial and her book The Way Down Diet, she taught her readers to use Christianity as a weight loss method by attempting to transfer their love of food into the love of God. She also received a lot of criticism for attaching the label of christian to a weight loss business, and the finances behind her business were put under inve instigation in two thousand and one. But despite the controversy, the Way Down Workshop was incredibly popular. By late nineteen ninety eight, it had
5:08 over two hundred and fifty thousand participants across the United States, Canada, and Europe. It meant that By the time Gwynn decided to found the Remnant Fellowship Church, she already had a large group of loyal followers. People who have since left the Remnant Fellowship Church claimed that corporal punishment of kids was a regular discussed topic in church teachings about how to correctly discipline a child. The church's website contained a collection of testimonies from those who had been helped by their teachings, and one of the testimonies included details of how the church had encouraged them to punish their children. Quote I was hesitant and sometimes refused to properly discipline my children because I didn't want to hurt them or have them hate me, the testimony read, going on to claim that the member was now comfortable disciplining their children to save their souls from hell, rather than being concerned about their flesh. The leaders of the church did not deny that they approved corporal punishment, but insisted that they let parents decide how to discipline their own children, and that the church believed that hitting a child should only be a last resort.
6:19 Soon after Joseph Junior's death, the church purchased two web domains related to the case. The Smiths are Guilty dot com and the Smiths Are Innocent dot com. If anybody googled the case and clicked onto the Smiths Areguilty dot com, they were instantly redirected to the Smiths Are Innocent dot com, a website which the Remnant Fellowship dedicated to proving that Joseph Senior and Sonia had never abused their son. The website's intro currently reads, Joseph Smith Senior and Sonia Smith have been accused by the police as abusers within four minutes of a nine on one call placed frantically in October two thousand and three, as their son lay dying of a fast acting infection and septic shock as the child abuse seeds were planted. Throughout the investigation that followed Young Joseph Smith's untimely death, the media frenzy began after Young Joseph's autopsy. The Cobb County Medical examiners concluded that the child had died because of a combination of acute and chronic abuse, but they were unable to tell whether the cause of the death had been asphyxiation or blunt force trauma. But there was no evidence to support the church's argument that Joseph had actually died from a septic infection, which was caused by him scratching his exema. According to the medical examiners, there was absolutely no chance that Joseph's death had been accidental or natural death in any way. The state of the
7:53 boy's body, which witnesses later called one of the worst child abuse cases they had ever seen, proved that the death was a homicide. The Remnant Fellowship Church was raided by the police in two thousand and four, but they were unable to find any evidence that linked the church's teachings to Joseph's murder. During Joseph Senior and Sonia's trial, their older son, Michael Smith, testified about the events that led to Joseph Junior's death. He said that the punishment began when Joseph Junior had behaved disruptively while the rest of the family had been watching a broadcast from the Remnant Fellowship Church. According to Michael, his brother had been screaming, cursing, and carrying on as well as bothering his younger brother, two year old James, causing his parents to begin to beat him with the glue stick. And by the way, I've mentioned these glue sticks a number of times. They're not the small ones that go into these small craft glue guns. These are large glue sticks, like industrial sized glue sticks that they were using as a weapon. Afterwards, Joseph Sor and Sonia had ordered Michael to force Joseph Junior into the wooden chest. When Joseph Junior kept struggling to get free, Michael tied the chest shut to prevent him from escaping.
9:11 For about the first ten minutes that Joseph Junior had been trapped inside the chest, Michael said that his brother was yelling and swearing, saying, quote, I'm going to kill all U mfors when I get out, James is the first one on my list. I'm going to slit his throat. After that, Joseph Junior was silent. On February sixteenth, two thousand and seven, all twelve jury members were in agreement. The Smiths were both guilty of felony murder, false imprisonment, reckless conduct, and multiple counts of cruelty to children and aggravated assault. In court on the day that the jury eventually reached their verdict, the prosecutors dimmed the lights during their closing arguments and brought out a birthday cake. They lit the candles and began to sing Happy Birthday to a young boy who would never grow older. It was the sixteenth of February two thousand and seven, the day that Joseph Smith Junior would have turned twelve.
10:09 Both Sonia and Joseph received the maximum sentence of life in prison plus thirty years, and despite the unanimous verdict from the jury, the support from the church did not falter. To this day, the remnant Fellowship Church still stands by the Smith's innocence, collecting online donations on their behalf and paying for their legal fees, and throughout their incarceration, Joseph Sor and Sonya have remained loyal members. That is ten Minute Murder for Today, Brief and bingeable true Crime.
10:50 My name is Joe. I'm the host, and thank you for taking the time out of your day to listen to this podcast. If you're on to the next episode, you're doing a bing listen, don't let me stop you keep right on rolling. And if you're brand new here, welcome. I'm super happy that you're here. Make sure you hit the subscribe button wherever you like to listen to podcasts. Probably I'm not a psychic or anything, but I'm going to guess that you like listening to podcasts. Right here where you're listening right now, hit the subscribe button right now, and you'll more easily catch up on all the back episodes of ten Minute Murder. And if you follow on social media, follow the podcast on social media, you'll see the pictures of what we talk about here on the podcast. I don't post grossing graphic stuff though. And if one of those places you're listening happens to be Apple, Spotify or Audible, there's a place where you can rate and review, and I'd appreciate if you'd do that and your positive feedback. It helps this show grow, So thank you so much for doing that, and quickly a listener email today. Good evening, Joe. I've seen some of the videos that you were talking about last week where the people don't know that they're in a restaurant meant to harass the customers. That's like Dick's Last Resort is what they're talking about. It's fun and I laughed, but have you seen the video of the war happening right now between the otters and the Orangutanes at a zoo. It's hilarious. Here's the link, and then they put the link in there. And let me tell you, I've clicked this link.
12:15 It's a link to TikTok video. I laughed so hard I cried watching this, didn't I had no idea there was a secret war going on with the zoo between the orangutans and the otters. It's so funny. I'll try to remember to post the link, but in case I don't, someone reach out and let me know to post the link. I've got it right here. And by the way, that email is from Maria in Lansing, and Maria, thank you so much for your email. If you'd like to send me an email, you can do that. Joe at ten Minute Murder dot com. Joe at ten Minute Murder dot com. Okay, that's gonna do it. That's the episode for today. Thank you so much for listening to ten Minute Murder.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube