The Devil Is Good Looking Too
For his whole life, Shawn Grate was considered to be a handsome ladies man - but he used his good looks and charming personality to hide a dark secret.
SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this...
SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.
10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com
Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder
Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/
TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder
Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder
Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw
Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement
0:13 Discretion is advised. This is ten minuted murderer. Often the life stories of serial killers begin with tragic, dysfunctional upbringings, but the beginning of Shawn Michael Great's childhood was perfectly normal. Born in nineteen seventy six in Marion, Ohio, he did struggle in school was held back a grade, but he was also sporty. He was a social kid who got along well with others.
0:57 Then, as Sean grew older, things began to change. When Shawn was six years old, his parents got a divorce, and five years later, his mother, Teresa, abandoned her two children. She left them behind in Ohio with their father and moved to Kentucky to live with her new boyfriend. Sewn spent his teenage years resenting Theresa for this decision, and he indulged in elaborate fantasies about killing his mother and making her pay for what she had done. While Shawn and his brother were living with their father, Seawan began attending River Valley High School. At first, he continued using sports as an outlet for his feelings and became one of the school's best baseball players until he broke his arm. When the fracture was X rayed, doctors discovered a tumor, which required immediate surgery. After that, Shawn never played baseball again. From that point, Shawn's mental health took a turn. One of his high school girls friends remembered that he went through severe depressive episodes where he would lay on the couch for days. Once the episode was over, he'd continue with his life like nothing ever happened. Despite this, Sewn never had a hard time getting a date. His school friend Amy Smith, said Sean was charming, he was always smiling, and he had those big blue eyes. All the girls liked Sean. Sean might have been considered a heart throb, but he
2:29 wasn't a good boyfriend. As his relationships progressed, he became more and more jealous and controlling, and after a while, he'd eventually become violent. When he was eighteen years old, he was arrested for the first time after he grabbed a girlfriend by her neck during an argument. His next arrest came the following year, shortly after he graduated from high school, when he was caught breaking into a house. He was charged with a felony burglary and sent to four years in prison, but He ended up being released early. That time behind bars did not change Shawn. If anything, his violent behavior towards women only escalated after he was released in nineteen ninety seven. Two years later, Shawn's girlfriend reported him to the police, saying that he had choked her almost to the point of unconsciousness. The girl was seventeen years old and she was a few months pregnant with Shawn's child. Shawn's adult life continued the same way.
3:30 He was a ladies man, but he was a menace to the women he dated, often terrorizing his girlfriends and threatening them whenever they stood up to him. If there was one thing that Sean hated more than anything else, it was a woman who told him no. He briefly got married and became a father once again, but only a few months after the wedding, his wife had enough and she filed for divorce. On September thirteenth, twenty sixteen, a nine to one one call came through in Ashland, Ohio. A female caller claimed that she had been kidnapped two days ago, and since then her captiir had kept her tied to a bed, repeatedly raping her to protect the victim's identity. Her name was never released to the public and she was only known by the moniker Jane Doe. And Jane Doe was certain that she knew the identity of the kidnapper. In fact, he was somebody whom she'd been friends with for several months. She told the police that his name was Sean Michael Great and she had been held captive in the abandoned house that he was living in. The police rushed to that address that Jane was calling from, and they were able to save her and apprehend her captor. After her rescue, she revealed more details about her ordeal. She'd met Sean in the summer of twenty sixteen at the local community center and viewed him as an older brother type. The two of them often met up for lunch together or to go on walk where they would talk about the Bible. Jane had been aware
5:02 that Sean was romantically interested in her, but she dodged his advances and even refused his attempts to get her cell phone number. Then, on the eleventh of September, Sean invited Jane Doe to come over to a house in Ashland, where she began to read the Bible sewn left to go to the kitchen, and when he came back, Jane didn't recognize the man she'd come to view as a friend. His friendly demeanor had vanished, and he grabbed the Bible, saying quote, you're not going anywhere. When Jane continued resisting Sean's sexual advances, he physically overpowered her and tied her to the bed. Throughout the following days, Sean regularly retied Jane Doe into different weird positions. On one occasion, he told her that he'd positioned the ropes so that if she struggled, she would be strangled to death. When Sean fell asleep, Jane was able to free herself from the restraints managed to place that nine to one one call that saved her life. When the police arrived at the abandoned house where Sean kept Jane prisoner, they immediately noticed an unmistakable stench. The entire house was full of piles of trash, surrounded by swarming flies and maggots, But the smell wasn't coming from the trash. It was coming from the two decomposing bodies that Sean had hidden under piles of dirty laundry. Those bodies belonged to two young women, Elizabeth Griffin and Stacy Stanley. Both of them had been strangled to death, and Sean hadn't bothered to dispose of their bodies.
6:36 He'd just hidden them pretty badly and then gone on a hunt for his next victims. Seawan was then indicted for two counts of aggravated murder for Elizabeth and Stacy's death, as well as the sexual assault and abduction of Jane Doe, and lesser counts of tampering with evidence and breaking and entering. The defense filed a not guilty plea by reason of insanity. Meanwhile, the prosecution announced that they would be pushing for the death penalty. By his twenty eighteen trial, Shawn hadn't just confessed to the charges he was facing, He'd also claimed to have killed three other women. After Seawn revealed details about the additional murders to local news stations, the defense and prosecution joined forces to request a gag order that would prevent him from talking to the media throughout the trial. Shawn showed absolutely no remorse. The following month, he was found guilty of both murders and sentenced to death. In March twenty nineteen, Shawn pleaded guilty to murdering two other women, Rebecca Lacey in twenty fifteen and Candace Cuttingham in twenty sixteen.
7:47 He had dated Candace for several months and even lived with her for a while, and throughout their relationship he admitted to fantasizing about murdering her. Rebecca Lacey was also someone that Shawn knew personally, although he wasn't as close with her as he was with Candace, and all of his victims were killed in the same fashion. Strangled to death. Seawn gave investigators directions to Candace's body, which was found behind a burnt house in Madison Township. Rebecca's body had been found in twenty fifteen in a patch of woodland in Ashland County. Before Shawn's confession, Rebecca's death was believed to be an accidental overdose. Now police knew that Sean had killed her over a petty dispute. She allegedly had stolen four dollars from him and paid for it with her life. In September that same year, Seawn pleaded guilty to a fifth murder, a woman whose unidentified body had been found in Marion County in two thousand and six. Shawn's confession eventually led to the woman being identified as Dana Lowry, a twenty three year old mother of two. Shortly after his original trial, Shawn's attorney appealed him death sentence, but in twenty twenty the Ohio Supreme Court dismissed this appeal and upheld the sentence. As of October twenty twenty three, his execution is scheduled for the nineteenth of March twenty twenty five. At Shawn's second trial, the
9:18 family friend of one of his victims addressed him directly, saying, quote, you will die with a needle in your arm, with no more notoriety than a junkie who overdoses in an alley. You will die, you will burn, and you will be completely forgotten. Shawn's mother, Teresa, was approached by the media countless times after her son's arrest. Finally, she agreed to give one interview with The Daily Mail. She shared that she believed time behind bars had changed Sean into someone she didn't recognize, but she also believed that he had spent his life using his charming nature to get what he wanted. Quote. Yes, he's good looking, she said, but the devil good looking too. That's ten Minute Murder for today brief and binge able true crime.
10:18 I'm Joe, I'm the host, and I really appreciate you taking the time out of your day to listen to this episode. If you're brand new, I'm super excited that you're here. Hope you enjoyed the episode, and if you did, be sure to subscribe before you go. It more easily lets you catch up on the back episodes and find ten Minute Murder wherever you like to listen to podcasts. Connect with me on social media to see the pictures of what we talk about here on the podcast, and it's never gross or graphic stuff. Ratings and reviews help the show grow, so please do that. And finally, this is the first episode I'm doing in the month of November. Halloween just happened, and I need to ask a question, do we not do Halloween anymore? I bought a bucket of candy and was all ready for the trick or treaters. I don't We're not doing it anymore.
11:07 I guess there were like three kids, and at one point I made the executive decision to just not get my hopes up anymore, turned off the porch light, and I enjoyed the kit Kats and Snickers bars myself. I don't know, maybe I'm missing something somewhere. There might have been a news release that it was happening on a different day and I just wasn't paying attention to it. But three tricker treaters for an entire bucket of candy that I had, and I do the good stuff too. I wanted to be the house that has the full size bars, the ones when like I was a kid, I'd go back and say, Hey, go to this house. They've got the full size stuff over there. They're not messing around. I wanted to be that house. But three trick or treaters. Anyway, that's your episode for today. Thank you so much for listening to ten minute Murder.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube