The Drugs Made Me Kill Him
A nineteen-year-old boy murdered and mutilated his 36-year-old roommate. Once Stephen Starr was dead, Michael Anderson dialed 911 and told the operator what he had done.
SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime...
SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.
10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com
HelloFresh FREE Shipping and 50% OFF:
hellofresh.com/10minmurder50
(enter code: 10MinMurder50)
Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder
Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/
TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder
Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder
Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw
Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement
0:07 Discretion. Is it by him? Maybe murder? None of stephen Stars neighbors knew how long Stephen had been sharing his home with nineteen year old Michael Anderson. According to Michael, the two men had met at a local gay club in early twenty eleven, where thirty six year old Stephen invited Michael to come and stay with him. Nobody would ever know if Stephen would have told a different version of that story. On February thirteenth, twenty eleven, Michael logged into Facebook and made a post that said, quote, my killing starts tonight.
1:04 Later on, he made a second post, this one read I finally cracked guys, I really did it this time. The events that took place between those two Facebook posts ruined the lives of both people. Inside Steven's house. At four forty five in the morning, Michael picked up the phone and made a nine one one call Katava County nine one one. Um, I'd like to report on post. Okay, what's wrong? UM I took some pills and um the pills man to go mad, and UM I murdered a roommate. Have you murdered your roommate? Yes? Where are you at?
1:48 What's your address? Drove Patory, North Carolina. Okay, what do you mean you murdered your roommate? I showed them three times and I used the ax and utilizes his body. Okay. Where is your roommate now? Are you still in the house with him? Okay? What's your name? Michael Anderson? Okay, Michael? What what did you text? It made you do this? Uh? Um? Odid on miss the next dum dejection working um makes me uh feel a little weird. Not took too many. Okay. What is your roommate's name, Stephen Star And you said you shot him?
2:34 Yes? Okay, where is the gun at now? In your hand? Okay? I need you to put the gun somewhere. Okay, I don't know what to do. What Listen, I'm gonna stay on the phone with you. Okay, listen to me. I'm gonna stay on the phone with you. What part of the house are you in? I'm in the master bedroom? Okay? Where is your roommate at? Okay? I want can you take the gun and put it down on the floor and go to like is the is a living living room? Where the front door is? Oh? No, okay, where's your front door at? What part of the house. Oh right, as you um, right, as you walk up to you master bedroom and you turn right. Okay, okay, okay, can you lay the gun down on the floor. Um. I don't want you to have a gun in your hand. Okay, can you lay it down on the floor? Um? You know? Okay. Well, I'm gonna help you, okay, But what I need you to do is put that gun down. Okay. Okay, Well we're gonna get you some help. Okay. M pick them on this for a few wells, but I didn't think it matter. Okay, that's okay. I'm gonna help you.
4:10 Okay, So to get a little bet on your rooms kilping me. And then there's a killer room. I can't believe it's a killer rooms room. Okay, listen, I need you to put that gun down, okay, and I need you can you put it on the floor all right? Okay. Are you on a cordless phone or a cell phone that you can walk around the house? Okay. I want you to go to the room that is where the front door is. Okay. I'm gonna get some help out there for you, all right. Oh and amen, uh huh. Just some things to buddy that you don't want them to see. Okay, well, I've got you some help on the way out there. Okay, you do not want to know who it is. Okay, I want you to stay on the phone with me till they get there. Okay, all right, to a middle hospital. We're gonna get you some help. All right, We're gonna get you some help, I promise. Okay, just try to calm down like I'm having a tend. Okay, what you need to do. Take a deep breath. Take a deep breath and calm down.
5:15 And did you in your roommate get in an argument or this just happened? Um? Okay? We met at UM. I went to UM. I was straight, and I wanted to go UM a sexual, just the experiment. And I went to a close and I met him and went to his house and he took me in and I turned straight again, and he wanted to um touch me in south and I wouldn't let him, and he kept turning. I waited until he went to sleeping, and I showed him three times and I immutilated him very busy. I'm sorry, Oh god, WoT do you have anybody else in the house with you? No? Right home? Okay? On the phone with me. Okay, okay, is this a house or a noble hame or it's a double word, it's a double wide. Do you have any cars out in front? You'll go down a you'll turn out a church on a dirt road. To go down the dirt road, you'll go down to your turn and you'll turn in a dirt driveway, um where there'll be a green truck, a green truck, a little green truck. And if you look in the window, to be manual, it'll be a yellow truck. And there'll be wood out there that I was chopping. Okay, I'm sorry. Remember the X isn't such a stomach.
6:40 Okay, I want you to stay on the phone with me. But you say you do not have any weapons with you? Correct, no, mam, Okay, I just don't want you to have any weapons in your hands. Okay, your man, all right, I'm sorry to ruin Yourn. You're you're fine. We're gonna get you some help. Okay. I got blood all over from my hands. Okay, I want you to I want you to stay where you are. Okay, just stay sitting in the chair, take some deep breaths. We got to some help. On the way forward. Okay, listen, listen to me, Listen to me, tail Meggy, and you do not have a gun or anything in your hand. Okay, all right. I want you to stay on the phone till I'll tell you what to do. While he was being transported to jail, Michael stopped to talk to reporters, telling them that he loved Stephen as a friend. The damage to Stephen's body was extensive and brutal. He hadn't just been killed, he had been violently attacked and then mutilated. First, he had been shot multiple times with shotgun and handgun, but he'd also been stabbed with a knife and had the blade of an axe thrust deep into a stomach.
7:46 Michael had also carved a word into Steven's torso. Initially, investigators refused to disclose more details about that mutilation, but it was later revealed to be the word joker carved capital letters. Michael had also used a ballpoint pen to write more words on Stephen's body. This time they were on the front of his stomach and chest. They read I'm effing Psycho. Despite the vicious nature of the attack, investigators didn't find any signs of struggle in Stephen's house only the large pools of blood found close to where Stephen's body was eventually found. The lack of struggle suggested that Stephen had been killed in his sleep and incapacitated before he was able to fight back. Law enforcement officials described the crime scene as being horrific. Coy Reid, the sheriff, said that it was probably one of the worst scenes he'd ever seen in his thirty years of law enforcement.
8:45 Michael was quickly charged with murder and held at the County Detention Center without bond. Just like he'd readily admitted to the murder and described his actions in grewsome detail during the nine one one call, he was willing to plead guilty to the charges against him. After being found guilty of second degree murder with aggravating factors, Michael Anderson received a minimum prison sentence of sixteen years and four months behind bars. Despite how much information Michael shared about the crime, one thing remained unclear to law enforcement. Had Michael really had a bad reaction to cough medicine causing him to misbehave violently. A medical examination confirmed that when Michael killed Stephen, he had almost twenty musenex pills in his stomach, a cough medication that can cause LSD like hallucinations and high doses. Or had he been telling the truth on the nine one one call when he said that Stephen had been making sexual advances, causing Michael to lash out and attack him. But when Michael was asked if he and Stephen had been fighting before the murder, he replied no. Michael Anderson had no history of violence. Second degree murder became the first crime on his Squeaky Clean record, and more than a decade after Stephen's Starr was murdered, the real motive for the crime remains unknown.
10:20 That is ten Minute Murder for today three fan Bingeible True Crime. My name is Joe. I'm the host of this podcast and I really appreciate you listening to it today. If this is your first time listening to Ten Minute Murder, please subscribe now so that you can catch up on all of the back episodes, plus you'll never miss any of the new ones. If you become a subscriber, connect with me on social media see the visuals of what we're talking about here on the podcast. And if you like this episode and you listen in a place that lets you rate and review podcasts. I hope that you'll give me five stars and say something kind about the podcast. Also tell your friends and family about ten Minute Murder. If you like it and you think it's a podcast to listen to, please share it with anyone that you think might also think it's a cool podcast to listen to. You can go to ten minute murder dot com for all things related to ten minute Murder.
11:09 Now quickly to email. This one's not a question, by the way. This one was just something that the person wants to remain anonymous, but they periodically just send me weird, random fun facts and I love a fun fact. This one I thought was kind of funny. Fun fact sharks bite about fifty seven people per year New Yorkers bytes New Yorkers bye, sixteen hundred people per year. That's not funny, but it's kind of funny. And I don't know how fun that fact actually was, but that was the subject of the email. If you would like to send me an email, Joe at ten minute murder dot com is my email address. You can also shoot it to my direct message on Facebook Instagram. You can send it there, but I get it easiest if you send it to my email Joe at ten minute murder dot com. All Right, that's it. That's gonna do it for this episode. Hope to catch you on the next one.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube