Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
Dec. 7, 2023

The Gay Panic Defense

The Gay Panic Defense
The Gay Panic Defense
10 Minute Murder
The Gay Panic Defense

The Gay Panic Defense: Murder of Scott Amedure

In 1995, Scott Amedure was excited to appear as a guest on one of his favorite talk shows. The episode was titled, “Revealing Same Sex Secret Crush.” Three days after filming finished, Scott was...

The Gay Panic Defense: Murder of Scott Amedure

In 1995, Scott Amedure was excited to appear as a guest on one of his favorite talk shows. The episode was titled, “Revealing Same Sex Secret Crush.” Three days after filming finished, Scott was murdered.

SUBSCRIBE
to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.


10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com


Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder

Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder


This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement

0:07 Discretion, is it vis tim immediate murders. On the sixth of March nineteen ninety five, thirty two year old Scott Bernard Ammendur was selected to appear on the Jenny Jones Show. He was a fan of the show. In fact, one of his neighbors described him as being a talk showed junkie. The episode was called Revealing Same Sex Secret Crush, a recent trend that had been appearing on several other talk shows at the same time. The premise was that six guests would be invited to publicly meet their secret admirer, and after the admirer confessed to their feelings, both people would be interviewed by Jenny Jones before the show. All of the guests had to undergo pre screening. In these interviews, the producers of the show told them that it was possible that their secret admirer could be male or female. But even though the episode was going to be titled Revealing Same Sex Secret Crush, the producers failed to inform any of the guests that all of the secret admirers would be the same sex as them. As a gay man, Scott was going to be one of the six secret admirers. He had always had a hard time with relationships and had been involved in a domestic violence incident in the past. However, he was

1:40 highly involved in the LGBT community, even working at a gay bar in Pontiac, Michigan, where he lived. At the beginning of the episode, Jenny Jones explained the premise to the audience. Each of the secret admirers were invited out to the stage, and Jenny interviewed them about their feelings, asking how they met their crush and probe for details about their romantic and sexual fantasies. To prevent each of the crushes from overhearing, they were asked to sit backstage with soundproof headphones on. Finally, once the interviews with the admirers were over, Jenny asked the crush to come on stage in front of the live audience. The admirers admitted their feelings for their crushes and then were immediately interviewed and asked whether they reciprocated the feelings. Scott was the third secret admirer to reveal his secret crush, telling the audience that he was infatuated with a man named Jonathan Schmidts who lived in the same area as him. When Jonathan came on stage and realized that Scott was his secret admirer. He gave Scott a bit of an awkward hug and said that he was flattered by the attention, but told Scott, Jenny and the audience that he was definitely heterosexual. The night after revealing same sex crush was taped, Scott and Jonathan decided to go out to a bar for a drink together. According to one of Scott's friends, despite Jonathan's insistence that he was heterosexual, the two men allegedly had a sexual encounter at some point the night before going their separate ways. Two days later,

3:13 Scott visited Jonathan's house and left behind a suggestive, handwritten note addressed to him. After reading that note, Jonathan didn't hesitate. He went to the bank withdrew some money, and he used that money to buy a gun. He drove to the mobile home where Scott lived and left the gun in his car while he went to knock on the door. Scott opened the door and Jonathan asked him, were you the one who left the note. Scott responded by smiling, leaving Scott standing in the doorway. Jonathan walked back to his car and picked up the gun, shot Scott in the chest, and then shot him a second time for good measure. Scott collapsed and died almost immediately.

3:58 Jonathan drove to a nearby gas station, called the police and told the operator that he just committed a murder. Before Jonathan went to trial, another court case took place that Jenny Jones Show faced a negligent suit that had been filed by Scott's loved ones. They argued that the show had irresponsibly put Scott and the other crushes who appeared on the episode in a position where they felt ambushed by their admirers, and that the show's producers should have considered the possibility of violence. Jonathan Schmidt's own family members also blamed his appearance on The Jenny Jones Show for Scott's murder. The talk shows. Jonathan's father said, they're absolutely rotten. Had Jenny Jones not done this, this would have never happened.

4:43 Most of the popular talk shows attempted to avoid giving an official comment on the case, but eventually several of them caved. Jerry Springer disagreed that the Jenny Jones Show could be found responsible for Scott's death, saying quote to suggest we have reached a in our society where people don't take responsibility for their own actions. That this man could justify a murder because of a talk show is stupid on its face. Another talk show host, Phil Donahue said that blaming the Jenny Jones Show for the murder came very close to saying that producers have a responsibility to administer a sanity test for all prospective guests. The case also resulted in a debate about how shock value was used in talk shows, especially when an episode revolved around revealing private information to somebody in an ambush. Several talk show hosts claimed that they changed their protocols immediately after hearing about the incident, and the backlash that surrounded the Jenny Jones Show after Scott's murder discouraged other talk show hosts from putting their guests in similar situations. Many talk shows began to consider carrying out psychological profiling and more in depth screening when deciding what guests to invite on the show. Four years after filing in the lawsuit, Scott's family was awarded a settlement of almost thirty million dollars later, The Jenny Jones Show appealed the verdict, and in October two thousand and two, the judgment was overturned by the Michigan Court of Appeals. Despite the jury previously being eight

6:16 to one in favor of Scott's family, the court now found that Jonathan's response to Scott's crush had been unforseeable, claiming that the Jenny Jones producers quote had no duty to anticipate and prevent the act of murder committed by Schmidtz three days after leaving the studio and hundreds of miles away. Jenny Jones herself, who had previously testified at the trial, described herself as being elated about that verdict being reversed. Quote. Scott Emmendur's murder was a horrible tragedy, but I have always believed that it was fundamentally wrong and unfair to blame the show. At Jonathan's nineteen ninety six trial, the defense relied on two factors that they believed had contributed to Scott's murder. Jonathan had Graves disease and bipolar disorder, and the fact that Scott Ammendor had been gay. They leaned on a legal term called gay panic, a defense that can be used when a heterosexual perpetrator claims that they killed an LGBT victim in a state of panic because of unwonted sexual advances, as well as alleging that Jonathan had been thrown into a state of panic by Scott's advances. His attorney told the jury about how Jonathan had a difficult childhood, including a traumatizing experience where he was publicly humiliated, and that he had suffered from suicidal tendencies as an adult. Regardless of Jonathan's medical history and the use of the gay panic defense, the jury still found him guilty of Scott's murder. However, they believed that Scott's mental state warranted a

7:50 less severe charge, so the first degree murder charges were reduced to second degree murder. When one of the jurors was asked about the trial's verdict, they replied, quote, we saw the show as a catalyst in a young man's life who had a lot of problems. It sent his life back into an emotional tael spin. The judge handed him a sentence of twenty five to fifty years, which he appealed. The appeal was granted and the conviction was overturned, but at his retrial, Jonathan was found guilty a second time and received the same sentence. In twenty seventeen, Jonathan was released on parole after serving twenty one years of his sentence. Although he was never officially charged with committing a hate crime, Scott's murder is often described as one. The case led to increased public awareness of how the gay panic defense could be used in court, with many people saying that the murder was blamed on the Jenny Jones Show when it should have been viewed as a consequence of homophobia. Jenny Jones herself stated that the crime had more to do with homophobia than anything else, saying that quote it was tragic that Jonathan Schmidts would rather have been labeled a murderer than a homosexual. The case has been one of the most notorious examples of the gay panic defense providing a lighter sentence to a murderer, and it was cited as an example of why the defense should be banned across the United States of America. Since then, the gay panic defense has been banned in eighteen American states, but in Michigan, where Scott mmandor was murdered, it is

9:24 still a valid defense In Court. That is ten minute murder for today Brief and binge able True Crime. I'm Joe, I'm the host, and thank you so much for listening. And just as a side note, not that it has anything to do with this trial or this case or this story. I've been to the Jenny Jones Show in the to late nineties after this all happened. I don't think I knew about it, but I was a guest in the audience, not a guest. I was in the audience, not a guest. Let me make that clear. I was not a guest, but I was in the audience watching the show because I knew people that were guests on the show. And if I remember, there's a photo of me, a screen capture of me sitting in the audience. You know when you come back from commercial break and everyone's clapping for literally no reason. There's a screen capture where you can see me back in the mid to late nineties.

10:31 I'll try to post that if I can remember. So for today's listener email questions, instead of doing one, I'm going to do several that I've gotten that are just very short question and answers. So let's do that. What is a movie or TV show that you love that you don't think people would guess. That's from Cheryl in Arizona. The answer to that is the Good Place, fantastic show. What skill or talent do you have that most people have never seen? That's Desiree in Florida. I can juggle. I taught myself how during baseball in high school. What is one story outside of the more well known that you still think about? That's Christian in New York Byron Smith and the home Invasion Homicide. Look it up. I did an episode on it in August of twenty twenty. Samara in Texas wants to know what is your podcast set up? Specifically, what microphone do you use? This is the Sennheiser MKH four sixteen. And finally, Laura in Florida. Do you call it a cooking sheet or a cookie sheet? And I'm gonna be honest with you, I didn't know that people called it a cooking sheet.

11:41 I just thought it was a cookie sheet because you put cookies on it to bake them. And I'm just now finding out that people call it something else. I don't know if I'm wrong, but it's going to be a cookie sheet for the rest of my life. I know that, and that's it. That's your episode for today. Thank you so much for listening to another ten minute Murder podcas Cast episode, and I'll see you on the next one. Bye.