The Michigan Murderer
The Michigan Murders were a series of murders that had young women around the Ann Arbor/Ypsilanti area of Southeastern Michigan terrified... especially if they were white and brunette. The perpetrator was John Norman Collins, but was he guilty of all...
SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.
10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com
Follow on THREADS:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder
Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/
TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder
Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder
Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw
Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement
0:07 Discretion. Is it by maybe it murder. Most of us, as children, were taught about stranger danger to fear unknown people. A mother squeezes her child's hand a little tighter when a stranger walks by. The neighbors wonder about a person that lives in the house with the uncut grass and the aluminum foil on the windows. Teen girls are cautioned not to walk by vans that you can't see inside, And as long as we avoid those situations, we should be safe. Right, not necessarily. John Norman Chapman was born on June seventeenth, nineteen forty seven, in Windsor, Ontario. His father was Canadian and his mother was American. He was the youngest of three children. His father was an abusive alcoholic, and he left shortly after John was born.
1:15 His mother soon remarried, and her second husband was also an abusive alcoholic who took a lot of his anger out on John. His mother left and relocated the family to Detroit, Michigan. It was there that she met William Collins. Perhaps the third time would be the charm, so his mother married again. Not only did she take Collins as her last name, but her children did as well. The third marriage only lasted a few years, and even though his childhood was pretty traumatic, he grew up to be quite the all American young man. John attended Saint Clement Catholic High School, where he was an honor student, captain of the football team, and star pitcher of the baseball team. After graduating, he attended did Eastern Michigan University. He majored in elementary education. He joined Theta Kai fraternity. He worked out and even landed a few modeling gigs. He loved motorcycles. What college girl wouldn't want to go on a date with him. The town where John lived was full of college co eds, and it was the sixties. Most of the young adults were enjoying life, although very few of them had their own cars, so they hitchhiked. But on July ninth, nineteen sixty seven, Mary Flazar, a nineteen year old accounting student, disappeared. A witness said that a blue and gray Chevrolet offered her a ride and she refused. The vehicle left, but then returned. Her body was later found near a farm in Superior
2:46 Township on August seventh. Mary had been stabbed more than thirty times, beaten part of her hand was missing and her feet had been severed at the ankles. Her body was so decomposed that they couldn't tell if she had been raped, and they had to use dental records to confirm her identity. The investigators noticed she had not been killed in that location, but had been moved around the area. At the funeral home, a man asked if he could take a picture of the body in the casket for the family. The employees denied the request. The employees noted that that man left angry and that they didn't even see a camera. Then, on July fifth, nineteen sixty eight, construction workers found the body of a woman on the roadside in ann Arbor.
3:31 The body found was twenty year old Joan Shell, a local art student. Joan had been raped and she was stabbed twenty five times. Her skull was fractured, her throat was slashed, and her skirt was tied around her neck. Due to the similarities, they assumed that her case was related to flazars. Her roommates had reported her missing. On June thirtieth, Joan was hitchhiking and accepted a ride from a guy driving a red and black Pontiac Bonneville. Her roommate, even helped the police form a sketch. They questioned one hundred and fifty owners of Red and Black Bonneville's, but didn't find a lead. They interviewed Shell's neighbors. The neighbor across the street, John Collins, matched the sketch. He said that he'd never met Joan and was at his mother's that weekend of June thirtieth. The police did not confirm that alibi. On March twentieth, nineteen sixty nine, Jane Mixer, a twenty three year old law student, went missing after she posted the need for a ride to Muskegon on a bulletin board. Her body was found the next day on top of a grave in the Denton Cemetery. She was clothed and had not been beaten or raped, but she had been shot in the head. There were similarities to the previous murders. She was a local student, and she had something around her neck, so investigators assumed the cases were connected. Just a few days later, on March twenty fifth, a naked and mutilated body was found by a surveyor just a few hundred yards from where they found Joan Shell's body.
5:05 One third of her skull was fractured. Some kind of leather strap had been used to whip her body, her garter belt had been tied around her neck, a piece of her shirt had been pushed down her throat, and a tree branch was shoved into her vagina. The body was soon identified as Marylyn's Skelton, a sixteen year old that had been seen hitchhiking the day before. After Skelton's murder, police from five jurisdictions formally combined resources in an effort to solve these crimes. Although they had exchanged some information before, they had not officially been working together. It wouldn't be long before they had yet another victim on their board. On April sixteenth, the body of thirteen year old Dawn Basim was found on a desolate road in Ipsilante. Dawn had been at a friend's house the night before and only had to walk about five blocks alone to get home, but she never made it there. She had been stabbed, slash wounds across her body and handkerchief was in her mouth. Her blouse, along with an electrical flex were wrapped around her neck, but there was no sign of sexual assault. The investigators believed she was killed one hundred yards away in an old farmhouse, where they found blood and articles of clothing.
6:24 They even found Skelton's missing earring there. This added to their theory that the murderer was revisiting the sites. Then, on May thirteenth, the farmhouse burned to the ground. The police stated that it was an act of arson. Did the murderer burn it down maybe? They found five recently cut lilacs arranged on the driveway, mimicking a memorial site, but the Michigan murderer was not done. On June ninth, another body was found. Her throat had been slashed, she had been stabbed multiple times, and she was shot in the head. The pathologist believed that she was also raped after death. Her clothes were scattered and her shoe was missing. The body was that of Alice Colam, a twenty one year old student going to college to better understand social relationships.
7:15 She had been last seen at a party a couple of nights before. Besides Mixer, she was the only other victim to have a gunshot wound. By July of that year, over a thousand convicted sex offenders had been interviewed and thousands of leads investigated. Sales drastically increased of tear gas, knives, and security locks. Hitchhiking slowed down, and many females accepted a buddy system when walking around. The police knew the suspect preferred Caucasian burnette females. Beyond that, they had little to nothing to go on. Eventually, the Michigan murderer would make an error and then they would find him. On July twenty third, Susan Bidemann, an eighteen year old student, was reported missing by her roommate. Her body was found three days later off Huron River Parkway.
8:09 She was nude, had been strangled and had lacerations so severe that strips of her skin had been ripped off. A caustic substance had been poured over her upper body and down her throat. Susan had been raped, and her underwear had been pushed into her vagina. They also found seamen and clippings of hair that did not belong to the victim on her underwear. The police expected the killer to return to the site, so they forced a media blackout, keeping the murderer from knowing that the body had been found. They placed a mannikin at the site and set up watch. After midnight, a man was seen running away from the site, but due to heavy rains, the officer couldn't make out a description. He tried to call it in, but the storm caused interference with the radios. When investigators investigated and retraced Susan's steps, they found a wig shop. The owner told them that Susan had come in and was with a man on a motorcycle. Diana Ghosh said the young woman told her that she only had done two things foolish in her life, buying a wig and accepting a ride from the stranger on the bike. When Diana described the man, one of the patrolmen thought that the man sounded like former Theta Kai brother John Collins. He got photos from one of Collins's old girlfriends and showed them to the shop owner. She was sure Collins was the man she saw that day. On July twenty seven, investigators went to Collins's apartment and
9:41 asked him to go to the police station with them. Collins refused. The next night, Collins's roommate saw him carrying out a box wrapped in a blanket. He saw a woman's shoe and a purse in the box. Two days later, the police showed up with a search warrant, but didn't find any physical evidence linking Collins to the other crimes. Collins's uncle was a sergeant on the police force, David Leak. He was notified of his nephew's suspects status before the arrest. He had just returned from a trip and Collins had been house sitting to care for their dog. David's wife had noticed some weird things in their basement. He realized his basement might be related to the case.
10:22 In the Leak's basement, investigators found blood that matched Susan's blood type and hair clippings that matched the ones on the underwear. On August first, John Collins was formerly arraigned. In early August, Washington All County was contacted by investigators in Salinas, California. It was discovered Collins was in California during the time of another murder. Roxy Phillips, a seventeen year old, was found naked, beaten, and strangled with a belt around her neck on August fifth. The cases were formerly connected, although John never went to California for trial. In August of nineteen seventy, John Collins was unanimously found guilty of the first degree murder of Susan Binnemann and sentenced to life in prison without parole. While in prison, he started writing letters to the press and even let investigators come in for more interviews. He revealed disturbing information that often confirmed their decades old suspicions. He makes his home in g Robert Cotton Correctional Facility and corresponds with quite a few women. In two thousand and one, with new DNA testing available, Mixer's case was reopened and the DNA on the stockings produced the match.
11:39 Gary Leidermann, a former nurse, was charged with Mixer's murder. So how many actual victims did John Collins have? No one except Collins is sure. If the officers would have had a search warrant in hand at their first visit, they might have found whatever items Collins got rid of in that box. What we do know is that looks can be deceiving, and John Collins preyed on young women with his trustworthy smile. The Michigan murderer or Ipsilante ripper is off the streets, but still in our nightmares. That's ten minute murder for today. Brief and binge able true crime. I'm Joe. I'm the host, and I really appreciate you listening today. And yes, I've been sick. I still sound sick, but I am not currently sick. I guess I am sick. I don't know. I feel fine. I'm at the point where I stopped taking medicine every four hours, so I hate doing that. So maybe I stopped doing that a little bit too soon. I might recover a little bit faster if I were to keep taking the medicine.
12:48 But I can't stay. I'd rather eat a five by seven rug than to take four hour every four hours to take medicine. That drives me crazy. Anyway, I feel great, but I sound like this. Sorry, you're welcome, and hey, if you're brand new to Ten Minute Murder, welcome to the podcasts. Glad that you're here. Please subscribe now so that you can more easily catch up on the back episodes and connect with me on social media. See the pictures of what we're talking about here in the podcast, and it's not gross stuff. I don't like to post graphic things to social media. I don't like to look at it, no less post it. And if you like this episode. Please leave a rating and review on Apple, Spotify, any place that that's possible and quickly. It is Spooky month and the whole month of October. If you share this podcast I've mentioned it before, if you share this podcast with other people in your social media feed, like on Facebook. If I were to post the pictures and links, the listening links to this story that we're talking about today, if you share that screenshot it, send it to me and at random multiple people throughout this month. I'm going to send you a target gift card and you'll know if you're selected because I'll send you a message and say, hey, congratulations, target gift card. What's your address and I'll send it to you. So make sure you do that. It doesn't have to be the post of the episodes. It can be anything to do with the podcast. Just share it, screenshot it, send it to me in a message. All right, that's going to do it. That is today's episode. Thank you so much for listening to ten Minute Murder.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube