Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
May 22, 2023

The Occult Killing of Colleen

The Occult Killing of Colleen
The Occult Killing of Colleen
10 Minute Murder
The Occult Killing of Colleen

In this episode, we dive into the chilling story of Christa Gail Pike, the youngest woman to ever be sentenced to death in the United States. Pike, who was just 18 at the time, was convicted of murdering Colleen Slemmer, a fellow student at the Job...

In this episode, we dive into the chilling story of Christa Gail Pike, the youngest woman to ever be sentenced to death in the United States. Pike, who was just 18 at the time, was convicted of murdering Colleen Slemmer, a fellow student at the Job Corps facility in Knoxville, Tennessee.

Pike's story is one of manipulation, jealousy, and brutality. She had a troubled past and a history of violence, but it was her obsession with a fellow student that ultimately led to Slemmer's horrific death. Pike convinced two male accomplices to help her lure Slemmer into the woods, where they brutally attacked her with a rock and a knife, ultimately leaving her to die.


The details of the murder are shocking, but what's even more unsettling is Pike's behavior in the aftermath. She showed no remorse, even bragging to her friends about the killing. Her trial was highly publicized, with many arguing that her age and gender made her a sympathetic figure. However, the jury ultimately found her guilty and sentenced her to death.
This episode explores the twisted mind of Christa Gail Pike and the tragic fate of Colleen Slemmer. As we delve into the details of this story, we're left with the haunting question: how could someone be capable of such monstrous violence?

SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.

10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com

HelloFresh FREE Shipping and 16 FREE Meals:
https://hellofresh.com/10minmurder16


Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder

0:15 Eighteen year old Christa Pike's relationship with her classmate Colleen Slimmer had quickly become full of one sided distrust and jealousy. Krista was convinced that Colleen was infatuated with her boyfriend to Darrell Ship and was trying to steal him away from her. Christa adored to Darryl, and even though he was a year younger than her, the two of them had a very intense relationship. Krista's life up until that point had been full of adversity. She had never completed high school, dropping out before graduation to join a government program called the Job Corps, which helped disadvantage young people to gain skills that would allow them to get jobs.

0:56 Despite everything she'd been through to Darrell still loved her. He made her into a better person, and she liked to think that she did the same for him. She wasn't about to let Colleen come between them, and she decided that she'd do whatever she had to to make sure that Colleen wouldn't get what she wanted, or what she thought Colleen wanted. Despite Christa's accusations, Colleen's friends were adamant that she was not interested in too Darrell at all. It seemed as if Christa had misinterpreted Colleen's friendly nature and innocent conversations with to Darrell as romantic interest. As time went on, Krista became angrier and angrier at Colleen. She started to obsess over Colleen's behavior, worried that she would lose to Darrell for good, and angry because she thought Colleen wanted someone who belonged to her. Finally, she reached a breaking point. She talked to one of her friends, Chadola Peterson, and began to make a plan to teach Colleen a lesson. It was the twelfth of January nineteen ninety five when the plan was set into motion. Christa to Daryl, Colleen, and their friend, eighteen year old Shedola Peterson, all signed out of their dorms and made their way to an abandoned steam plant in the woods near campus. Colleen knew that Christa didn't like her, but she believed that the trip was sort of a peace offering where the group was going to smoke some weed together and overcome their differences. However, when the four teenagers arrived at their destination, it

2:30 was clear to Colleen that she had been lied to. Krista and her boyfriend immediately turned on Colleen and began beating her. Chidolah didn't participate in the attack and instead stood nearby to warn the couple if any witnesses approached the area. This role as a guard or lookout had been decided by Christa during her planning of the attack. For around half an hour to forty five minutes, Colleen was ferociously toward shirt. She was severely beaten and cut, and the couple used a blade to carve the shape of a pentagram into her skin. Finally, the attack ended when Christa grabbed a large piece of asphalt and hit Colleen in the head with it. The force of the blow shattered Colleen's skull.

3:17 It killed her instantly. Christa didn't regret the murder. In fact, she pride one of the broken pieces of skull free and took it back with her to her dorm to keep as a trophy. She didn't just feel a lack of remorse, she felt pride. Over the next day and a half, Christa carried this piece of calling skull around campus with her while Colleen's family and friends were gradually realizing that she was missing. It didn't take long for authorities to view Christa, to Darryl, and Chidola as suspects. The evidence was clear four students had signed out of the dorm together and then the group had returned without Colleen, resulting in Christa and her accomplices being arrested thirty six hours after the murder. It's almost like they didn't even try to hide their crime, which, don't get me wrong, I'm glad they got caught so quickly, but with all due disrespect, what a stupid plan. When Christa was arrested and her clothes were searched for evidence, police found her disgusting trophy, the fragment of Colleen's skull, tucked in the pocket of her coat. Christa quickly confessed to her involvement in Colling's death, but she insisted that it had not been a murder. She and Tadarrel had just been trying to send Colleen a message and scare her a little bit, but then got carried away and accidentally killed her. A search of the three accomplices dorms uncovered more pieces of the puzzle, especially when a religious occult book, the Satanic Bible, was

4:50 found into Darrell's room. Christa and Tadarrel had not been into Satanism before they got together, but during their relationship a mutual interest had spiraled into a full blown devil worship. It had become a cornerstone of their relationship. For Christa, it gave her security and a sense of purpose. Suddenly, the pentagram carved into Colleen's body made sense to the investigators. At the nineteen ninety six trial, the jury found it easy to reach a verdict. Even though Christa had insisted Colleen's death was an accident, she had already confessed to being the one to kill her. The rest of the evidence brought forth by the prosecution made it clear that no part of the killing had been an accident. It had been premeditated torture ending with cold blooded murder. On the twenty second of March nineteen ninety six, Christa Pike was found guilty of both conspiracy to commit murder and murder in the first degree. Four days later, she received her sentence twenty five years of jail time and death by electrocution. The other murderer to Darrell received a much lighter sentence of life in prison with the possibility of parole. Shadola, who had stood guard during the attack and had been involved in the planning of Colleen's death, had already pleaded guilty to being an accessory to murder and then acted as an informant for investigators. In exchange for a reduced sentence, she received credit for four hundred and sixty days in prison and

6:24 probation for six years. Krista's violent, vengeful behavior didn't stop when she was imprisoned. The twenty fourth of August two thousand and one, she and another inmates, Natasha Cornett, attacked a prisoner named Patricia Jones. The two women attempted to murder Patricia by strangling her to death with a shoelace. While the attack caused serious injury, Krista and Natasha did not succeed in killing Patricia. Although there wasn't enough evidence to charge Natasha for her role in the assault, Christa was not so lucky. She received additional charges for the attack, tempted first degree murder. While incarceration, Christa made a friend. His name was Donald Cohut, and he was a personal trainer who had for some reason started writing letters to Krista. In two eleven, the two of them regularly wrote back and forth, and eventually Donald started driving to Tennessee, which was an eighteen hundred mile long road trip from his home in Flemington, New Jersey, so that he could see Christa in person. He made this journey multiple times every month. Donald wanted to help Christa, so he devised a plan to help her escape from prison. He got in touch with a guy named Jason Hefflin, who was a corrupt corrections officer, who agreed that he would help and aid Christa's escape for a fee. But the plan did not get very far before it was discovered and two twelve prison staff were tipped off about an escape plan involving Christa Pike. The investigation was launched in both Tennessee and Donald's

7:56 home state of New Jersey, and the details of the plot were covered. Donald had planned to use Justin's role in the facility to obtain the tracing of a key, which could then be used to create a copy. The finer details of the plan have never been released to the public due to concerns that prison security could be impacted, but the Tennessee Bureau of Investigations simply stated that the plan had been in the early stages when it was discovered saying quote Christa's jailbreak was not imminent. Donald Cohut was charged with conspiracy to commit escape as well as bribery. He received seven years of jail time. Justin, the corrections officer was charged with conspiracy to commit escape, bribery, and official misconduct.

8:39 Because of Justin's willingness to cooperate with the police, the only consequence he faced was losing his job at the prison. Investigators were unsure whether Christa had actually taken part in any of the plan, or if she was just aware that Donald wanted to break her out of jail. Because of this uncertainty, Christa was not charged to this. Christa's fate is still hanging in the balance. In two twenty her attorneys were given extensions due to the COVID nineteen pandemic, giving them more time to compile a convincing argument to save christoph from death by electrocution. In June of two twenty one, Christa's attorney filed a motion that requested a certificate of commutation, which would allow Christa's punishment to be reduced.

9:24 Ultimately, the decision about the execution is now down to the courts. If Christa Pike's execution does go ahead, she will make history as being the only female criminal to be executed in the state of Tennessee in the past two centuries. Colleen Slimmer's mother just wants closure and for this case to be finally over, because the fragment of Colleen's skull that was once a trophy for Krista is still considered evidence and in custody of the police. When this story finally ends, the last piece of Colleen can be laid to rest. That's ten minute murder for today Brief and binge able True Crime. I'm Joe the host, and I really appreciate you listening, and I hope your day is fantastic.

10:18 I made myself a cup of coffee earlier. I spilled a little bit, and during the process of cleaning up, I got the sleeve of my shirt wet. I was washing my hands, and you know it gets in the water a little bit, and we know that ruins your whole day. So your thoughts and prayers are welcome during this difficult time in my life. I could just change my shirt, but I don't want to do that. Hey, if this is your first time listening to ten Minute Murder. Please subscribe now so that you can catch up on all the back episodes, never miss any of the new ones. Connect with me on social media, see the visuals that we're talking about doing the podcast, And if you liked this episode, please leave a rating and review on Apple or any place that is possible. Your positive feedback is a preciated go to ten minute murder dot com for all things ten minute Murder