True Crime Blueprint - JonBenét: The Family, the Secrets, and the Case That Broke America

0:01 Hi, it's Joe and what you're about to hear is a sample of an episode from a new podcast created now. If you like it it vibes with what you're looking for in a true crime podcast, go over and subscribe to the new one. You can find links for it in the episode notes here, or you can just search for True Crime Blueprint. I'll be releasing weekly episodes there, full deep dives, no ten minute restriction. So again, if you like this new podcast, it's very important that you search for and go to True Crime Blueprint and follow subscribe to the new podcast. A six year old girl goes missing from her bedroom on the morning after Christmas. Three hours later, her father finds her body in the basement of their own house. One of the most prominent families in their city becomes the most hated family in America, and twenty nine years later, nobody has gone to prison for it. This is True Crime Blueprint, Okay, So let me set the scene here, because to really understand this case, you have to understand who the Ramseys were before any of this happened. And I think part of the story gets completely lost because people jumped straight to the pageant photos and the suspicion and the press conferences. There's a whole life that existed before December twenty sixth, nineteen ninety six, and it matters enormously. John Ramsey was born in Lincoln, Nebraska,

1:32 in December of nineteen forty three. He grew up in the Midwest with a very structured, achievement oriented value system that a lot of people from that part of the country carry with them their whole lives. He eventually moved to Michigan, attended Michigan State, got his bachelor's degree, then his MBA. He served in the Navy after that. His military experience instilled a particular sense of order and hierarchy in him that would later find his management style as a CEO, and it would later be misread by investigators and the public as emotional coldness. His first marriage was to a woman named Lucinda. They married in nineteen sixty six and they had three children together, Elizabeth, Melinda, and John Andrew. That marriage ended in nineteen seventy eight. And here's something that gets genuinely underappreciated in most profiles of John Ramsey. In January of nineteen ninety two, his eldest daughter, Elizabeth was killed in a car accident at the age of twenty two in Athens, Georgia. John Ramsey had already lost a child before John Benay. He already knew what it felt like to have his world collapse without warning.

2:44 That piece of his psychological history is real and important, because when investigators later described him as seeming too composed after John Benney's death, they were evaluating a man who had already been through devastating grief once before. That's not an excuse for anything, it's just context that deserves to be part of the picture. Now, enter Patsy. Patricia Ann Paul was born nineteen fifty six in Parkersburg, West Virginia. She grew up in a household where ambition was encouraged, an achievement was the clear expectation. Her mother fostered her participation in beauty pageants from a young age, and Patsy absorbed that mentality completely. In nineteen seventy seven, she won Miss West Virginia. And here's a detail that really tells you who Patsy Ramsey was at her core. She reportedly watched the previous year's competition and took detailed notes before entering herself she studied it, she reverse engineered what winning looked like, and then she went out and she won the thing herself. That meticulous, analytical approach to achievement would later define how she operated as a pageant mother to John Benney. She got a journalism degree from West Virginia University, moved to Atlan, and in that city social orbit, she met John Ramsey, who was by then a successful businessman, turning a garage based startup into something significant. They married in nineteen eighty. Patsy was thirteen years younger than John.

4:15 John's company, called Access Graphics, was eventually acquired by Lockheed Martin and grew into a subsidiary that reached a billion dollars in annual sales. John mentioned that milestone proudly in the family's nineteen ninety six Christmas card, because that's exactly what a CEO running a billion dollar company in nineteen ninety six would do. That's peak nineties executive culture right there. Merry Christmas. Here are the photos of the kids. Also, bt dubs, I run a multi billion dollar company. God bless. Now those aren't exactly the words that he used, but I'm taking a liberty there. The family moved to Boulder, Colorado in nineteen ninety one, following John's professional success. They settled into a seven thousand square foot Tudor style home.

5:01 They were prominent members of Saint John's Episcopal Church. They hosted elaborate parties and were visible at the top of Boulder's social circle. By every surface measurement, they were living exactly that life that the American professional culture told them that they were supposed to build. There was, however, something heavy underneath all of that carefully constructed success. In nineteen ninety three, Patsy was diagnosed with stage four ovarian cancer. Stage four that's not a diagnosis that you strategize around. That's a diagnosis that fundamentally re orders a person's relationship with time, with their children, with a very concept of the future. She went through aggressive chemotherapy, she went into remission, and surviving something that was expected to probably kill you leaves its own psychological residue. It can intensify your focus on legacy, on appearance, on the things you can control when your body has proven itself to be unreliable. A lot of people who have analyzed Patsy Ramsey's behavior later, especially her intense involvement in John Beney's pageant career. Have pointed to that cancer diagnosis as a turning point and how she processed the concept of time and what mattered most in the time that she had John Beney. Patricia Ramsey was born on August sixth, nineteen ninety in Atlanta, Georgia.

6:24 By the time the family settled in Bolder, she was a toddler, and she grew up in a city that was culturally speaking, pretty far removed from the pageant world. Her mother came from Bolder in the mid nineteen nineties, had a very specific personality. It was academic, outdoorsy, liberal, and fairly low key about overt displays of wealth. The richest person at any given Bolder social event was probably wearing a fleece vest and talking about a hiking trail they'd recently discovered. Status existed, but it tended to express itself through experiences and ideas rather than formal appearance. That was the environment John Benay grew up in. And then there were the Ramseys, with their Southern influenced traditions, their formal entertaining style, and their participation in a pageants subculture that was well established in Georgia, Texas, and Tennessee, but landed somewhat oddly in Bolder. John Benay competed in child beauty pageants. She held titles including Little Miss Colorado and National Tiny Miss Beauty. Patsy coached her, dressed her in elaborate costumes, arranged her hair and stage makeup. In the pageant community, there was standard practice. In the context of Boulder, it felt foreign and a little uncomfortable to a lot of people who encountered it. And here's where I want to be careful, because there's a significant amount of judgment that gets loaded onto the ramseys based entirely on those pageant photos. Was child pageantry the right choice? People genuinely

7:58 disagree on that. It's a legitimate conversation. Was it evidence of abuse or neglect? The evidence doesn't support that conclusion. John Benay, by the accounts of people that actually knew her in daily life, was a cheerful, energetic, funny kid. She liked to dance, She liked to perform. Whether that enthusiasm was entirely her own or partly shaped by her mother's ambitions is something we can't definitively separate. But treating her parents' participation in pageant culture as proof of deeper dysfunction or violent secrets is a logical leap that the facts simply do not support. What is true is that the images from those pageants, a six year old and heavy makeup and sequin costumes styled to look much older became the defining visual shorthand for this entire case in the media, and those images shaped the national conversation in ways that had almost nothing to do with justice and almost everything to do with American cultural discous comfort with a very specific kind of parenting. You have to understand the environment this happened and to fully understand how the public and the police responded to it. By nineteen ninety six, violent crime in the US had been falling for several years running. Boulder specifically was doing well on every single metric.

9:20 Serious crimes on the University of Colorado campus were down nearly twenty percent that year. Burglary rates were dropping city wide. People in Boulder felt genuinely reasonably safe. There's a particular confidence that comes with a low crime rate, combined with the university town sense of its own thoughtfulness. Boulder had that nobody in that community was operating with their guard fully up because statistically they didn't need to be. This matters because it explained some of what happened with the initial police response. The Bolder police departments in nineteen ninety six had years of experience handling drug offenses, property crimes, and the occasional assault. They had no meaningful experience handling anything like what landed on their desks on December twenty sixth, and that inexperience would cost the investigation dearly. Within the first few hours. The Ramses spent Christmas Day nineteen ninety six making the social rounds. They visited friends, including the family of Fleet White, who would become a significant figure later in the story. They got home late. John Benay had apparently fallen asleep in the car on the way home, and John, all right, what do you think. It's a bit different than regular ten minute murder episodes. I didn't want to create a new podcast that was simply a ten minute murder but longer, so this one's still me and my vibe. Actually, it's probably much more me because I'm not limited by time constraints. So please right now go and follow True Crime Blueprint wherever you're listening to

10:51 this episode. That's super important for the show to grow, like Ten Minute Murder has grown. Hey Joe, question, will you still be doing ten Minute Murder? Answer? Absolutely I will. Ten Minute Murder has been and always will be the main podcast for me into the foreseeable future. So I'm not slowing down or that podcast isn't going to go anywhere, so don't worry about that. Thank you for listening to both podcasts. Now go and subscribe and I'll see you next time.