William Pierce Jr.: The Serial Killer Who Killed for a Dollar
William Pierce Jr.: The Serial Killer Who Killed for a Dollar
A kind gesture to a stranger—just a pack of cigarettes and a dollar—turned into a nightmare for one man when William Pierce Jr. came back to collect his debt. Pierce, a troubled man from a...
A kind gesture to a stranger—just a pack of cigarettes and a dollar—turned into a nightmare for one man when William Pierce Jr. came back to collect his debt. Pierce, a troubled man from a broken home, spiraled into a life of crime and murder after a traumatic head injury. From robbing stores to the horrific killing of a babysitter and a young girl, Pierce left behind a trail of blood across Georgia and South Carolina. In this episode, we’ll explore the tragic events, the failed parole system, and how one man’s small act of compassion unleashed a monster.
Thanks a ton for listening to 10 Minute Murder—your support means the world!
Make sure to subscribe so you never miss a quick, chilling episode. Got friends who are obsessed with true crime? Share the show with them and let them join the binge!
For more updates, behind-the-scenes, and episode visuals, connect with us on social media.
10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com
_______
Follow 10 Minute Murder-
Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/
TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder
Threads:
https://www.threads.net/@10minutemurder
Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw
Have a case you want us to cover? Or maybe just want to chat with Joe? Drop your suggestions or questions to the email above. We'd love to hear from you!
*******
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/10-minute-murder--4603604/support.
0:02 Sometimes just a small act of kindness could open the door to an unimaginable horror. When a man extended a helping hand to a stranger, he never thought it would be the same person who'd later destroy his world. In this story, we rewind the clock to trace the disturbing path of William Pierce Junior, a troubled man whose life of crime and brutality wreaked havoc across multiple states. From a heartbreaking confession to a string of ruthless murders, the story will leave you questioning the terrifying ripple effect of a single moment in time. Welcome to ten Minute Murder.
0:51 I told him to stop back when he got out if he needed anything. He stopped back. That heart wrenching line came from a husband who never imagined that a small act of kindness to a stranger would end in devastation. Now he's left feeling like that one moment changed everything for his family. To really get how this all went so wrong, we've got to rewind and start from the beginning. His name was William Pierce Junior, or Junior, as he liked to go by. He was born October eleventh, nineteen thirty one in Midville, Georgia. Those of you that know your American history will know that the date that William came into the world, it was right in the middle of the Great Depression. He, like many other people during this challenging period of time, grew up hungry and in deep, deep poverty. Times were difficult and many people suffered. Among those were William's parents, who often fought with each other.
1:51 The loudest and most digressive of witch being his mother. She was a strict, opinionated woman, and after she divorced William's father, she took her frustrations out solely on her son. His mother ruled the household with an iron fist, and whenever she deemed that William was misbehaving, she would beat him without mercy. William grew into a severely psychologically damaged child, and that also reflected in his school life. He did poorly in his classes, and later a test discovered that he had an IQ of only seventy. This would categorize him as mentally challenged by today's standards. William stayed in school until the ninth grade, and he dropped out and got a job as a road worker. He didn't last very long, however, and quickly quit to join the army.
2:40 That also only lasted a few months before William's mother submitted several presumably fraudulent doctor's certificates that claimed he was medically unfit for service. William was then discharged and sent right back to live with his dominating mother. By then, William was a bit older and had seen a tiny bit more of the world. He was still afraid of his mother and her beatings, but mixed in with that fear was also a hatred and disdain. William now believed that he was smarter than the woman who was dominating his life, although he wasn't quite brave enough to stand up to her just yet. To keep himself busy, William found work in a local car rental service. His colleagues seemed to like him well enough, but they also found him stiff and awkward, especially with the customers. Today, you might say that William was probably on the spectrum somewhere.
3:33 Despite this social awkwardness, William did, however, find love, if only briefly. He got married and moved to Swainsborough, but his marriage only lasted three months before he and his wife divorced. He may not have been successful in romance, but the move did at least separate him from his mother. Now with a fresh start, William found work at a furniture factory and began building a new life for himself. He did relatively well, but but his new success unfortunately wasn't to last. Sometime when he was in his late twenties, William was involved in an accident at work that left him with a concussion, as we often see with severe head traumas. The accident changed him, and not for the better.
4:15 William became more arrogant and outwardly aggressive towards others. Later in his life. There were people who believed that this change in behavior were the early warning signs of him developing a personality disorder of sorts. Now, with some sort of inflated ego and sense of self worth, William was about to take his life in an entirely different direction. He began stealing and was caught a short time later. He was then sentenced to five years in prison. He managed to get out on parole early after serving nearly three years of his sentence, but only a few weeks after and he was charged again. While out on parole, William robbed and then burned down a store. This time he was sentenced to twenty years in prison, with a possible ability of parole after ten. It was during a panel review for his parole that William's future hung in the balance. Before him laid a few more years in prison and down a different path awaited freedom. Between them stood the parole board. He had years of good behavior and being a model inmate strengthening his case, but on the other hand, he had some pretty hefty opposition. The prison psychologist was there, arguing that William should stay in custody.
5:28 He warned the board that William quote may be dangerous to himself and others, and that he was showing clear signs of mental illness. The board didn't listen, and a paroled William only eight years into his twenty year sentence. This decision was one that they would soon regret. Later that year, in June nineteen seventy, William broke into a home in North Augusta, South Carolina. There he came upon eighteen year old Anne Goodwin, who was there babysitting her neighbor's children. William sexually assaulted Anne and then shot her. He raided the home, stealing several valuables before fleeing the scene and leaving Anne to her fate. She had survived the initial shooting, but would later unfortunately to come to the wounds in the hospital. A few months later, thirteen year old Peg Coutino left her family home in Sumter, South Carolina, to have lunch with her sister. Forty five minutes passed. When she didn't return home, her parents knew something must be wrong. A statewide search ensued, fueled by the fact that PEG's father was a South Carolina state representative.
6:34 Her body was recovered almost two weeks later, and in all times he revealed that she had been sexually assaulted, beaten, and then suffocated to death. Just two days after PEG's disappearance, William appeared in a service station in Vy Delia, Georgia, about three and a half hours away from Sumter by car. There he shot and killed fifty nine year old station attendant Joe Fletcher. William then i tole about seventy nine dollars from the cash register before fleeing the scene. He did the same thing again only a few weeks later, where he shot and killed a store manager, Lacy Tigpin, and then he returned to a familiar place while previously working on a prison road crew. Only two months before his parole, William went into a store in Appling County.
7:21 The store belonged to Helen Wilcox, but her husband was there that day, and Homer Wilcox was feeling compassionate. Quote. He wanted some cigarettes, and I gave them to him. I wouldn't take his money. I said, no, sir, I want to give this to you. I gave him a dollar out of the cash register and I told him, I know it ain't much. I told him to stop back when he got out if he needed anything. He stopped back. This time he was met by Helen Wilcox, and Helen would have a very different experience with William than her husband had previously. William kidnapped her and took her out to the woods rounding the city. There, he sexually assaulted her before shooting and killing the thirty two year old woman. He then buried her in a shallow grave and fled. Six days later, William was robbing another store in Baxley. This time he killed sixty year old Vivian Miles and attacked her five year old granddaughter. The child managed to survive the incident with a severe head injury, but it turned out that she wasn't the only witness to Vivian's murder. While fleeing the scene, William was interrupted by a truck driver named Joe Overstreet. William shot at Joe, but somehow missed, leaving behind a man who would later be able to define William Pierce's fate. Finally, two months after killing Vivian, William was arrested after robbing another gas station in Baxley. In police custody, he confessed to a total of nine murders, including the kidnapping of thirteen year
8:55 old Peg Catino. A world wind stream of events would follow. Joe Overstreet was brought in and identified William as the man he had seen fleeing the scene of Helen Wilcox's murder. This corroborated William's earlier confession, and law enforcement had many reasons for waiting to prove that William had initially been telling them the truth. By then, he had recanted his confession, claiming that he'd been drunk during his interview with the police and he hadn't been read his miranda rights. Authorities had an irate state representative breathing down their necks, and he wanted justice for the murder of his daughter. William would also retract his confession about killing Peg. He claimed that the detectives had coerced him into making it by beating and torturing him, the claim that was somewhat substantiated by report that mentioned bruises and burns across William's body.
9:48 There also seemed to be a cluster of burnmarks near his genitals. Others would believe his claims and question the legitimacy of his initial confession, but the courts disagreed. He traveled around America, following the path of destruction and the life of crime that he had led since his early parole in nineteen seventy, only this time he would be there to face the music for every judge and jury in front of him. William was hit with another life sentence, officially sealing his fate. He would remain behind bars for the rest of his life. He died in prison and Jackson, Georgia, in twenty twenty at the age of eighty eight, after serving nearly fifty years in prison. That is ten minute murder for today, brief and binge able true crime I'm Joe.
10:48 I'm the host, and thank you for taking the time to listen. If you're a brand new listener, subscribe wherever you like to listen to podcasts. If you're an OG listener, keep doing what you're doing. I love you because I know that you should hearing this podcast with your friends and family. And I know that because I can see the numbers. They continue to grow. The show continues to grow, and it has to be because of you listening that have been listening for a while are telling people about the podcast, and I really do love you for that. If you have any questions about the podcast, anything you want to know about, you can go to ten minute murder dot com. All the answers are there, or there you can find my email address, which is Joe at ten minute murder dot com. And some of you have emailed me asking if I've seen the new Menendez Brothers series on Netflix, and if I have, what I think about it, and I can tell you at the point I am right now that recording this podcast, I haven't seen all of it, but I've seen a good chunk of it, and I'll tell you that it's okay. It's not bad, it's not great, it's not terrible. It's all right to me. But there is one part of it where I had to pause it and then do some research because I was like, there's no way this is true.
11:54 This just seems like it's just made up for dramatic reasons for this series. I looked it up and it was absolutely true, and I'll tell you what it is. During the funeral scene when the brothers are playing the Milli Vanilli song, I thought, this is so weird and strange and looks like it's made for TV. It wasn't. It's real. They weren't making that part up, but it's so strange that it feels like they have to be, but they're not anyway. I will finish watching the series at some point, but I'm not canceling appointments to go and watch the series. It's not that good and that's going to do it. That is your episode for today. Thank you for listening to ten Minute Murder.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube