Listen to the latest episode now!
10 Minute Murder
10 Minute Murder
Bingeable True Crime Stories with Joe.
joe@10minutemurder.com
July 3, 2023

Yosemite Park Killer: Cary Stayner

Yosemite Park Killer: Cary Stayner
Yosemite Park Killer: Cary Stayner
10 Minute Murder
Yosemite Park Killer: Cary Stayner

When Cary Stayner was a child, his younger brother Steven was kidnapped by a child molester… a monster… and held captive. After 7 years he managed to escape. But when Cary grew up, he became a monster himself.

SUBSCRIBE to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you...

When Cary Stayner was a child, his younger brother Steven was kidnapped by a child molester… a monster… and held captive. After 7 years he managed to escape. But when Cary grew up, he became a monster himself.

SUBSCRIBE
to 10 Minute Murder.
Do you have friends that also like true crime stories? SHARE this podcast with them!
CONNECT on social media to know when new episodes are released and see visuals that go along with the episodes.

10minutemurder.com
email: joe@10minutemurder.com

HelloFresh FREE Shipping and 16 FREE Meals:
https://hellofresh.com/10minmurder16


Facebook:
https://facebook.com/10MMpodcast

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/10minutemurder/

TikTok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@10minutemurder

Twitter:
https://twitter.com/10minutemurder

Youtube:
https://youtube.com/channel/UCkJLUCEZlkn9In3AA46RVxw

Click Here for Merch:
https://www.teepublic.com/user/minute-murder



This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4603604/advertisement

0:01 Discretion is advised. This is treated murder. Murderers, rapists, and kidnappers often choose to shift blame away from themselves, pointing the finger at some kind of traumatic event that changed the course of their lives and made them turn towards crime. Detectives and criminal psychologists also examined the upbringing and history of killers, searching for anything that might have acted as a turning point molestation, abandonment, violence. But for one serial killer, his turning point was a little more unusual, the childhood kidnapping of his own younger brother. Carrie Stainer had three sisters but only one brother, Stephen, who was four years younger than Carrie.

0:58 When Stephen was seven years old, he disappeared. Although his family had no idea what happened to him, Stephen was being held captive less than forty miles away, kept in the house of the man who abducted him, a pedophile by the name of Kenneth Parnell. By the time seven years had passed, the chances of Stephen still being alive were slim to none. Even before Stephen went missing, Carrie had not been like the other kids. He'd always been anxious, developing trichotillomania as a toddler, which made him pull out his own hair. Despite medication, he continued to compulsively pluck the hair from his scalp, causing bald spots that the other kids made fun of him for later.

1:42 He reported having dark sexual fantasies from a very young age, imagining kidnapping, raping, and killing women, even before his own brother became the victim of the same kind of criminal. Stephen's abduction became the center of Carrie's teenage years. While his parents grieved, Stephen, their older son felt neglected and pushed aside. He was shockingly intelligent and creative, but none of his academic pursuits satisfied him. His dark fantasies got stronger and stronger in his teenage years, and he eventually acted on them by exposing his genitals to a friend of his sisters. Then, essentially a miracle took place. Stephen Steiner, who was now a teenager, managed to escape captivity alongside Timothy White, another kidnapped boy. He was an instant celebrity, even featuring in a TV series called I Know My First Name Is Stephen. Carrie felt like his family's forgotten child, the son that they didn't pay attention to. After his graduation, Carrie had gotten a job working at a glass company. He later said that while he was at work installing windows, he constantly fantasized about killing all of his co workers by crashing a truck into his workplace and then lighting it on fire.

3:00 During this time, tragedy struck the Stainer family again. After surviving seven years of sexual abuse in captivity, Stephen was in a fatal motorcycle crash. He'd only lived for ten years after his escape. In his early thirties, Carry tried to kill himself with carbon monoxide poisoning, but his suicide attempt failed. Four years later, he spent time in a mental health facility after having a breakdown, but after his symptoms got better, he was discharged. Carrie tried to self medicate, using drugs to distract himself. All they did was make him more and more unstable. In nineteen ninety seven, Carrie started work as a general handyman at the Cedar Lodge motel, close to one of the entrances to Yosemite National Park. The lodge soon became a hunting ground full of the kind of prey that he'd always fantasized about catching. Over a six month period in nineteen nine, four people connected to the motel were violently killed.

4:04 In February nineteen ninety nine, Carol Yvonne Sunned, her fifteen year old daughter Julie Sunned, and a sixteen year old exchange student, Sylvina Paloso, were staying at Cedar Lodge and went missing. Two of the bodies, Carol's and Sylvina's, were found almost a month later, crammed into the trunk of Carol's rental car. The car had been set on fire, and Carol and Sylvina's charred remains needed to be identified with dental records. Even with a degree of damage the fired caused to the bodies. The autopsy found that Sylvina had been raped while Carol had been strangled. Both victims had also been shot. One week after the two bodies were located, somebody sent a note to the local police, reading quote, we had fun with this one, with a sketch of a map drawn underneath. At the location indicated by the map, police found jewe's body. She had been sexually assaulted before having her throat cut.

5:04 Police carried out interviews of all the employees at the motel, but they didn't view Carrie as a suspect. Four months later, a headless body was found in the same area and later identified as twenty six year old Joey Ruth Armstrong, a naturalist who worked for the Yosemite Institute. Unlike the previous three victims, Joey had only been killed the previous day, making it easier for investigators to follow the trail of the killer. Eyewitnesses had seen Carrie's vehicle parked outside Joey's cabin the day before her body was found, but he was nowhere to be seen. The FBI was involved and track carried to a nudest resort where he was staying and rested him on suspicion of murder. During questioning, Carrie made an unusual choice. He immediately confessed to killing Joey, but told investigators that he had also murdered Carol, Julie and Sylphe and he had been the one to send the map of where Julie's body could be found. Now investigators had a man in custody who had openly admitted to four violent crimes.

6:09 It would be highly unusual for a man this violence and sadistic to only have started killing in his late thirties, and detectives began to examine other cases that Carrie could have been involved in when he was younger. Once they started looking, the clues were everywhere. At nineteen eighty one, a young woman named Patricia Dahlstrom had testified against a cult leader, Donald Gibson, who had sexually assaulted her. Donald was an acquaintance of Carrie. Carrie even went to his trial to support the man. Two years later, Patricia went missing in Yosemite National Park and her skeletal remains were found the following year. Had Carrie murdered Patricia as revenge for testifying against his friend? It definitely looks that way.

6:55 Another cold case, at nineteen ninety four, two severed hands were found in the Serra Nevada Foothills, followed by a decapitated handless body two months later. The following year, the remains were positively identified as a twenty four year old woman named Sherlyn Murphy. Her killer was never identified, and to this day, despite extensive searching, her missing head has not been found. Was it possible that Carrie also murdered male victims. Investigators considered the possibility that he had been also responsible for the disappearance of twenty year old Michael Madden, who had gone missing on his way to California's Stanislos National Forest. Yosemite National Park, where Carrie seemed to commit all of his crimes, was only seventy five miles away from there. There was also one potential victim who was closer to home, Carrie's uncle, Jesse Stainer, who had been shot to death in nineteen ninety. The murder weapon was Jesse's own gun, and the killer was never found. Later, Carrie claimed that his uncle had molested him when he was a little boy. Although he was never found guilty of killing his uncle, he had a connection with the victim as well as a possible motive for killing him. Because Joey Armstrong had been killed on federal land, Carrie went to trial in federal court. Desperate to avoid a death sentence, he decided to plead guilty to all the charges against him, a hefty list of first degree murder, kidnapping, and aggravated sexual abuse that had resulted in death. Despite

8:28 seemingly completely unbothered even proud during his confession, he showed a completely different reaction during his sentencing in front of the court, Carrie began sobbing, saying, quote, I wish I could tell you why I did such a thing, but I don't even know myself. I'm so sorry. I wish there was a reason, but there isn't. It's senseless. Carry avoided a death sentence, instead being sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. In state court. Facing charges for another three murders, Carrie changed his tactic and pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. While a doctor testified that Carrie had autism, OCD and abnormal sexual desires, as well as a potential history of sexual abuse, Carrie was found to be sane. He was found guilty a first degree murder of all three victims, as well as the kidnapping of one victim he'd remove from the scene. For these charges, Carrie was sentenced to death in two thousand and two. Since then, Carrie has been imprisoned on death row at California's San Quentin State Prison, but nobody has been executed in California since two thousand and six. The Stainer family lost their two boys, one a victim and one a perpetrator. Somehow, Carrie lived through the experience of his brother being abducted by a monster and then grew up to be a monster himself. That's ten Minute Murder for today, brief and binge able true

10:11 crime. I'm Joe the host, and thank you so much for listening today. And a group that I know is listening that I really appreciate is the Hammond fire Station in June seventy two out in California. They're og supporters of Ten Minute Murder, especially mister Albarez there. He suggested this story today that I did, along with one a while back that I covered Marcus Wesson, which was extremely interesting to research and very disturbing. One of the most difficult ones to cover that I've ever done. If you haven't listened to that one, go back. It's a very good one. So thanks to you all for what you're doing. I know it's a difficult job, so stay safe. Hey, if this is your first time listening to Ten Minute Murder, please subscribe now so that you can catch up on all the back episodes, never miss any of the new ones. Connect with me on social media.

10:56 See the visuals that we're talking about here in the podcast. Nothing gross and graphic. I wouldn't do that to you. And if you like this episode, please leave a rating and review on Apple or any place that's possible. Your positive feedback is appreciated. And if you're thinking maybe I'd like to send Joe a message or email, you can. You can DM me on social media slide into my dms, but not not like that, but you know what I mean. That's less reliable though, because you know how it goes on social media. You get bots and stuff I don't know who's real and who's fake, and then just the volume of them that I get. It's hard to I read them all, but it's hard to respond to all of them. So the easiest way to make sure my eyeballs get to your message is email Joe at ten minute Murder dot com. And that's it. Thanks for listening today or if you're onto the next episode, talk to you again soon