Join Joe's List! Get updates on new episodes, blogs, and more
When TikTok Beef Turns Deadly: The Durhams vs. The Lathams
Let’s be clear—this isn’t some medieval tale of knights defending family honor. It’s not epic. It’s not noble. It’s suburban South Jersey in 2020. The only armor involved was probably Carha…
A Name That Should Have Never Made Headlines
There’s a saying that nothing is ever black or white. That life exists in the gray, where nuance matters. And sure, if every single moment of someone’s life was put under a microscope, most people wouldn…
A Quiet Farm, a Troubled Home
In 1922, deep in the Bavarian countryside, nestled among rolling fields and medieval towns, was Hinterkaifeck—a small farming community where everyone knew everyone. And on one of its remote farms lived the Gruber fami…
The Illusion of Respectability
In 1980s Manchester, James Smith looked like the kind of man who had his life together. Middle-aged, well-groomed, and with an almost obsessive dedication to keeping his home spotless, he stood out—especially among hi…
Tucker Reed: Born Into a Storybook Life
Tucker Reed didn’t just grow up around stories—she was one. The eldest daughter of New York Times best-selling authors Daniel Reed and Kelly Moore, she was practically written into existence. Her parents had …
The Swinging Sixties and the Illusion of Peace
The 1960s came with a promise—or at least, that’s what the idealists believed. Across America, young people draped themselves in the language of love and peace, convinced that a little flower power and…
Tsutomu Miyazaki: An Isolated Beginning
Tsutomu Miyazaki came into the world already marked as different. Born in Tokyo in the 1960s, he had a rare birth defect that fused the bones in his wrists together, preventing him from bending them upward. I…
A Child Born to Disappointment
In October 1946, in Clarksburg, West Virginia, William Crutchley and Mildred Burnside welcomed a new baby into the world. But this wasn’t just any birth—it was supposed to be a do-over. A cosmic correction to the trag…
A Normal Day Turns into a Nightmare
On May 6, 2023, a man dressed head-to-toe in black pulled up to an outlet mall in Allen, Texas. No hesitation, no buildup—just cold, deliberate action. The second his foot hit the pavement, he raised his gun and …
It has been over a decade, and people still can’t believe she walked free.
One of the jurors in the Casey Anthony trial summed it up best when he turned to his fellow jurors and said, “Holy crap, we are letting her go free.”
It was July 5, 2011, w…
Some crimes are so disturbing, so completely unhinged, that trying to make sense of them is a waste of time. This is one of those cases.
In December 2016, Manuel Vela murdered his pregnant girlfriend, cut the baby from her body, and then led police…
February 14, 2018. A day that should have been filled with flowers, candy, and teenage romance turned into a nightmare that left 17 people dead, 17 others wounded, and an entire country questioning—again—why this keeps happening.
The shooting at Ma…
In the quiet, tree-lined suburb of Cedar Mill, Oregon, Dickson and Arlene Janowski lived what appeared to be a comfortable, private life. Their split-level home sat far from the road, nestled behind thick shrubs, offering the kind of seclusion that …
The Wild West of the Internet: Where Tupperware and Terror Coexisted
There was a time—not too long ago—when the internet was a mysterious and futuristic concept, like flying cars or robot butlers that actually worked. Most people hadn’t even logged…
The Night Paramedics Found Gabriel Fernandez
A Call for Help in Palmdale
On the night of May 22, 2013, paramedics in Palmdale, California, were dispatched to what they were initially told was a medical emergency involving an eight-year-old boy who…
Herbert Baumeister: The Man Who Buried His Secrets
The House That Knew Too Much
There’s a certain kind of house that just looks like it’s hiding something. You know the type—overgrown weeds, windows dark like empty eye sockets, the kind of place t…
A Life Built on Determination: The Story of Amie Harwick
February 2020: A Desperate Fight for Survival
Hollywood is known for its bright lights and red carpets, but on one February night in 2020, the focus wasn’t on a star-studded event—it was on …
The Rise of Truckee’s Chinatown: A Community Built on Railroad Tracks
1868: The Railroad That Changed Everything
By 1868, railroad construction had climbed its way into the unforgiving terrain of Donner Pass, California. Laying those steel tracks …
The Making of a Killer: Dylann Roof’s Path to Violence
“Well, someone has to have the bravery to take it to the real world, and I guess that has to be me.”
At first glance, it sounds like something you’d find on an inspirational poster—maybe next …
A Night Out in Denver: The Start of a Tragic Story
March 31st, 2011, was just another busy evening in downtown Denver. The city hummed with the energy of nightlife—clubs overflowing, streets bustling, and drinks flowing a little too freely. Outside…
The Dark Roots of Keith Jesperson’s Childhood
In the 1950s, Selah, Washington, wasn’t just a small, picturesque town—it was a battleground for young Keith Jesperson. Towering over his peers and burdened with a quiet, shy demeanor, Keith was caught …
The Morning Routine That Defied Death
For Peter Porco, November 15, 2004, wasn’t supposed to be memorable. It was just another Monday, the kind of day you coast through without a second thought. The 52-year-old court clerk in Delmar, New York, star…
A Late-Night Bong Hit and a Cryptic Confession
It was 2001, and Lloyd Avery II sat in the family garage with his younger brother, Che. Lloyd passed the bong across the dimly lit space, and Che took a hit that nearly floored him.
“I’ve had a good l…
The Unlikely Beginnings of Theodore Coneys: A Life Shaped by Illness and Isolation
Most of us stand at our refrigerators, pondering snacks or leftovers, blissfully unaware that such a mundane moment could mark the end of a life. But for one man in …