Join Joe's List! Get updates on new episodes, blogs, and more
A Camping Trip in Gitchie Manitou Takes a Deadly Turn
In 1973, five teenagers headed into the serene woods of Gitchie Manitou State Preserve in Iowa for a night of campfire fun. Among them were Roger Essam, 17; Stewart Baade, 18; his younger brothe…
The Mysterious Death of Cindy James: A Decade of Fear Ends in Tragedy
On June 8, 1989, a disturbing discovery was made in the backyard of an abandoned house in Richmond, Canada. Cindy James was found hogtied, drugged, and strangled with a black nyl…
A Quiet Romance: The Love Story of Teri Helfrich and Charles Brandt
In 1986, Teri Helfrich found what many spend a lifetime searching for—a love that felt like home. Teri was the kind of person who lit up every room she entered. A free spirit with …
A Killer’s Beginnings: The Early Life of Peter Sutcliffe
“Bastard prostitutes who were littering the streets. I was just cleaning up the place a bit.” Those were the words of a man whose reign of terror gripped the UK for five years—the Yorkshire R…
The Curious Transformation of Manuela Bartel: From Model Student to Chaos Incarnate
Manuela Bartel was the kind of kid who made parents breathe a sigh of relief—polite, hardworking, and bright. Growing up in 1980s and 1990s Germany, her life follow…
Augusta Gein: Tyrant, Preacher, and Queen of Condemnation
Augusta Wilhelmine Gein ruled her household like a fire-and-brimstone despot, her reign extending over a remote Plainfield, Wisconsin farm where she kept a firm grip on her two sons, Henry a…
A Killer’s Checklist: Errands with a Dark Purpose
“Get killing knives, get sledgehammer, bring food grinder, get bleach…”
Sounds like the twisted to-do list of a Hollywood villain, right? Except this isn’t fiction. This is a verbatim excerpt from …
Henry Lee Lucas: A Grim Beginning in Blacksburg, Virginia
“I killed ’em every way there is except poison. Strangulations, knifings, shootings, hit-and-runs… I had no feelings for the people themselves… It was just, like I say, as though I left my b…
Bloodlines of Chaos: The Troubled Origin of Richard Chase
When it comes to true crime, some cases read like poorly thought-out fiction—implausible, grotesque, and baffling. Then there’s Richard Chase, whose life was a parade of warning signs ignore…
The Making of a Monster: Daniel LaPlante’s Early Years
A loner. A creep. A childhood soaked in neglect and streaked with a steady parade of run-ins with the law. Some stories seem almost engineered to remind us why certain stereotypes exist. And th…
The Disappearance of Maura Murray: True Crime’s Most Baffling Mystery
What would drive a seemingly normal college student to pack up her belongings, crash her car on a remote and snowy New Hampshire road, and vanish into thin air? That’s the questi…
The Typical Courtroom Playbook (And a Surprise Third Option)
When a case heads to court, the script usually follows one of two familiar paths. First, the defendant might plead guilty, which speeds things up by skipping straight to the sentencing ph…
The West Memphis Three: Convicted for Being “Weird”?
The story of the West Memphis Three isn’t just a true crime case; it’s a cautionary tale about how badly things can go when fear and bias overtake reason. What if three teenagers didn’t brutally …
The Crime That Shook West Memphis: 1993
In 1993, West Memphis, Arkansas, was the kind of place where people left their doors unlocked and kids rode their bikes until dinner. That peace shattered when the bodies of three eight-year-old boys—Stevie B…
The Shocking Rise and Mysterious Fall of Natalie Wood
A Love Story on Screen, a Tragedy Off It“One hand, one heart, even death won’t part us now.” Those dreamy lyrics from West Side Story sound like a promise, don’t they? A vow of undying love betw…
The Baton Rouge Killer Wasn’t Alone
On May 27, 2003, Derrick Todd Lee, the Baton Rouge Killer, was finally in cuffs. Cue the collective sigh of relief from Baton Rouge. The boogeyman was behind bars, and surely, the nightmare was over. Case closed,…
A Chilling Day in Delphi: The Last Moments of Libby and Abby
On an unseasonably warm February afternoon in 2017, best friends Liberty “Libby” German and Abigail “Abby” Williams set out to explore the Monon High Bridge Trail in Delphi, Indiana. It w…
Who Was Brian Wells?
Brian Douglas Wells was, by all accounts, the human equivalent of a reliable clock. Forty-six years old, a pizza delivery man with a decade-long tenure at the same pizzeria, and a guy who didn’t just show up—he always showed up…
Netflix’s Cold Case: Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey Dives into the Unsolved Mystery
The Netflix docuseries Cold Case: Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey takes a deep dive into the chilling and endlessly frustrating investigation surrounding the 1996 murder …
The Unlikely Defense: A Killer in Court
It’s one thing to represent yourself in court; it’s another to represent yourself in court and treat it like an open mic night where the goal is to air every grievance, implicate half your contact list, and s…
Mark Twitchell: The Dexter Wannabe Who Took Method Acting Way Too Far
Mark Twitchell fancied himself a visionary, the kind of filmmaker who wasn’t afraid to explore the darker corners of human nature. The problem was, he didn’t stop at storytelling…
Introduction to the Green River Killer: Gary Ridgway’s Dark Legacy
The First Victim: Wendy Lee Coffield and the Beginning of a Nightmare
Picture this: It’s 1982, and the serene waters of Seattle’s Green River are about to become the backdrop for o…
The Chilling Beginnings of Amy Archer-Gilligan
In the suffocating heat of a Connecticut summer in 1916, a determined woman sat across a desk from a man she hoped could deliver justice. Nellie Pierce clutched a worn envelope, her brother’s name scra…
A Not-So-Classic Family Beginning
Florida, 1958. George Waterfield Russell Sr. and his wife, Joyce, had their first child, George Russell Jr., and, on paper, it probably looked like a classic, happy family was in the making. But reality had other p…