Burlap and Blueprints: Rex Heuermann and the Gilgo Beach Murders
Burlap and Blueprints: Rex Heuermann and the Gilgo Beach Murders In April 2026, Rex Andrew Heuermann pleaded guilty to the murders of at least eight women in one of the most devastating serial homicide cases in Long Island history, after a...
Burlap and Blueprints: Rex Heuermann and the Gilgo Beach Murders
In April 2026, Rex Andrew Heuermann pleaded guilty to the murders of at least eight women in one of the most devastating serial homicide cases in Long Island history, after a decades-long investigation by the Suffolk County Police Department and the Gilgo Beach Homicide Task Force broke the case through forensic DNA evidence, surveillance, and genetic genealogy. Victims including Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello disappeared between 1993 and 2010 along New York's South Shore, with some remains found wrapped in burlap near Ocean Parkway.He was an architect. He designed buildings for a living. He had a wife, two kids, and a house in the suburbs where he grew up. And on a hard drive in the basement of that house, there was a Word document with sections labeled "Supplies," "Body Prep," and "Things to Remember." This is the story of how Rex Heuermann hid in plain sight for over thirty years, how corruption inside the very police department supposed to stop him helped him do it longer than anyone wants to admit, and how a discarded pizza crust in a Manhattan trash can undid everything he thought he'd built.
🔔 Subscribe for True Crime Cases multiple times a week
Never miss a story. Subscribe to 10 Minute Murder for bite-sized true crime episodes delivered fresh every week.
Get a weekly email from me about the upcoming cases and more: 10minutemurder.com/newsletter
📱 Follow for Behind-the-Scenes Content Get exclusive case updates, research photos, and sneak peeks of upcoming episodes:
- Instagram: @10minutemurder on IG
- Facebook: 10 Minute Murder on FB
- TikTok: 10 Minute Murder on TikTok
- Rate & Review: Leave a 5-star review to help other true crime fans discover the show
- Share: Send this episode to fellow true crime enthusiasts
- Join the Discussion: Tag us in your episode reactions on social media
Check out True Crime Blueprint, also created and hosted by Joe.
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/43zuDpH01HtdIrH0ShCAid?si=86b2281063334139
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/true-crime-blueprint/id1877878404
iHeartRadio: https://iheart.com/podcast/323307878
Amazon Music/Audible: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/b7d5eaae-9d27-40f9-8efb-6864c2af8055
Deezer: https://www.deezer.com/show/1002664071
Podcast Addict: https://podcastaddict.com/podcast/true-crime-blueprint/6785639
Podchaser: https://www.podchaser.com/podcasts/true-crime-blueprint-6381660
Spreaker: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-blueprint--6879387
Stitcher: https://www.stitcher.com/show/1113943
Pandora: https://www.pandora.com/podcast/true-crime-blueprint/PC:1001113943
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/10-minute-murder-bingeable-true-crime-stories--4603604/support.
0:00 He had a word document on a hard drive in his basement. It had sections labeled "targets, supplies, body prep, and things to remember." Under things to remember, he had written "use heavier rope and don't charge gas." He was an architect by trade, a husband and a father. Yet a house in the suburbs where he grew up. And for at least 30 years, he was also a serial killer operating out of Long Island. This is Rex Heurman and the Gilgo Beach Murders. [Music] There was a house on 1st Avenue and Massa Pequopark, Long Island, that Rex Heurman lived in for nearly his entire life.
0:57 He grew up there as a kid, bought it from his mother in 1994, and raised his own family inside it. Neighbors thought it was a bit spooky looking, always slightly rundown looking, the sort of house where kids dare each other to go ring the doorbell. The man who lived there was, by all outward appearances, just a large, somewhat disheveled architect, who commuted to Midtown Manhattan and mostly kept to himself. He ran his own firm, R.H. Consultants and Associates, built a professional reputation over the decades, had a wife, two kids, and a personality that co-workers described as socially awkward but professionally competent. In the way suburban Long Island produces people who are just quietly there, occupying space without much ceremony, Rex Heurman seemed thoroughly unremarkable, other than his size.
1:47 He was also, as of April 2026, confirmed a serial killer, who had been operating out of that house since at least 1993. Rex Andrew Heurman was born September 13, 1963, Long Island South Shore in the early '60s ran on post-war suburban aspiration. A place where you kept the lawn trimmed, you kept the front door painted, and projected normalcy outward without asking too many questions about what was behind it. His father, Theodore, was a World War II veteran, a former Air Force second lieutenant in Aerospace Engineer and a Cabinet Maker. That blend of technical precision and physical craft left a mark, pulling Rex toward architecture, a field that required the same synthesis of abstract spatial planning and hands-on execution.
2:35 Theodore died in 1975 when Rex was 11 or 12. His mother Dolores ran the household after that, and neighbors described her as "very controlling". Classmates at Berner High School remembered Rex's towering, quiet, intelligent, and a consistent target for bullying. The actor William Baldwin recalled him as "largely on the margins", which, right, is exactly where you want to be if you're the biggest person in the room and somehow invisible to most of it. He earned his architecture degree from New York Institute of Technology, became very good at designing structures and even better at constructing facades. By the mid-90s, the surface-level narrative was tidy.
3:15 He bought the house from his mother, started the firm, married a Swedish woman named Assa Ellarup in 1996, at two children, an ordinary, long-eiling commuter life with nothing about it to suggest otherwise. Sandra Castilla was 28 years old when she was killed in November of 1993. Her remains were found in North Sea, New York. Hureman admitted to her murder as part of his April 2026 guilty plea. Valerie Mack followed in 2000. Her remains scattered between the Manorville Woods and Cedar Beach at Gilgo. Jessica Taylor disappeared in 2003 and was also dismembered. Her remains found in two separate locations, years, and miles apart.
3:57 The gaps between these crimes stretched from months to years. He was patient, and with each one, he was getting better at this. Forensic investigators later recovered a word document from a hard drive in his basement. It read like an internal project brief, with sections for targets, dump sites, supplies, body prep, and a section called Things to Remember. Under supplies, he listed burlap, acid, police scanners, and booties. Under Things to Remember, use heavier rope and don't charge gas. The top entry under problems was DNA. He was designing his crimes around the forensic science that might eventually catch him, updating his approach between the killings, the way any professional revises their plan, after a bad sight inspection.
4:43 Between 2007 and 2010, four more women disappeared from the South Shore. Marine-Branored Barnes, a mother of two facing a viction, who was fighting to keep her family in their home, Melissa Barthellamy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Castillo. All four were petite and in their 20s. All four were found wrapped in camouflage burlap, along Ocean Parkway near Gilgo Beach in December 2010. When a police dog on a completely unrelated missing person search, wandered off its assigned path and stumbled across Marines' remains. A dog, following its nose, found what years of investigative work had not. After Melissa Barthellamy disappeared, someone began calling her teenage sister from Melissa's own phone.
5:27 The calls were extended, taunting, and sadistic. Investigators believed that caller was Rex. Whatever he got from the crimes themselves apparently was not enough. He wanted to reach out to the people who loved these women the most and keep the damage going. In 2010, a witness placed a very tall man in a green Chevy Avalanche near one of the victim's dump sites. That description was documented and filed. In 2012, a federal report used cell tower data to conclude the Gilgo Killer likely lived in Massa Pequot Park and worked in Midtown Manhattan. That report was delivered to the Suffolk County Police Department and was effectively ignored.
6:08 Standard cell tower analysis that could have linked to your men to his burner phones, to his personal devices, was never performed. Investigators had a working profile of their suspect in their own files and walked right past it for over a decade. The reason for all of that is James Burke. Burke became Suffolk County Police Chief in 2012 and moved quickly to Consolidate Power, removing veteran detectives who had found the Gilgo Beach 4 and held the most institutional knowledge of the case. He blocked his department from sharing information with the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit, the specialist trained to build criminal profiles in exactly these situations. He stated justification and departmental pride.
6:51 His actual motivation was keeping the FBI away from himself personally. Burke had his own complicated history with sex workers and an FBI investigation circling the Gilgo murders was a situation that he could not afford. Then, in 2012, a man named Christopher Loeb stole a bag from Burke's personal SUV. Inside the bag were a sex toys and pornography. Burke then had Loeb assaulted in custody and then organized a cover-up that consumed the SCP-D's senior leadership for years. Burke was eventually convicted of federal civil rights violations any serve time. The Gilgo Beach investigation sat dormant through all of that. One man's need to conceal his own behavior gave a serial killer extra years he never should have had.
7:35 In February 2022, new Commissioner Rodney Harrison formed the Gilgo Beach homicide task force. They went back to the 2010 Chevy Avalanche witness description cross-referenced it with vehicle registrations and mass-a-pequel park and Rex Heurman surfaced almost immediately. Investigators began surveillance, watching him admittance to prepaid burner phones and then use those phones to contact sex workers. Analysis of his email accounts turned up thousands of searches for the Gilgo investigation, the victim's families, and also violent pornography. He'd been following coverage of the search for himself in real time. He thought he was still ahead of them. In January 2023, investigators followed Heurman to his Manhattan office at lunchtime.
8:20 He ate pizza and he tossed the crust into a street trash can and went back inside. They retrieved it. DNA from that crust matched a male hair recovered from Meghan Waterman's remains. DNA from trash outside the Rex Heurman home matched hairs found on three other victims, too, his wife, Assa Ellerup, who had no involvement in the crimes. What that evidence established was that those women had been inside of that house and first avenue in the basement and what Heurman would later call his "kill room". He was arrested in July 2023. In April of 2026, Rex Heurman pleaded guilty. Before the public allocation, he met privately with his family, setting the terms of his own confession with the same careful deliberateness that he brought to everything else.
9:07 He described four-day rituals surrounding each murder. Stopwatch time-body disposals. Windows calculated for when his wife and children were out of the state. He'd been doing this since 1993 across 30 years and eight victims. Maureen, Melissa, Megan, Amber, Sandra, Valerie, Jessica, and Karen. They were real women with families who spent years waiting for answers, treated by institutions as people whose disappearances didn't quite warrant the same urgency as someone else's. New York State has since passed the Sex Worker Immunity Act, the Survivor's First Act, and broader reforms of how law enforcement handles missing and murdered women, particularly women of color.
9:50 Those eight names are attached to actual changes in the law. Rex Heurman built a lot of things across 30 years, a career, a reputation, a domestic facade convincing enough that his own wife never saw what was behind it. The last thing he built was a confession, and it arrived three decades too late. [Music] Thanks for listening to 10 Minute Murder, Bingeable True Crime Stories. I'm Joe, hello. I'm the host, and here's an email.
10:32 Subject, your consistency is underrated. Hey, Joe, I was thinking the other day about how rare it is for a podcast to stay consistent over time. A lot of shows start strong and then slowly turn to inside jokes and rambling. Yours still feels focused and intentional, which is probably why I've stuck around so long. Random question though, do you ever take a full break from listening to podcasts or are you always consuming something in the background? Rachel and Carrie North Carolina. Rachel, thank you for listening for so long, and also thank you for reaching out. And to answer your question, yeah, I'm always, I'm almost always listening to something in the background, or I'm researching something for the podcast. In the background, not always podcasts, but currently I'm trying to work my way through the stand by Stephen King, and it's a full-blown marathon.
11:18 It's very long, but it's also really good. So it's not always true crime-related stuff that I've got going on in my life. I used to listen to a lot of podcasts before I started doing my own, and I cut way back on that because I needed that time to research for this podcast, as well as my newer podcast True Crime Blueprint, which by the way, my ADHD brain wants to remind you that if you thought today's episode was interesting, there's a longer version of the Go Go Beach murders on True Crime Blueprint. It's out right now, and you can go listen to it right now. Whereas this one is 10 minutes talking about this case, that one on True Crime Blueprint is like 30 minutes talking about this case. I go into a lot more detail about everything surrounding it, and everything that went on with the case, and specifically, more about what went on with Sheriff Burke.
12:04 Alright, if you're a new listener to the podcast, welcome. Make sure you put your feet up, get comfortable, because there are literally hundreds of back episodes for you to catch up on, and more importantly, make sure you hit subscribe to 10 Minute Murder. You can also go to 10minuteMurder.com. There you'll find, listen, links to, listen, and different places. Also, links to where you can find me on social media. That's at 10minuteMurder.com. And that's going to do it. That's your episode for today. Thank you for listening to 10 Minute Murder. See you next time.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
Pandora
Amazon Music
Podchaser
Spreaker
RSS Feed
Audible
Castbox
iHeartRadio
Castro
Deezer
YouTube